Patent No. 5227874 Method for measuring the effectiveness of stimuli on decisions of shoppers
Patent No. 5227874
Method for measuring the effectiveness of stimuli on decisions of shoppers (VonKohorn, Jul 13, 1993)
Abstract
Methods for the evaluation of stimuli such as broadcast commercials intended to promote purchases by shoppers are disclosed. The methods quantify the effectiveness of controlled variables of stimuli and of inducements associated therewith. The immediate impact and degree of erosion of the impact of stimuli on families and on individual household members are measured. Inducements can take the form of printouts, such as monetary coupons, dispensed in homes of broadcast audience members who have responded to a task. The system and method for evaluating responses to broadcast or telephone programs, such as television programs, includes an instructional signal, such as a signal modulated onto a signal transmitted concurrently with the television program, or time-multiplexed therewith. At each of a plurality of remote receiving stations, one or more members of an audience has the opportunity to respond to a situation presented in the program by entering a response or a selection on a keyboard. The system includes at each remote receiving station a memory responsive to the instructional signal for storing acceptable responses, and a comparison circuit for comparing responses entered at the keyboard with those stored in the memory. Also provided is electronic circuitry for scoring the responses in accordance with commands from the instructional signal, and a recording device for providing a permanent record. A prize-winning respondent can select a product from a listing and apply the value of a prize to the purchase price of the selected product.
Notes:
BACKGROUND
OF THE INVENTION
This invention relates to the measuring of the impact of stimuli on individuals
and, more particularly to evaluating the short term and long term effectiveness
of broadcast and print stimuli under varying circumstances.
Market researchers currently make great efforts to improve the degree of accuracy
and validity of results that measure the impact and lasting effect of isolated
and combined purchase stimuli such as television and radio commercials, as well
as print advertisements. Yet, no method or system for achieving these objectives
has been available. A particularly important target area of market research
has been the assessment and evaluation of the continuing effectiveness of advertising
and sales promotions presented to a shopper before the shopper enters a retail
store, as affected by various types of in-store promotions and point-of-purchase
advertising.
Also, heretofore, there has been no technique available to market researchers
to quantitatively measure on an individual or on a household basis the effect
of variables affecting promotions, such as frequency and timing of stimuli,
shopping inducements and their effect on different population segments.
It therefore is an object of the present invention to quantify the initial impact
and the continuing effectiveness of advertising on shoppers with respect to
an identified advertisement in terms of the purchase of the advertised product.
It is another object to measure the magnitude of sales which are lost and are
excluded from a shopper's intended purchases. Most of these purchases are directed
to a different product as a consequence of in-store advertising and the promotion
of product competitive with the product initially selected for purchase by said
shopper based on the immediate impact of the advertisement.
It is another object of the invention to quantify the impact on shoppers of
a number of controlled variables of an advertising or promotional campaign,
individually or in combination.
Manufacturers of packaged consumer goods sold in supermarkets sometimes find
it difficult to obtain market data from these supermarkets. Yet, such manufacturers
who are large advertisers are anxious to obtain as much feedback as possible
giving them reliable information not only with respect to the overall redemption
of coupons, but broken down by households or, ideally, by individual family
members. Such information would be of utmost value to all advertisers in that,
once the buying habit or pattern of an individual household is known, marketing
efforts can be focused on individual shoppers or families and the mailing cost
and other expenses of indiscriminate direct mailings can be avoided. A typical
example would be an elderly couple for which the said cumulative record would
indicate no babyfood purchase and would obviate corresponding coupon mailings.
The above objectives are attained by the invention by compiling a cumulative
record as described in a form that lends itself to direct communication between
families and manufacturers without requiring efforts or expenses by retailers.
The methods of the invention utilize shoppers' implementations of individual
personal buying decisions, as evidenced by requested discount coupons, in the
quantitative measurement of a shopper's buying behavior. At the same time, shoppers'
buying decisions are used as yardsticks in the evaluation of the effectiveness
of discrete functions of purchase stimuli.
All coupons, by their numbers or other identifications, can be traced to the
household having requested them. This makes it possible to compare the coupons
requested and redeemed with the coupons requested and not redeemed by individual
families or shopping units. The method also permits an evaluation of each individual
stimulus or advertisement household by household.
It may not be necessary to provide for all of these indications by shoppers
on a nationwide scale, as market research on a more limited scale will yield
data essential with respect to some marketing aspects, such as product development,
packaging and overall advertising. In other respects, however, household by
household data and purchasing behavior are valuable, such as in respect to direct
mailings. These and other benefits of the invention are described herein.
SUMMARY
OF THE INVENTION
These and other objects quantifying the effects of advertising and promotional
activities are achieved by the invention.
In practicing the invention, the systems described in the above identified patents
and patent applications are used. Persons exposed to the stimulus of a television,
radio or printed advertisement or other promotion are given an opportunity to
respond to a task, such as the selection of an advertised product or to provide
an answer to a question. Following a response, such persons receive a token
having value, such as a coupon carrying a discount on the product featured in
the advertisement. In the case of a correct answer to a question, a shopper's
response is entered in a programmed response unit, which evaluates and scores
the response and which prints a discount coupon specifying the advertised product.
The response unit is programmed by electronic instructional signals which convey
acceptable responses and the value of awards won by successful respondents.
Each broadcast or print advertisement can be identified by a reference element,
such as alphanumeric data and/or by the time of its appearance. Thus a shopper
in the process of selecting a product and receiving a prize coupon identifies
the stimulus that brought about the selection and buying decision.
In another version of the above method, a shopper need not respond to a question,
but makes a product selection and requests the printing and dispensing of a
coupon carrying a discount on the chosen advertised product by entering an appropriate
request in the entering device of a response unit.
The response units at individual shoppers' locations have means for dispensing
individual coupons following a response and for compiling a cumulative record
of products for which the shopper has requested or selected discount coupons.
Such a cumulative record can take the form of a tape intermittently printed
as coupons are requested. Whereas the coupons are dispensed individually when
printed as described in connection with the drawings, the tape matrix having
the cumulative coupon data printed thereon is temporarily retained in the response
unit in the form of a tape.
It is removed and replaced the way the tapes of known calculators are retained
until fully used, at which time they are replaced.
In the event a shopper uses, i.e. redeems all of the coupons requested by purchasing
the specified product, the total number of products thus purchased will equal
the number of products listed on the cumulative record compiled by the response
unit of that shopper.
If, however, a shopper changes his or her mind following receipt of a coupon
reading on a specified product and if said shopper purchases a competitor's
product instead, or purchases no product, the total of presented coupons will
be less than the total of products shown on said cumulative record, which reflects
a shopper's original intention. The difference between these two sets of data
represents the loss of sales due to a change of heart by a shopper following
the time of exposure to the identified stimulus.
By identifying on each coupon the wanted product, the stimulus responsible for
the initial buying decision and the member of a household, the method generates
a person-by-person behavior pattern and reaction to discrete stimuli and to
controlled variations thereof.
While the methods of the invention are applicable to all forms of stimuli, including
stimuli to induce acts other than purchases, such as survey responses, the descriptions
that follow focus primarily on purchase promotions and are intended to be only
illustrative.
The methods of the invention permit the heretofore unattainable statistical
analysis of a great many factors that have an impact on the buying behavior
of shoppers. The advance in the statistical measurement of intangible factors
such as the combination effect of stimuli or their timing and the increase or
decrease in the monetary value of purchase incentives as reflected by the buying
behavior of individual shoppers, is made possible by the methods of the invention
which induce shoppers to avail themselves of monetary incentives in the form
of shopper-selected, product-specific discount coupons and similar hard copy
records; said inducements being promoted by the stimuli whose impact is to be
quantified under controlled varied conditions.
The present method permits generating the buying pattern not only of a household
but of the individuals comprising said household, including children. To identify
each individual and in view of the fact that each household is associated with
an identified response unit, the additional identification for each member of
the household can be a very simple one, such as a one-digit number or initial.
Children will have no problem entering their personal identification symbol
when making a product selection.
The described methods thus add to present market research tools the capability
of statistically measuring the effectiveness of the discrete purchase behavior
of an individual consumer.
DETAILED
DESCRIPTION
In the following description, FIGS. 1-5 disclose embodiments of the invention
useful for programs to be conducted with participation from remote audiences.
In the disclosure of FIGS. 6-10, the system is adapted for a greater selection
of, and modification of, parameters in criteria for evaluating answers to questions.
The criteria are controllable from a central station. A level of difficulty
in the questions may be selected by a contestant. The embodiment of the system
of FIGS. 1-5 is described in terms of two signal groups, namely, a radio/television
signal group, Group One, and an instructional signal group, Group Two. The embodiment
of the system of FIGS. 6-10 is described with reference to at least four types
of signals, namely, a television signal presenting a studio scene (TV program),
a television signal presenting a task such as a set of questions (task signal),
a signal setting forth acceptable answers to questions (response criteria),
and a signal setting forth criteria to be employed in the evaluation of the
answers (scoring mode). In FIGS. 11-22, there is shown a set of embodiments
of the invention wherein an event, scenario, presentation, situation or other
scene having a task to be performed is recorded for subsequent playback to respondents.
The system of FIGS. 1-5 will be described first, this being followed by a description
of the system of FIGS. 6-10 and the system of FIGS. 11-23. The systems of the
various embodiments will now be described primarily in the context of responses
to tasks and questions; it being understood that the practice of the invention
is applicable to the making, evaluation and rewarding of predictions. Methods
and systems employed in the context of predictions of the outcome of events
are more particularly described in connection with FIGS. 22 and 24.
FIG. 1 presents a simplified description of a system 10 wherein a central station
12 includes a studio 14, such as a television studio which broadcasts programs
to many external or remote receiving stations, two such receiving stations 16
and 18 being shown by way of example. In accordance with the invention, each
of the receiving stations 16 and 18 includes means for observing the broadcast
program, such as a television screen 20, and means by which persons in the external
viewing audience can respond to situations presented in the studio, the response
means being a response unit 22 which evaluates and records responses entered
by persons in the viewing audience.
Two signals are broadcast by the central station 12 to each of the receiving
stations 16 and 18. One of these two signals is a program signal for presenting
on the television screen 20 a program generated in the studio 14. The second
of the two signals is an instructional or command signal for operation of the
response unit 22, the instructional signal providing appropriate commands to
the response unit 22 for evaluating, rejecting or accepting, and scoring audience
responses to questions raised in the televised program.
Two modes of transmission are provided for the two signals. In the case of the
receiving station 18, both of the signals are carried by a single television
channel carrier radiated from an antenna 24 of the central station 22, and received
by an antenna 26 at the receiving station 18. The antenna 26 connects with a
television system 28 which includes the foregoing television screen 20 and,
furthermore, includes circuitry 30 for the separation of the instructional signal
from the program signal. The instructional signal is then applied via line 32
to the response unit 22. In the case of the receiving station 16, the two signals
are processed separately. The instructional signal is broadcast by a radio channel
employing a radio antenna 34 at the central station 12, and received by an antenna
36 at the receiving station 16. Thus, at the receiving station 16, a standard
television set 38 including the screen 20 receives the televised program via
antenna 26 and presents the program on the screen 20. A separate radio receiver
40 and demodulator 42 are employed for receiving the instructional signal and
for applying the instructional signal to the response unit 22.
In the practice of the invention, the instructional signal may be transmitted
to a remote receiving station in any convenient manner such as via a cable transmission
or by a specially broadcast transmission (not shown) or by combining the instructional
signal with the audio signal in a radio broadcast or television broadcast. The
combination of the instructional signal with the audio spectrum is demonstrated
in the graph of FIG. 2 which shows a typical relationship of amplitude versus
frequency in a transmitted audio spectrum. In that spectrum, a relatively narrow
frequency band is set aside for transmission of the instructional signal, the
narrow frequency band being at the upper frequency edge of the audio spectrum.
For example, the bandwidth of the instructional signal may be approximately
1% of the audio bandwidth, this being sufficient to enable a relatively slow
transmission of instructional data to the response units 22 in the respective
receiving stations. By maintaining the amplitude of the instructional signal
well below that of the audio signal, the instructional signal does not introduce
more than a negligible amount of interference with the audio signal. Also, it
is noted that the instructional signal is not continuously present but, rather,
appears only for a momentary burst of time, typically less than a few seconds
duration, when necessary to instruct each response unit 22. In the case of the
receiving station 16, a simulcast of radio and television is employed while,
in the case of the receiving station 18, only the television program is broadcast,
as has been described above. However, in both cases, the audio spectrum is the
same, and the mode of combining the instructional signal with the audio transmission
is the same. Typically, the system 10 would be implemented with only one of
the transmissions, either the television transmission with the instructional
signal combined therewith, as demonstrated by the receiving station 18, or by
the simulcast of both the television and the radio transmissions as demonstrated
by the receiving station 16. In the case of the simulcast, the instructional
signal need not be combined with the television signal, the instructional signal
appearing only in the radio broadcast from the antenna 34 as described above.
The receiver 40 and the demodulator 42 operate in a manner similar to that of
the separation circuitry 30, and will be described in detail hereinafter, with
reference to FIG. 3.
In both of the receiving stations 16 and 18, the response unit 22 includes a
keyboard 44 whereby a person in the remote viewing audience enters a response.
The response unit 22 includes a dispenser 46 which dispenses a record of the
score and/or responses in a permanent recording medium such as a card 48 of
plastic, or similar material, and including a well-known strip of magnetizable
material (not shown) upon which the score and/or responses have been recorded.
Alternatively, by way of example, the dispenser 46 may be constructed in a form
(not shown) for outputting a tape which has been imprinted or punched with the
desired information. Easily recognizable indicia may also be imprinted on the
tape or card.
The system described lends itself well to multi-part questions and/or to multiple
choice answers, for any of which special forms can be provided, to be filled
in or otherwise marked. The response recording and/or data entering means can
have provisions for the insertion of special forms or blanks, which can be made
available or mailed to participants. For example, a school may mail to students
forms specially prepared for a particular examination or assignment. The response
unit 22 may therefore be configured to hold a recording medium such as a paper
blank to which markings are applied. Alternatively, the medium, such as paper
tape, discontinuous or continuous forms, may be inserted by the respondents.
Examination papers, whether taking the shape of forms to be filled in, or the
result of a free hand composition or narrative, may also be graded by the comparator
means, which is capable of identifying key phrases and words that are expected
to appear on the completed examination paper. In similar fashion, comparator
means to be described hereinafter is designed so as to be able to recognize
and accept any one or more of a plurality of predetermined key words, symbols
or phrases.
Dispenser 46 can be adapted to reward children who have provided answers meeting
the predetermined response criteria by dispensing gold stars or other tokens.
In another embodiment, the dispenser combines the coupons issued to winners
with advertising material or shopping hints.
The records created pursuant to the present invention may be used as tokens,
coupons, certificates and general proof of participation in the broadcast transmission
program. Coupons may be redeemed by mail or in retail establishments for cash,
prizes or discounts.
The following terms are useful in describing the system of the invention.
The term "quiz program" relates to one or more questions or interrogatories
constituting an entire program, and also includes the insertion of a question
into other material, such as a cinematic film presentation.
The term "task-setting" is intended to include the meaning of interrogative,
opinion-eliciting, prediction-eliciting and statement-eliciting, as well as
the soliciting of creative endeavors and all kinds of functions capable of being
performed by an entry in a data entering device.
The term "comparing" relates to one or more possible established responses which
may be established prior to or subsequent to a contestant's response (the previously
known color of a golf ball, or during a game, a prediction of how close the
ball will come to the hole), and a comparing of an actual response to an established
response to determine if an actual response is acceptable. An acceptable response
may be based on one or more words or phrase or alphanumeric symbol or selection
of designated objects, by way of example.
The terms "evaluating" and "scoring" are intended to refer to and include the
meanings of sorting, counting, screening, evaluating, analyzing and processing
information, data and responses in accordance with predetermined criteria, ranging
from simple comparing tasks to computerized processing and analyses.
The term "interactive system" refers to a system for communicating from a sender
to a respondent and having the capacity for allowing the sender to receive a
communication, when desired, from the respondent whether by manual or electronic
means.
The term "response" is intended to include answers, elicited opinions, predictions
and statements, text and narrative provided by contestants, respondents, students
and other participants in broadcasts calling for interaction, reaction and responses.
The term "response criteria" is intended to refer to descriptive words, key
words, key phrases, parameters, equations, formulas, symbols and definiens describing
or defining responses that have been determined by the producer of a program
to be acceptable in the context of a task so as to qualify for a reward.
The terms "outcome criteria" and "success criteria" are intended to include
alphanumeric symbols and data by which the outcome of an event can be described,
measured or identified, such as key and descriptive words, coordinates, grid,
pinpointed and other locations, pictorial, diagrammatic and graphic presentations,
results, scores, counts, records, distances, rates and other measurements.
The term "processed response" is intended to refer to and include the results
produced by screening, sorting, scoring, evaluating, massaging, statistically
analyzing, or otherwise machine-processing responses, data and information provided
by participants at the receiving stations.
The term "hard copy" is intended to refer to and include any kind of permanent
record capable of being visually read, scanned or machine read. The term "matrix"
may be used to refer to the source or origin from which something originates,
takes form or develops, such as a cellulosic or plastic strip capable of being
provided with printed markings or magnetic recordings so as to create a hard
copy record. The term "simulcast" is intended to refer to the simultaneous,
but separate transmission from different propagating sources of the video and
audio portions of a program.
In the context of formulating response criteria, the terms "formulate", "generate",
"format" and "reformat" are intended to refer to and include the selection and
determination of all factors affecting the evaluation and scoring of responses.
In the case of a task requiring a prediction of the outcome of an event which
has not yet occurred or been completed, such as the completion of a forward
pass in a football game, or winning a hand at a card game such as bridge, the
response criteria may be referred to as outcome criteria. The outcome criteria
is to be transmitted to contestants at remote stations at a time after the prediction
has been made.
In the context of transmitting response criteria, for example, on an audio frequency,
the use of the term "encoding" is intended to include various forms of signal
coding as well as a transmission of signals at an increased speed which would
render the signals unintelligible to the human ear. The term "encoding", as
used by way of example for transmitting response criteria, is intended to include
other modes of communication such as various forms of color signal coding and
transmission of signals to television stations capable of being read by sensors
of devices for receiving signals outside the audible frequency range. The transmission
of encoded information, whether within the audio spectrum or within the visual
spectrum, is to be accomplished preferably in a fashion which is essentially
unnoticed by a contestant and cannot be perceived as conveying information.
In this sense, the encoding is perceptually unintelligible.
The term "keypad" is understood to include other forms of data entry devices,
the keyboard being presented by way of example.
The term "print-out" is intended to include printed, embossed, punched, stamped,
and other types of hard copy, paper, cardboard and plastic in the form of coupons,
certificates, tokens, cards, forms and matrices. The printing of the print-out
includes the foregoing forms of marking including the creation of three-dimensional
configurations.
The term "central" as used, for example, in "central location", is intended
to refer to a broadcast station or network serving a country, a time zone or
a region, and also is intended to include discrete local broadcast stations
operating independently and serving a town or other smaller geographic area,
always provided that such "central" station serves a multiplicity of remote
receiving stations.
The terms "remote" or "external" as used for example in "external audience",
are intended to include all television viewers and radio listeners tuned into
an electronic transmission station, irrespective of the distance from such central
station; as such, a "remote" audience includes, for example, students or other
respondents positioned in close proximity to the source of a program, as in
the case of a closed circuit transmission.
The term "interval" is intended to mean time interval or period of time.
The terms "code", "encoding", and "encryption" are intended to include alphanumeric
codes, color codes, bar codes and symbols, including those readable, recognizable
or conveyable by humans and machines.
The terms "acceptable response" or "acceptable answer" are intended to include
all answers to a question, which answers meet or exceed a minimum standard or
degree of accuracy, comprehensiveness or responsiveness; such "acceptable answers"
specifically including partially correct answers. Similarly "acceptable predictions"
are intended to include predictions falling within predetermined parameters
or meeting standards determined by the operator of an event following its occurrence.
Answers and predictions may be defined as "acceptable" irrespective of a level
of difficulty or a scoring mode.
The term "commercial message" as used herein includes sponsored, paid-for and
other messages intended for commercial purposes.
The term "user" of a recording medium as used herein includes viewers, listeners,
and buyers of a recording medium such as video tapes, and the target audience
intended to be reached by the commercial message.
The term "intelligible" is intended to mean intelligible to a human without
machine intervention, for example, without decoding, demodulation, change of
transmission or receiving speed, or other manipulations to make a signal intelligible
to humans. The term "intelligible" includes material and forms of expression
which can be seen or heard such as written material or speech. The term "unintelligible",
as applied to various signals which may be transmitted by equipment employed
in the practice of the invention, is intended to include signals which can be
made intelligible only be machine intervention.
The terms "multipart task" or "multipart question" are intended to include any
situations, such as questions, tasks and puzzles, in which a contestant is required
to provide chronologically spaced responses related to a common question, task,
puzzle, or subject matter requiring an action by the contestant. Such a task
may include so-called umbrella or omnibus questions comprising sub-groups, contingent
questions (e.g "if the answer is "true", then proceed to . . . ) and sub-questions
derived from a parent question.
The term "reward" is intended to include in its scope discounts, prizes, free
merchandise, monetary awards and other rewards having monetary or symbolic value.
A "sweepstakes award" may be a special award of extra value beyond the value
of a typical award.
The term "host" is intended to include an on-stage and an off-stage announcer,
master of ceremonies, program director, operator, guest host and celebrities,
announcers of commercials and any other individual associated with the program
or appointed to carry out one or more of the activities enumerated herein. It
also is intended to include the individuals engaged in the operation of formulating
a message or program for broadcasting on behalf of an advertiser, manufacturer,
store or sponsor.
The term "difficulty level" is intended to include difficulty levels set by
the host and inherent in the task or question, as reflected by possible answers,
as well as difficulty levels inherent in a response or answer set by a respondent
based on the speed, accuracy, comprehensiveness or responsiveness of the response
and reflecting respondent's confidence in his or her knowledge of the subject
matter. Similarly, a "difficulty level" may apply to the outcome of an event,
as reflected by possible predictions.
In the formulation of a response to a question by a member of the external television
audience, in the ensuing description reference will be made to a response in
terms of recognition of key words as well as responses which require several
words as in a phrase, sentence, formula and the like. It is to be understood
that, in the generation of such responses, the term "word" includes also alphanumeric
characters and other symbols such as pictorial representations which may be
required as a proper response to a question.
With respect to various embodiments of the invention, the response unit 22 may
be configured to provide the foregoing functions of evaluating and scoring,
as well as the processed response.
In FIG. 3 the studio 14 is shown, by way of example, to include a television
host 50, conducting a quiz program or game 52 in front of a television camera
54 which views both the game 52 and the host 50, and, also including when required,
display means on stage (not shown) to provide an image thereof, which image
is televised or only visible to the studio audience. Words spoken by the host
50, as well as other sounds in the studio 14, are converted by a microphone
56 to electric signals.
Also included within the studio 14 is a keyboard 58 by which the host 50 or
another person, may enter commands and instructions to be communicated via the
instructional signal. The central station 12 further comprises an encoder 60
a modulator 62, an oscillator 64, a band-pass filter 66, a summer 68, a combiner
70, a radio transmitter 72, a television transmitter 74, and a switch 76. The
switch 76 connects an input terminal of the combiner 70 to either an output
terminal of the summer 68 on line 78 or an output terminal of the microphone
56 on line 80.
The instructional signals may be prerecorded and then propagated from a central
transmission station to remote locations. In such a case, the host uses the
keyboard (or other such device) to initiate the transmission of the instructional
signal message.
In operation, the pressing of keys on the keyboard 58 activates the encoder
60 to output digital signals representing the keys which have been pressed.
The oscillator 64 outputs a carrier signal which is modulated by the modulator
62 with the digital signals outputted by the encoder 60. The modulator 62 applies
the modulated carrier signal to the filter 66 which narrows the bandwidth of
the modulated signal to equal the instructional bandwidth shown in FIG. 2. The
filtered signal is coupled from the filter 66 to one input terminal of the summer
68, a second input terminal of the summer 68 receiving the output electrical
signal from the microphone 56 via line 80. An output signal of the camera 54
is connected to one input terminal of the combiner 70, either directly or via
a video mixing unit (to be described with reference to FIG. 23). To facilitate
the explanation of this embodiment of the invention, it is presumed now that
the camera 54 is connected directly to the combiner 70. A second input terminal
of the combiner 70 is connectable via the switch 76 in line 78 to an output
terminal of the summer 68. In the alternative position of the switch 76, the
second input terminal of the combiner 70 is connected via line 80 to receive
the output electric signal of the microphone 56 rather than the output signal
of the summer 68. An output terminal of the combiner 70 is connected to the
television transmitter 74. Signals outputted by the summer 68 are connected
via line 78 also to the radio transmitter 72.
The signal outputted by the band-pass filter 66 is the instructional signal
which is to be transmitted via either the transmitter 72 or 74 to a remote receiving
station. The signal outputted by the microphone 56 is the audio signal component
of the signals transmitted in the television channel via the transmitter 74,
and is also transmitted via the radio transmitter 72 to the remote receiving
stations when a radio transmission of the audio portion of the activity in the
studio 14 is desired. The summer 68 performs the function of combining the instructional
signal with the audio signal whereby the instructional signal shares a small
fraction of the audio spectrum as shown in FIG. 2. This is accomplished by adding
the output signals of the microphone 56 and the filter 66 to output the sum
signal on line 78. The combiner 70 functions, in a well-known fashion, to combine
the video portion of the television channel signal from the camera 54 with either
the microphone signal on line 80 or the composite signal of the summer 68 depending
on the position of the switch 76.
In the event that the simulcast of both the radio and the television transmissions
is to be provided by the transmitter 72 and 74, the switch 76 connects the combiner
70 to line 80 in which case the television signal transmitted by the transmitter
74 has the standard format of video and audio portions without the instructional
signal, the latter being transmitted via the radio transmitter 72. In the event
that the switch 76 is connected to line 78, then the television signal transmitted
by the transmitter 74 includes the instructional signal within the audio portion
of the television signal.
The circuitry of FIG. 3 demonstrates two possible embodiments of the invention
wherein the receiving stations may have either of the two forms shown for the
remote receiving stations 16 and 18. If all of the receiving stations have the
form of the station 16, then the switch 76 may be placed in the position for
connection of the line 80 to the combiner 70, in which case the transmitter
74 transmits a normal television signal while the instructional signal is transmitted
by the transmitter 72. In the event that all of the receiving stations are in
the form of the station 18 then the switch 76 connects a line 78 to the combiner
70 for providing a modified form of the transmitted television signal wherein
the instructional signal is included within the television signal. In such case,
the radio transmitter 72 is not used by the invention, but may, nevertheless,
transmit a radio program to remote radios which do not form a part of the system
of the invention.
The television system 28 comprises a receiver 82, a demodulator 84, and a speaker
86. The separation circuitry 30 comprises a narrow-band filter 88 and a demodulator
90. The passband of the filter 88 is equal to the bandwidth of the instructional
signal shown in FIG. 2.
In the operation of the receiving station 16, the receiver 40 functions in the
manner of a well-known radio receiver for receiving the radio transmission incident
upon the antenna 36. In addition, the receiver 40 includes a narrow-band filter
92 having a passband equal to that of the filter 88. Thereby, the filter 92
extracts from the audio spectrum the portion of the spectrum, shown in FIG.
2 designated for the instructional signal. The signal outputted by the filter
92 is demodulated by the demodulator 42 to recover the digitally formatted signal
produced by the encoder 60, which digitally formatted signal is applied to the
response unit 22 for providing instruction thereto. The television set 38 in
the receiving station 16, as noted hereinabove, functions in accordance with
the well-known form of television set outputting both audio and video signals,
the latter appearing on the screen 20.
In the operation of the receiving station 18, the receiver 82 includes a well-known
television tuner (not shown) and outputs the television signal of the channel
to which the receiver 82 is tuned. The television signal outputted by the receiver
82 is demodulated in a well-known fashion by the demodulator 84 to provide a
video signal which is presented on the television screen 20, and an audio signal
which is presented by the speaker 86.
In accordance with a feature of the invention the demodulator 84 also applies
an audio signal to the filter 88 of the separation circuitry 30. The filter
88 extracts the portion of the audio spectrum designated for the instructional
signal, as does the filter 92, and outputs the instructional signal to the demodulator
90. The demodulator 90 operates, as does the demodulator 42 to recover the digitally
formatted signal produced by the encoder 60, which digitally formatted signal
is applied to the response unit 22 to provide instruction thereto. Thereby,
the response units 22 of the receiving stations 16 and 18 are able to function
concurrently with the presentation of the broadcast television program upon
the television screens 20. As indicated in the drawing for the receiving station
18, a member of the normally remote audience 94 operates the keyboard 44 of
the response unit 22 while listening to the speaker 86 and watching the television
screen 20.
With reference to FIG. 4, there is shown one embodiment of the response unit
22 of FIG. 3. The circuitry shown therein accomplishes the major functions of
the response unit 22, namely, providing a member of the audience 94 with a means
for entering a response to a situation viewed on the television screen 20 and/or
heard via the speaker 86, not accepting (rejecting) or accepting, evaluating
and scoring such response, recording such response, and outputting a temporary
or permanent record of the response. In particular, it can be advantageous if
the permanent record is in the form of the card 48, which form is machine readable
to facilitate a reading of the score and/or response by either a third party
or the host 50. It is to be understood that the circuitry of FIG. 4 constitutes
only one possible embodiment of the invention for performing these functions
and that other embodiments employing a digital computer suitably programmed
(not shown) may also be employed.
The response unit 22 comprises three decoders 96, 98, and 100, a register 102,
a score counter 104, a memory 106 for storing data, and a memory 108 for storing
an operating program, a timer 110, a gate 112, a buffer store 114, a comparator
116 for comparing output signals of the store 114 with the memory 106, a logic
unit 118, and a clock 120, these components being in addition to the keyboard
44 and the dispenser 46 disclosed previously with reference to FIGS. 1 and 3.
In operation, the memory 106 stores data with respect to the answers which are
to be provided by the viewing audience. For example, in the event that the viewing
audience is composed of children in a children's show wherein children are learning
to identify colors, the host may point successively to a red hat, a blue table,
and a green car and request to know the colors of the respective objects. In
such case, the memory 106 would store response criteria, in this instance, the
words red, blue, and green in the sequence corresponding to the order in which
the objects are to be addressed by the host. The keys on the keyboard 44 may
be similarly colored to enable entry of the correct response. Alternatively,
for older children, the keyboard may be an alphanumeric keyboard, as is found
on a typewriter, in which case the viewing audience is to type the words corresponding
to the colors addressed by the host. In this case, the comparator 116 would
compare the spelling of the words entered via the keyboard 44 with the spelling
of the colors stored in the memory 106. The buffer store 114 stores the responses
entered via the keyboard 44 to enable the comparator 116 to compare the response
with the data stored in the memory 106.
The method and system of the invention lend themselves particularly well to
educational shows for children. Questions pertaining to educational toys, to
books, to stories and to subjects being taught or addressed, are interspersed
in the show. Children are rewarded with tokens or other forms of award, such
as coupons redeemable at candy stores, ice cream parlors, and the like.
The score counter 104 operates under command from the program memory 108 to
score each correct response signal outputted by the comparator 116. When the
response entered at the keyboard 44 agrees with the data stored in the memory
106, the comparator 116 outputs a logic-1 signal via gate 112 to the counter
104. The output signal of the comparator 116 serves as an enable signal to initiate
a count by the counter 104. The counter increments its count by 1, 2, 3, or
other amount depending on the magnitude of the score to be awarded for the correct
response. In the event that the response is to be timed in the sense that a
limited time is available for the response, then the timer 110 is activated
by the program memory 108 to render the gate 112 in a state of conduction of
signals of the comparator 116 only during the interval of time when the response
is permitted. Both before and after this interval of time, the timer 110 places
the gate 112 in a state of nonconduction so that a response entered at the keyboard
44 outside of the desired response interval, or "window", cannot enable the
counter 104 to increment or modify the score.
The output count, score, or evaluation of the counter 104 is applied to the
dispenser 46 which includes a recording medium, such as the card 48, for providing
a permanent record of the score. The dispenser 46 includes suitable magnetic
recording heads (not shown)for recording information on the card 48 in a well-known
fashion. In addition, if desired, the dispenser 46 may include well-known encryption
circuitry for recording the score on the card 48 in a fashion which cannot be
read except by an automatic card reader having circuitry for decrypting the
recorded message. The dispenser 46 is activated by the program memory 108 to
accomplish the foregoing recording of the score.
The score counter/evaluator 104 can take different forms. While the score counting
function is described herein for illustrative purposes, it should be understood
that unit 104 may be designed to perform the processing of data entered by respondents
on keyboard 44 or other data entering device. Included in such processing are,
for instance, the computerized processing of data provided by respondents in
accordance with one of several programs stored in memory 108 and brought into
play by the instructional or command signals transmitted by transmitters 72
or 74. Questionnaires or forms used in market research may be stored in dispenser
46 or may be placed into it by respondents. Following a set of questions, or
upon the completion of the broadcast, processed or unprocessed data are issued
by dispenser 46 in the form of hard copy taking the form of one of the embodiments
described. If desired, the actual response entered at the keyboard 44, such
as the words red, blue, and green of the foregoing example, may be recorded
by the dispenser 46. For this purpose, the responses are coupled from the buffer
store 114 to a register 102 wherein the responses are stored prior to recording
at the dispenser 46. After all of the responses have been stored in the register
102, the program memory 108 strobes the register 102 to pass the data of the
responses into the dispenser 46 for recordation upon the card 48 or such other
form of storage media as may be employed.
The printout mechanism or marking device may take different forms to meet the
requirements of the broadcast, whether quiz programs, educational programs,
tests surveys or other task setting assignments. These devices may be relatively
small, utilizing a continuous tape as the substrate to which the markings are
applied, or they may utilize full page printouts. The recording medium may be
a special form or blank dispensed individually by the device as a cut section,
or may take other configurations, including discontinuous shapes.
Although completely blank forms may be used in recording respondents' entries
in the data entering device, in many instances the forms or blanks preferably
are provided with lines, grids, schematics and the like for easier subsequent
scoring of responses recorded on such forms or blanks.
To prevent tampering, forging and counterfeiting, the recording medium may comprise
material, such as paper or cardboard stock, plastic and the like, of special
composition or containing admixtures of identifiable substances facilitating
recognition by electronic or other sensing and scanning devices. Verification
may also be facilitated by using recording media that are colored, coated, embossed,
textured, magnetized or otherwise given recognizable properties.
By replacing the recording media, such as rolls of paper tape, periodically,
and by stipulating redemption of the record thus created within a specified
time period, the unauthorized reproduction, tampering with and counterfeiting
of the marked recording media can, for all practical purposes, be prevented.
The marking may be applied by any known methods, including printing with or
without impact, using ink sprays, heat, magnetic pulses, laser beams and other
light sources. The markings may also take the form of depressions and embossed
configurations legible by appropriate devices.
In addition, to prevent tampering, the recording mechanism, such as a printer,
can be provided with means for alternatively and selectively applying one of
a plurality of different types of markings. As an example, the color, intensity,
width, spacing, positioning, font and resolution of the markings may be built
into the recording means and may be controlled by radio or other electronic
command signals from a central station.
The shape and configuration of the markings to be utilized at any particular
time and subject to change at any time, includes numbers, letters, dots, dashes,
regular and irregular shapes, codes, symbols and other configurations, which
may be discrete, connected or continuous. The markings may also comprise shapes
and configurations having no discernible pattern and readable only by appropriate
scanning, reading or decoding means.
The number of combinations and permutations of the above mentioned properties
of the recording media and markings is so large as practically to preclude tampering,
forging, altering, counterfeiting or reproduction of authentic records; the
unauthorized manufacture of special composition paper alone, would be far too
costly and particularly time consuming to be practical.
According to a feature of the invention, with respect to preventing the forging
of prize winning coupons, a would-be forger is denied use of the printer to
accomplish forgery.
As an illustration, a TV-viewer having a response unit (as described above)
in his home, is provided with two materials or matrices to form hard copy outputted
by the dispenser. For example, the matrices may be a paper tape comprised of
100 coupon sections, which tape is fed into the printer of the response unit,
and a verification card having 100 spaces or boxes. The coupons and the card
have the name or other identification of the TV-viewer imprinted thereon. Codes
can be provided on both the tapes and cards. The paper tape and the verification
card are tamper-resisting in various ways. Both can carry time limits for redemption.
Tapes and cards provided to TV-viewers, say monthly, can for example have a
30-day limit for redemption. In view of the special composition of the tape
and the card, their duplication by a forger would be impractical, because special
paper or cardboard would have to be manufactured. The individual coupons and
the spaces or boxes on the card carry identical consecutive numbers.
Each time a winning coupon is presented at a redemption center, the winner of
such a prize is required to present the verification card. The numbers on the
winning coupon and on the card are compared to verify their matching. When the
coupon is redeemed, the corresponding space or box in the verification card
are canceled or invalidated by any one of many known methods, such as marking,
punching, tearing off, stamping and the like. When 100 coupons have been presented,
both the paper tape and the verification card have been used up.
By the method described, forging of coupons alone is rendered useless. Frequent
changing of the properties of tapes and cards by the operator of the system
and the multiplication of obstacles faced by a would-be forger are so great
as to make forging practically impossible.
A similar system can be employed when using magnetized cards in lieu of paper
coupons. The magnetized card of a winning contestant is provided with identifying
indicia and codes, the verification card carrying matching markings and codes.
The redemption procedures are similar.
If magnetized cards are used and validated by dispenser, the validation may
be erased at the time a card is presented for redemption, so that it may be
reused.
It is noted that the data to be stored in the memory 106 is provided by the
instruction signal on line 122 or 124 from the demodulators of the receiving
stations 16 or 18 shown in FIG. 3. The digital format of the instructional signal
is decoded by the decoder 96 to extract the portion of the signal relating to
the data which is to be stored in memory 106. The decoder 98 decodes that portion
of the signal which is to be employed for presetting the timer 110 for the designated
interval of response time. The decoder 100 may be coupled directly to the memory
108, or via an OR gate which will be described with reference to FIG. 23. To
facilitate the present explanation of this embodiment of the invention, it is
presumed that the decoder 100 is connected directly to the memory 108. The decoder
100 decodes that portion of the instruction signal which presets the memory
108 to any one of a number of previously stored formats for responding to situations
presented in the studio 14. In this regard, it is noted that the form of the
instructional signal follows common communication practice wherein the instructional
signal is set up as a sequence of digital words or fields which identify respective
portions of the message dealing with data, timing interval, and program commands.
Thereby, the decoders 96, 98 and 100 are able to recognize the specific parts
of the instructional signal and to extract the requisite data and commands.
The response criteria may consist of a simple requirement to be met by a respondent
or may comprise a plurality of independently variable factors.
The control logic 118 operates in response to a succession of clock pulses provided
by the clock 120 for outputting control function signals to the memories 106
and 108 and to the buffer store 114. A connection between the keyboard 44 and
the logic unit 118 provides for a control function, such as an entry command
whereby a person responding directs the store 114 to enter the data inputted
by the keyboard 44. The control logic of the unit 118 may also be activated
by a command from the program memory 108. Thereby, the response unit 22 is capable
of receiving, scoring, and recording a response entered by a member of the audience
at a remote receiving station.
The construction of the foregoing system of the invention permits its use in
numerous situations involving participation wherein members in the external
audience are to participate with members of the studio audience in situations
requiring participation. An example of the utility of the system may be demonstrated
by considering a television game/quiz show involving both people at home as
well as in the studio. The invention makes it possible to broadcast quiz show
permitting home viewers to become participants and contestants. The invention
is applicable to a variety of present and future game shows.
As an illustration, a game show or quiz program may include the task of listing,
in reverse chronological order, the names of all teams having won the baseball
World Series, or the World Soccer Championship. A time limit is set which makes
it impossible for contestants to enter all correct answers; this is common practice
in aptitude tests.
There are five contestants on the studio stage. Each studio contestant is equipped
with well known means to write, print, type or otherwise enter his or her response
on a board, keyboard or other data entering device adapted so that the responses,
in the process of being entered, may be projected on a screen or screens visible
to the studio audience, but not to the contestants and not to the home viewers
until the predetermined time limit has been reached, or until the time allowed
has substantially been consumed. The responses of studio contestants can be
displayed to the studio audience and to home viewers with some delay, thereby
preventing any of the home contestants from benefiting from the answers of the
stage contestants.
It therefore is an object of the system described to elicit responses from contestants
at remote sites and to capture their responses in their data entering devices
essentially before the responses given by stage or studio contestants become
known to home contestants. This is accomplished by projecting the questions
on a screen hidden from studio contestants but in view of the camera 54 of FIG.
3. Concurrently with, or prior to the projection of the questions, the host
50 employs the keyboard 58 to transmit instructions to the response units 22
of the remote audience. The response entered by a participant in the remote
audience is timed and is subject to a time limit, the time period to conclude
before the questions are presented to the studio contestants. Thereby, the responses
of the remote audience are not influenced by the responses of the studio contestants.
Keyboard 58 may be operated by a person other than the quiz show host and may
be situated on-stage or off-stage.
In a simple version, the system can be employed to attract viewers and listeners
not normally disposed to participate in game or quiz shows per se, but willing
to answer a few unobtrusive questions, especially if pertaining to a subject
of interest to the viewer. By responding to questions, a home viewer can, in
effect, act as a contestant. The questions to be answered by home viewers and
radio listeners can be interspersed in shows other than quiz shows and can be
so simple as to require essentially only a confirmation by participants of being
tuned in to a particular program.
Thus, for instance, home participants may be asked to identify the soap opera
character who earlier appeared in the program. Or home viewers of a sports program
may be asked to name a player who just scored. These implementations of the
system and accompanying awards to a correct answer are intended to increase
the television and radio audience. Viewers of a soap opera or persons listening
to a radio sports broadcast, constitute a highly targeted audience and as a
result of the lower per-household cost, advertisers will be able to award more
valuable coupons and prizes to successful respondents. Participants who have
given an acceptable answer can be rewarded with a coupon of defined value to
be redeemed in cash, or to be applied to the price of a specified product or
to the price of any product in a specified retail outlet. Other forms of rewards,
whether of commercial or symbolic value, may be devised.
Advertising material, such as shopping hints and promotional material may be
provided on hard copy records as coupons, prior to the delivery of the matrix,
for example a paper tape, to participants at remote locations; or the advertising
material may be provided and printed on the coupons at the time at which other
data, such as prize information, is provided thereon.
The latter method has the advantage that a sponsor or advertiser can have up-to-date
promotional information printed on coupons by directing the station which transmits
instructional signals to remote locations to include in such signals the desired
advertising material. A last-minute-telephone call by an advertiser to the sub-carrier
station with directives to incorporate certain instructional signals in the
sub-carrier transmission will result in a large number of shoppers being alerted
to special sales through up-to-the-minute coupon promotions.
The quantitative results obtained by this method can also be used in the statistical
analysis and the reactions of audiences tuned in to certain programs. It is
noted that the equipment of the invention may well be installed in numerous
selected or random households in which case, responses by household members
can readily serve as a bases for statistically sampling peoples' responses to
a product, service, political candidates, corporate images and other subjects
of surveys. The increased audience provided by the invention is significant
in survey and market research fields because, by way of example, an increase
of sample size from 2000 to 2 million will reduce a sampling error from 3% to
0.1%.
In the field of qualitative market analysis and consumer research, the system
and methods described can be employed very effectively, substituting home viewers
and listeners for the so-called focus groups or other population samples used
to determine buyer responses to products and services. The versatility and flexibility
of the home keyboard or other data entering device are particularly well suited
to the elicitation of unbiased responses to questions or statements by advertising
agencies and market analysts. The market research and other surveys and polls
made possible by the system and methods described, can be part of a regular
quiz show or can can be conducted separately. Respondents are rewarded for their
cooperation by issuing certificates, coupons and the like to them. The permanent
records produced by the dispensing means in remote locations can be mailed to
the research organization. For this purpose the forms dispensed by the dispensers
in participants' homes can take the form of self-addressed return envelopes.
Special printed forms may be used in conducting research into respondents' reactions
to tasks or questions. Coupon awards be dispensed separately or may be a tear-off
section of a survey form.
The relative simplicity and compactness of the electronic devices comprising
the response unit, and the fact that the response unit is not connected by wire
and requires no installation, makes it possible to design the response unit
as a portable unit. A plurality of such units may be placed in systematically
or randomly selected homes, used for the desired research purposes and thereupon
moved to new locations. The units may be battery powered to provide mobility
for use at private or public locations.
For the implementation of game/quiz shows, the following advantages of the invention
are noted. The system of the invention does not require any wiring or rewiring
of a home nor the use of telephone lines, and may be offered to viewers free
of charge. In the context of the disclosed embodiment, a telephone is suggested
merely as a convenient and rapid means for interaction between respondent and
host, but is not required to practice the invention. For example, the external
audience might be located in a separate room within walking distance from the
studio in which case interaction can be accomplished personally by allowing
a member of the external audience to walk over to the studio. The system permits
home viewers to participate in quiz shows on the spur of the moment without
advance notice and without any requirement for special forms or entry blanks.
The system can be superposed upon a variety of game and quiz shows to permit
viewer participation without interference with existing show formats, and has
the advantage of expanding the television audience, thereby attracting sponsors
of the shows. The machine readable card 48, or a one-time coupon which may be
outputted by the dispenser 46, may be presented or redeemed for prizes by successful
participants at a local store or other business establishment cooperating with
the broadcaster.
When applying the methods and systems described to a multi-part task, contestants
normally are confronted with a situation, such as questions or puzzles, in which
a plurality of entries on the response entering device are required, the total
of the responses determining the correctness or acceptability of a contestant's
response.
While such an event or operation of such a task is in progress, the responses,
entered piecemeal, as well as the applicable response criteria, are stored at
contestants' locations. In a game shoe situation, one unacceptable answer may
eliminate or disqualify a contestant from winning a prize. The task may be presented
all at once, or in parts presented successively and calling for a partial response
to each partial task.
The comparison and scoring means can be programmed to perform their functions
at each stage of the task, upon completion of the entire task, or following
a group of partial tasks. The printer/dispenser normally is programmed to operate
at the end of all responses by a contestant to a multi-part task.
The system provides simplicity in the administration of the game by identification
of the successful respondents; this is readily accomplished at the dispenser
46 in each remote location by imprinting each card 48 or token with the name
of the respondent. If desired, the name of the respondent can also be inputted
at the keyboard 44 as are other answers to questions. The questions may include
multiple-part questions and may require multiple choice answers, if desired.
The questions may require simple answers such as yes or no, a single word such
as a number or a color, or a plurality of words as in a phrase or narrative.
Operation of the score counter 104 for various choices of answer permit a scoring
of partially correct responses and those meeting a predetermined response criteria.
In its simplest form, the keyboard may be provided with only two keys to answer
yes or no, while in a more complex form, the keyboard may include the alphanumeric
character keys for entering words or phrases, as well as other symbols.
If, as an example, a respondent must select a number from the numbers 1 through
9, and if the completely accurate answer is 5, the comparator unit may be programmed
so as to accept any number between 4 and 6, or 3 and 6, etc.
The response entering device 44 may be provided with keys, buttons, levers,
or other means for indicating a response, which response can have an assigned
meaning. It may be a shorthand entry, standing for a word, a phrase or a sentence.
A response unit may be constructed as a dedicated unit for a specific purpose
as for playing a game, in which case a key may generate a specific type of response
or responses.
By way of alternative embodiments of the invention, it is noted that the comparator
116 may output a multiple-bit digital word wherein the additional bits are provided
by the memory 106 dependent on the specific answer stored in the memory 106,
which answer is compared to the response within the buffer store 114. For example,
if two possible responses would be regarded as correct, but one of the two responses
is preferred, then the comparator 116 would output an additional bit for the
preferred response. The additional bit would be passed by the gate 112 to advance
the count of the counter 104, thereby to increase the score by a larger amount
when the preferred response is entered at the keyboard 44.
The formatting and reformatting can provide for various ways of weighting the
responses of home contestants, such as straight line additions, geometric and
exponential progressions, or computations of scores based on formulas incorporating
discrete groups of responses. Thus, score counter 104 may be replaced with a
microcomputer (not shown) which is responsive to commands from the memory 108
for combining inputs from keyboard 44, memories 106 and 108, and capable of
reflecting the time element, to serve, in effect, as an evaluator of complex
answers.
According to the present invention, questions may be transmitted from the central
station, to which more than one acceptable answer may be given, the answers
varying in the degree of difficulty from the respondent's standpoint. As an
example, a question may call for naming a minimum of two European cities, the
names beginning with the letter M, this being difficulty level 1. Difficulty
level 2 might call for four such cities and difficulty level 3 might call for
six such cities, all answers to be entered within 30 seconds. The particular
difficulty level may be specified by the person controlling the transmission,
or it may be selected by the individual respondent prior to seeing or hearing
the question. In order to enable a contestant to choose a difficulty level,
the host may announce or hint at the general nature, or the context of the question
about to be asked. The degree of difficulty will normally determine the value
of the prize, etc. The device evaluating the responses may dispense records,
e.g. coupons, certificates and the like of different value or in different denominations.
For instance, it may issue a 10 cent coupon at level 1, and 25 cent coupon at
level 2, and a 50 cent coupon at level 3. The coupons may be redeemed in retail
establishments, the coupons being similar to those contained in newspapers.
It should be understood, therefore, that in addition to the difficulty level
set by the host, a higher difficulty level may be superimposed by an individual
contestant, as will be disclosed subsequently with reference to FIGS. 6-10.
By use of encryption, the card 48 provides an essentially tamper-proof record.
The invention is applicable, not only to home viewers but also to viewers in
a public establishment such as a restaurant or school wherein people may participate
as teams. The questions may be gradated to be suitable for a variety of audiences
varying from those having limited formal education to those having special interests.
By use of the timer 110, the studio host can designate the beginning and end
of a response interval, and vary the time limit allowed from question to question.
In addition, the invention lends itself to the development of further forms
of game and quiz shows. The difficulty level can be increased by decreasing
an allocated time for response.
It should be understood that individual questions may vary with respect to the
nature of the task, the type and particulars of acceptable responses, the difficulty
level, the period of time allowed for responding, the kind and range of prizes,
the weighting of responses, the composition of the target audience and other
considerations.
It should be further understood that normally the announcements to remote participants
of levels of difficulty and of time intervals allowed for responding to a task
are transmitted and received in a form directly intelligible to participants,
such as in open language. If an acceptable response criteria is transmitted,
prior to entry of a response by a participant, it is conveyed in coded or otherwise
unintelligible form; if it is transmitted subsequent to such entry, it may be
conveyed in open language.
As an example in the use of the invention in the educational field, the memories
of the response units at the remote locations receive and retain instructional
signals from a central transmitting station conveying the correct, preferred,
or acceptable response or responses to the task posed by the task-setting message.
Upon completion of a task by a respondent, or upon lapsing of the allotted time,
the printout mechanism is activated by the instructional signals so as to communicate
or so as to dispense in hard copy form the correct or preferred response to
each respondent at remote locations. In this manner, a student who receives
a printout containing his or her scored response, also receives the "textbook"
solution or most desirable response to the task presented. For comparison purposes,
the dispenser may provide printed hard copy containing a student's original
response.
The foregoing features in the operation of the system of the invention are readily
applied to the educational field to encourage both early educational experiences
among children as well as for home-study courses for high school and university
students. In the educational field, the situation portrayed in the studio and
presented on the television screen may be in the nature of a task-setting situation
rather than that of a pure question. The appropriate response be a brief statement,
an equation, or may contain a number of cross-referenced key words or key phrases
or symbols. The system of the invention may be implemented also by closed circuit
television and cable television as well as by the broadcast situation of FIG.
1. The keyboard 44 at each of the response units 22 may be a standard typewriter
keyboard, as noted above, or may include a display of the typed response such
as is presently available on some electronic typewriters. Such a display would
be useful in the answering of examination questions for home-study programs.
It is also noted that the keyboard 44 is representative of a response entry
device, and may, if desired, be replaced by other entry devices such as a joystick,
switches, or a device responsive to a spoken voice.
Response evaluation means referred to herein may include, when appropriate,
as for example in the educational field, scanning devices capable of recognizing
symbols, diagrams, charts, formulas, equations and drawings responsive to the
response criteria.
In the practice of the invention, the answers given by studio contestants may,
for instance, be displayed to the studio audience and/or broadcast to TV-viewers
following a predetermined delay of, say 5-20 seconds. During this 5-20 second
period, the data or response entering devices of the stage contestants, or the
studio display devices, may be made inoperative, so that no answers may be entered
and/or displayed, even if the stage contestants are aware of the questions.
Other ways of staggering the "response windows" by 5-20 seconds or more can
be devised.
This time lag is intended to make the answers projected on studio screens following
the time lag useless to home contestants from the point of view of total time
allowed for response. By the time the correct answers are televised, all or
a critical amount of the allotted time will have elapsed. This forces home contestants
to enter their responses before knowing the responses of studio contestants.
By way of example only, a typical sequence of events as pertaining to a quiz
show with studio and home contestants is as follows: TV home viewers and contestants
see and hear the questions without delay. However, the questions are presented
to stage contestants and the studio audience after a delay of 5-20 seconds.
The respective contestants may begin answering questions upon their presentation,
subject to time limits. Acceptable responses are presented to everyone, only
after the stage contestants have completed their time for response.
To provide attention-attracting action on stage for the studio audience and
TV-viewers who are not contestants, the announcer or master of ceremonies can
set the stage for the questions, or a performer may walk across the stage to
a podium and read the questions to the stage contestants and the audience, thereby
consuming 5-20 seconds. The questions are displayed on a screen, visible to
all TV-viewers, including home contestants. Other ways of giving home contestants
a head start of 5-20 seconds, or more, can be devised. In another embodiment,
the responses by stage contestants are entered, but not displayed for a predetermined
period of time. Home contestants may be allotted more or less time than studio
participants. If there is only one participant or contestant on stage, the quiz
show still follows the concept outlined. The studio contestants and/or home
contestants may be allowed a choice of different difficulty levels.
As an example, the use of key words and key phrases is illustrated in the context
of a game show described hereinafter, which might be entitled "Definitions".
the host presents a situation, hints at, or announces a dictionary word and
defines the task as one of providing the correct definition or definitions of
such word. The dictionary definition, frequently a phrase, is of course an acceptable
answer. Using the task word "many" as an example, an indispensable key work
that would have to appear in any acceptable response would be the word "number".
However, two or more definitions may exist for a task word.
It will be obvious that this type of show lends itself well to evaluating partially
correct and less-than-exhaustive responses. Partial credit may be given to definitions
that are reasonably close to the dictionary definition. A more complex task
in the context of said show might be the definition of the word "set", for which
a large number of definitions exist. Cumulative credits may be awarded to contestants
listing a plurality of key definition words or phrases.
According to another show format, separate quiz programs for studio contestants
and home contestants may be conducted concurrently by the same game show host.
He or she may, for instance, conduct one quiz program for studio contestants
in the manner described and while the studio contestants ponder their answers
may present supplemental, or a separate set of, questions to home contestants,
to which the latter respond in accordance with the method of the present invention.
Such separate questions for home contestants may be posed by a second or off-stage
announcer.
In the United States, Europe and other regions, television programs are frequently
broadcast repetitively in different time zones. In the case of game shows, this
enables television viewers who are tuned in to such program and who are in a
time zone which first receives one such game or quiz show to inform members
of an audience in another time zone of the correct responses to tasks or questions,
thus ensuring such members in other time zones of winning an award without having
independently correctly responded to such tasks. This potential problem resulting
from a sequential broadcasting of television game shows in the context of the
present invention will now be addressed.
When the awards offered successful contestants are of a monetary value representing,
say 10-15 percent of the price of the merchandise, and are designed only to
attract buyers to a store, then a sponsor, such as a manufacturer, may choose
to ignore the risk of, or may even welcome, having members of an audience in
a first time zone provide members in a later time zone, who themselves did not
think of the correct answer, with an appropriate response. Awarding such viewer
a 10 percent discount is similar to making 10 percent discount coupons available
through newspapers and magazines.
A more serious problem may arise when a sponsor or manufacturer offers awards
of a larger magnitude. In such instances, it is desirable to employ a method,
and such methods are hereinafter described, which permit airing a quiz or educational
program presenting tasks or questions calling for different responses in different
time zones. This is achieved by a modified version of the methods described
above, which modified methods may be practiced with the systems described in
this specification and accompanying drawings.
For example, a host or professor may stand in front of a map of the world. He
or she verbally poses the question "In which country is the river to which I
am pointing located?" For purposes of this illustration, the audio portion of
the question, posed by an on-stage or off-stage announcer, is referred to herein
as a "module question", and normally a quiz show or educational program comprises
many such module questions. The object of formulating module questions is to
be able easily and economically to substitute such module questions for each
other in the same show, which normally is taped prior to airing. Such a module
question, consisting of the audio portion of the question can easily and economically
be replaced by another audio portion, while the more costly video portion (the
host pointing to a map) remains the same.
In such a modified method, a part of all of a question or task presented in
a program in one time zone, are differentiated and are different from the corresponding
question or task asked in a similar program aired in another time one. This
is achieved by formulating at least a part of a question or task in interchangeable
module form.
Either an entire question may be
substituted in a program, or a part of a question may be substituted. If only
a part of a question is to be substituted, such part can for instance be a part
or all of only the video portion of a question. Normally, such interchangeable
module questions will be of approximately the same length, so as not to affect
the overall length of a program.
If a program comprises an entertainment portion and a game or quiz show portion,
the part of the show consisting of questions or tasks may be produced and taped
separately and independently of the entertainment of other portions of the show.
Many forms of implementation of this method may be devised. The example given
below is illustrative of only one of the alternative methods which achieve the
above mentioned object.
According to a preferred method, a plurality of sets of different tasks is formulated,
using one set of tasks in one time zone and another set of tasks in another
time zone. Although the tasks may differ in their entirety, a preferred method
is described wherein the tasks differ only with respect to their audio portion.
In the taping of the show, the video portion is the same in all tapes, irrespective
of the time zone in which such program is to be aired or transmitted by cable.
The audio and video portions together form a question or task. The audio -portions
of module questions change from one such program to the next. Thus the host
or professor is seen in all versions of the show to be pointing to the same
map. He or she will, however, tape a plurality of oral module questions, only
one of these module questions being used in any one time zone. With reference
to the above example, in which a host points to a map of the world, another
module question may be "What is the name of the river?" Yet another such module
question by the host, or off-stage person, may be "Is the river to which I am
pointing among the five longest rivers in the world?"
The above described example involves the same host or professor asking a set
of questions, each of which questions must be taped in its entirety. This necessitates
the involvement of the host in asking a set of successive oral questions, while
the video portion remains the same. In another version of this preferred method,
the module questions, that is the audio portions of each question, are asked
by an off-camera announcer. This method has the advantage that in the taping
of the show, the host spends only sufficient time in front of the camera to
ask one question, the host providing such action in front of the camera as is
required to make the oral module question asked by the off-camera announcer
intelligible. Thus, the host may silently point to an object, such as a map,
for a length of time permitting an off-camera announcer to pose one module question.
Other module questions asked by the off-camera announcer and accompanying the
same video portion showing the host, are dubbed or inserted into the appropriate
part of the tape. In the taping of a quiz show intended to be aired in four
time zones, an off-camera announcer therefore asks four sets of module questions,
one set of these oral questions being inserted into the appropriate place in
each of the four program tapes used in transmitting the show in the four time
zones.
According to a preferred embodiment of the above-described methods for use in
the presentation of quiz programs in different languages, a host announces the
oral module questions in one language. Different oral module questions are dubbed
in, both in the language originally used by the host and in any other languages
for use in different countries. In such an event the words and sentences chosen
in formulating questions, are such as to lend themselves to dubbing. Also, the
host when announcing some questions, can face towards a picture or a map, away
from the viewing audience, in order to facilitate dubbing.
Thus the dubbing technique is an economical method of achieving the above-mentioned
objective of utilizing the same video portions with a variety of different audio
questions in different time zones.
Yet another example of a simplified version of the above methods may entail
a projection of a scene or the filming of an object without a host being present.
The object could be a well-known personality, or a picture of such personality;
or an action shot of such personality may be used. An off-camera announcer may
ask a number of oral or module questions to meet the requirements of the number
of shows to be shown in different time zones.
The examples set forth are simple ones and many different and more complex versions
and implementations of the home quiz show are possible and will occur to game
show producers.
In some instances, such as in market research, the system described can be employed
to identify consumers meeting certain criteria. In that event, the memory and
control elements of response unit 22 are programmed in accordance with the requirements
of the particular consumer research. Response unit 22 normally is placed in
remote locations, which need not be homes and can be other private and public
places. In an alternative application of the system, the response unit 22 is
equipped with appropriate means capable of limiting the functions of the scoring
and evaluation means. For this purpose, controls and switches (not shown) are
provided, which cause memories 106 and 108, logic control 118, comparator 116
and gate 112 to selectively perform only those evaluating functions required
for the specific application. In such an event, dispenser 46 receives only partially
processed data and generates a record of responses entered on keyboard 44 reflecting
responses evaluated only to the desired extent and at least partially resembling
the original information entered by respondents. Respondents are rewarded in
one of the manners previously described, including a monetary prize simply for
participating in a test.
It is a particular advantage of the present system that the kind of data-entering
device may vary between different remote locations. Furthermore, the kind of
data entering, scoring or evaluating device installed at different locations
may vary in accordance with the intended use. Thus, for instance, in selected
remote locations, electronic devices of known design may be installed, which
are capable of subjecting the raw data entered by respondents to computer analysis.
The invention may be practiced by providing two or more response units at each
remote location together with one set of program presenting means. Providing
more than one response unit, including means to modify a difficulty level and
timing, and including comparison, storing, scoring and dispensing means in,
for example, one household, enables two or more family members to become contestants
by responding individually to a situation presented by a single television or
radio receiver based on a program transmission from a central station. In a
public place, a plurality of response units will generate increased and competitive
participation by persons present
FIG. 5 shows the buffer store 114, the register 102 and the program memory 108,
as well as further details of the dispenser 46 of FIG. 4 to accomplish the imprinting
of a response on a recording medium, such as a paper or card, having a prescribed
format for the entry of answers. As has been noted hereinabove, such a data
entry form or questionnaire, is useful for providing responses by respondents
in situations such as contests, educational and advertising promotional or research
activities. An example of such a questionnaire 126 is shown in FIG. 5. Therein,
blocks numbered 1-6 are provided for entry of responses by members of the audience
at the remote receiving stations 16 and 18.
Also shown in FIG. 5 is an enlarged fragmentary view of the keyboard 44, the
view showing a keypad with keys for the entry of identifying numerals for identifying
the blocks of the questionnaire 126 in which the respective answers are to be
entered. The respondent identifies a questionnaire block by holding down a control
key Q while typing the identifying numeral on the keyboard 44. The response
to be entered in that block is then typed by use of the alphabet keys of the
keyboard 44.
The dispenser 46 comprises a decoder 128, a printer 130 and a programmable read-only
memory (PROM) 132. In operation, the typed answer and the questionnaire block
identification is applied by the keyboard 44 and via the store 114 to the register
102. The contents of the register 102, as described hereinabove, are subsequently
transferred to the dispenser 46. The decoder 128 detects the presence of a digital
word produced by the control key Q, and thereby decodes the incoming digital
signals from the register 102 so as to separate the block identification from
the response. The decoder 128 activates the printer 130, upon the appearance
of the response, to print the response on the questionnaire 126, the latter
having been previously placed into the dispenser 46 by the respondent. The decoder
also addresses the PROM 132 with the block identification, whereupon the PROM
132 outputs the block location to the printer 130 to direct the printer 130
to print the response at the correct location on the questionnaire 126. Information
with respect to the layout of the questionnaire 126 is loaded into the PROM
132 by the program memory 108 as directed by the instructional signal on line
122 or 124 of FIG. 4.
Alternatively, the block location data and the responses may be stored on the
card 48 for printing out at another location, such as the facilities of an advertiser
or a company providing the promotional activities. The response may include
a narrative text, in which case the comparator 116 may be employed to signal
the presence of key words in the response, which have been previously entered
into the data memory 106.
By way of further embodiments of the invention, it is noted that the dispenser
46 may include a group of trays 134 each of which stores a separate set of forms
such as the questionnaire 126 upon which a response is to be printed. The trays
134 are activated by a control signal from the program memory 108 to present
a blank form to the printer 130 to be imprinted with the response. Information
with respect to the desired form to be employed in response to a task-setting
situation is loaded into the program memory 108 by the instructional signal
on line 122 or 124, whereby an instructor or the host 50 in a classroom or in
the studio 14 designates the requisite form for use in preparing the response.
The completed form, or questionnaire 126, exits a slot 136 of the printer 130.
The completed questionnaire 126 may be provided on any suitable recording medium
which serves as a hard copy such as paper, plastic strip, or plastic card.
As was shown with respect to FIG. 4, the score counter 104 is under control
of the program memory 108. This permits the score counter 104 to activated and
deactivated by commands transmitted via the instructional signal. In the outputting
of the foregoing questionnaire 126 from the printer 130 with words printed in
the appropriate blocks, a score can also be imprinted upon the questionnaire
126 upon activation of the counter 104, which score is omitted upon deactivation
of the counter 104.
The embodiments of the system of FIGS. 6-10 provide further capability to the
system of FIGS. 1-5 for conducting a quiz or game-type television show with
both local and remote audience participation. The embodiments of FIGS. 6-10
provide for selection of difficulty level, evaluation of response based on key
words and phrases, interaction between members of the remote audience and the
program host as by use of telephone communication, and adaptation of the program
by the host to the interaction by modification and reformatting of response
criteria as by altering a basis or mode of scoring and a period of time allowed
for response. As with the system of FIGS. 1-5, the present system of FIGS. 6-10
can also be employed with radio programs. Descriptive material relating to the
program can be transmitted over the video and/or the voice channels of the television
transmission. In particular, it is noted that much of the system description
provided in FIGS. 1-5 applies also to the system of FIGS. 6-10 but, that additionally,
the system description presented in FIGS. 6-10 shows the use of at least two
separate signals, in the instructional signal group, for providing answers and
evaluating the answers under control of both the program host and the remote
viewer.
At the discretion of the television program conductor, or other person assigned
for this purpose, and that of individual viewers, different difficulty levels
may be applied to individual questions, it being understood that answers to
more difficult questions or answers to the same questions at higher difficulty
level may carry with them larger awards. However, even if only one set of response
criteria is established for a task, it is understood that such response criteria
carry a specified or implied difficulty level. Each successful respondent may
be issued a printout or similar hard copy displaying the value of the award
and containing a code which is verifiable over the telephone by a central station,
or without the use of a telephone, by a cooperating store or merchandising center,
for issuing an award.
FIG. 6 shows a further embodiment of the invention having greater versatility
in the evaluation of learning situations and the scoring of games and contests
by means of a system 200. In the system 200, a central station 202 includes
a studio 204, such as a television studio, and broadcasts programs to many remote
receiving stations, one such station 206 being shown by way of example. Each
of the receiving stations 206 includes means, such as a television screen 208,
for observing a broadcast program, and means by which persons in a remote viewing
audience can respond to situations presented in the studio 204. The response
means is shown as a response unit 210 which, as will be described hereinafter,
includes circuitry for evaluating and recording responses entered by persons
in the viewing audience.
A television program is conducted in the studio 204 by a host 212. While various
types of programs may be employed in conjunction with the study of specific
subject matter, for example, a course in advertising or packaging, in which
there is a display of a specimen 214 of merchandise, or other subject of interest,
to members of a remote television audience 216 located at the remote receiving
stations 206, a game program employing a television game 218 is presented by
way of illustration of the invention.
The use of a game is a recognized technique in the teaching of children, as
well as older persons, in a classroom. The object of the study or program, designated
herein as specimen 214, might be an article, such as furniture or clothing,
normally offered for sale, or other type of object such as a painting or animal
in the case of study of such subject matter. For example, in a study of architecture,
the "specimen" would be a model of a building, and in a home-study course of
geography, the "specimen" would be a map or other teaching aid. In the case
of services being offered, the specimen may take the form of an advertisement
of such services. Each receiving station 206 is provided with a television system
220 which receives broadcast transmissions 222 of the televised game show for
presentation on the television screen 208.
In the studio 204, the host 212, or an associate who may be off-camera, is provided
with two keyboards 224 and 226, respectively, for entering appropriate responses
to situations posed by the game 218 (response criteria) and for entering appropriate
guidelines for scoring the responses (scoring mode). The response criteria may
consist of specific delineating or parametric information. The game 218 and
the specimen 214 are viewed by a television camera 228 which provides video
signals for the broadcast transmission 222. It is to be understood that, in
addition to the remote audience 216, a local or studio audience (not shown)
may be present within the studio 204 for participating in the game 218. The
host 212 addresses the local audience and the remote audience by means of a
microphone 230, the microphone 230 providing an audio signal for the broadcast
transmission 222. In this example of the television game, a first video signal
is transmitted to the remote audience to present a picture of of the game situation,
this signal being followed, preceded or accompanied by an audio signal in which
the host describes the task to be performed by the remote audience, which task
may be the answering of specific questions in a designated fashion. As described
above, when confronted with a time zone problem, one or more off-camera announcers
ask a number of questions in the form of the oral or module questions, which
module questions are then selectively inserted into the tapes of television
programs to be broadcast successively in different time zones. Alternatively,
the second signal describing the task may be transmitted over the video channel
by use of a display in front of the studio audience, the display having the
questions set forth in large lettering which is read readily.
With reference to both FIGS. 6 and 10, the central station 202 provides for
a modulation of signals of the instructional signal group outputted by the keyboards
224 and 226 for the predetermined responses and scoring criteria within the
audio channel to occupy narrow spectral bands in the upper portion of the audio
spectral band. The system 200 is readily described in terms of four or more
signals, the first signal being the television signal portraying activity in
the studio 204. The second signal provides the description of the task to be
performed by the studio and/or the remote audience. The studio scene and the
task carried by the first two signals are presented diagrammatically in a typical
time sequence by a graph shown alongside the camera 228, it being understood
that the time sequence may be varied since the task announcement may precede
or accompany the studio situation. The third signal carries the designated criteria
for a response or range of responses entered by the host 212 upon the keyboard
224, such criteria being, by way of example, key words to be entered by the
respondents. The fourth signal provides the scoring mode or guidelines entered
by the host 212 upon the keyboard 226, such scoring being, by way of example,
that an answer of the word "fish" is worth three points while an answer of the
word "salmon" is worth five points. Additional examples of response criteria
and scoring mode are discussed herein.
As example of a further signal, a fifth signal providing a verification code
for use in verifying a printout of awards at a remote station may be sent subsequently
along the same channel employed for transmission of the scoring criteria. The
passbands of the third and the fourth signals, namely the response criteria
and the scoring mode signals respectively, are indicated in FIG. 10, both of
these passbands being much narrower than the passband of the audio spectrum,
and carrying signal amplitude of relatively low levels, as compared to the audio
signal, so as to avoid any interference with the transmission of the voice of
the host 212. Since four separate signal channels are provided for the first
four of the foregoing signals, these signals may be transmitted in any desired
time sequence including a concurrent transmission of a plurality of these signals.
One or more of the signals of the four channels may be retransmitted with an
updated message, such as a reformatted scoring mode, to adapt the game program
to new scoring instructions by the program conductor, or to audience responses,
thereby to provide interaction between the host and the remote audience.
The central station 202 further comprises two signal processors 232 and 234,
the summer 236, a combiner 238, a transmitter 240 and two oscillators 242 and
244 coupled respectively to the processors 232 and 234. The microphone 230 is
connected to a first input terminal of the summer 236. The processor 232 is
connected between the keyboard 224 and a second input terminal of the summer
236 for encoding designated response signals outputted by the keyboard 224,
and for modulating the signals onto a carrier frequency F.sub.1, which carrier
frequency lies in the response signal band of FIG. 10.
Similarly, the processor 234 is connected between the keyboard 226 and a third
input terminal of the summer 236 for coding scoring mode signals outputted by
the keyboard 226, and for modulating these signals onto a carrier frequency
F.sub.2, the carrier frequency F.sub.2 being within the score signal band of
FIG. 10. The summer 236 combines the response and the score signals with the
audio signal of the microphone 230 to output a sum signal to the combiner 238.
The combiner 238 operates in a well-known fashion to combine the audio signal
of the microphone 230 with the video signal of the camera 228 to output a composite
television signal to the transmitter 240 for transmission via antenna 246 as
the broadcast transmission 222.
Each of the processors 232 and 234 are constructed of the same components, these
components being an encoder 248, a register 250, a modulator 252, a band-pass
filter 254, and a clock 256. The operations of both of the processors 232 and
234 are the same and, accordingly, only the operation of the processor 234 need
be described, it being understood that this description applies also to the
processor 232.
In operation, the encoder 248 digitally encodes signals provided by respective
keys 258 of the keyboard 226. The clock 256 outputs both a high speed clock
signal and a low speed clock signal to the register 250. The high speed signal
has a relatively high pulse repetition frequency for strobing bits of a digital
signal outputted by the encoder 248 at a relatively high speed into the register
250. The bits of the digital signal are than outputted from the register 250
at a relatively low rate to the modulator 252 in response to strobing of the
register 250 by the low speed clock signal. This arrangement of the high and
low speed clocking allows a command to be entered at the keyboard 226 rapidly
by the host 212, and then to be transmitted relatively slowly as a component
of the audio signal. The slow transmission minimizes the requisite width of
the score signal passband (FIG. 10). The modulator 252 may employ a suitable
form of modulation as is commonly employed, such as amplitude modulation or
phase modulation, for modulating the digital signal on the F.sub.2 carrier.
The modulated signal outputted by the modulator 252 is then coupled via the
filter 254 to the summer 236, the filter 254 limiting the spectral components
of the modulated signal to the desired passband of FIG. 10. In the same manner,
the processor 232 digitally encodes signals entered by keys 260 of the keyboard
224, and modulates the digitally encoded signals of the designated response
upon the F.sub.1 carrier.
The television system 220 comprises a receiver 262, three demodulators 264,
266, and 268, a speaker 270, two band-pass filters 272 and 274, and two oscillators
276 and 278. Also shown in FIG. 6 is a telephone circuit 280 including a telephone
at the remote station 206 and a telephone at the central station 202 which enable
interaction in the form of direct communication between a member of the remote
audience 216 and a person at the central station 202. The telephone at the central
station 202 enables members of the remote audience 216 to communicate, when
desired, with the host 212, for instance, to furnish their names for announcing
on the air. The telephone circuit 280 is presented as a conveniently implemented
form of communication system, it being understood that such communication is
an optional feature and not essential to the practice of the invention, and
that other forms of communication systems may be employed.
In operation, the receiver 262 receives the broadcast transmission 222 via an
antenna 282, and outputs the received signal to the demodulator 264. The demodulator
264 operates in a well-known fashion to separate the audio and video portions
of the television signal, the audio portion being applied to the speaker 270
and the video portion being presented on the television screen 208. Members
of the remote audience 216 hear the voice of the host 212 on the speaker 270,
and view the progress of the game 218 and other activities of the studio 204
on the screen 208. The filters 272 and 274 separate, respectively, the response
and score signals from the audio spectrum and apply the signals, respectively,
to the demodulator 266 and the demodulator 268. The oscillator 276 provides
the F.sub.1 carrier to the demodulator 266 for demodulation of the response
signal to recover the designate responses. Similarly the oscillator 278 provides
the F.sub.2 carrier to the demodulator 268 to enable the demodulation of the
score signal to recover the scoring mode criteria. The response signal is applied
by the demodulator 266 to the response unit 210 via line 346. The score signal
is outputted by the demodulator 268 to the response unit 210 via line 348.
FIG. 7 shows a modification of the system 200 of FIG. 6 wherein the third and
fourth signals, respectively, for the designated response and scoring mode criteria
are transmitted in the video portion of the television signal rather than in
the audio portion of the television signal. In FIG. 7, the modified system 200A
comprises a central station 202A and a television system 220A which contains
some of the components presented in the system 200 of FIG. 6, and has further
components which provide for an interlacing of the third and the fourth signals
with the television video portion by insertion of the third and the fourth signals
within the time intervals allocated for the television vertical retrace. The
system 200A is understood to include, when desired, the telephone circuit 280,
the game 218, and the specimen 214 which have been deleted in FIG. 7 to simplify
the presentation of the system 200A.
In the central station 202A, the signals outputted by the keyboards 224 and
226 are digitally coded by encoders 284 and 286, respectively, and applied via
an OR circuit 288 to a register 290. The station 202A further comprises a modulator
292 and a summer 294 which operate with the combiner 238 and the transmitter
240. The television camera 228 includes a well-known vidicon 296, oscillator
298 for production of a carrier frequency, and timing and synchronization circuitry
300.
In operation, the encoded response criteria and scoring mode signals of the
keyboards 224 and 226 are stored in the register 290 from which they are applied
to an input terminal of the modulator 292. The modulator 292 is activated by
a pulse signal on line 302 provided by the timing circuitry 300 during each
vertical retrace interval in the generation of the television picture frame
at the camera 228. The modulator 292 receives the encoded keyboard signals and
modulates these signals onto the carrier provided by the oscillator 298, this
carrier being the same carrier employed for carrying the television video signal.
Thereby, the modulated keyboard signals outputted by the modulator 292, and
the television video signal outputted by the camera 228 are on the same carrier,
and are summed together by the summer 294. The output signal of the summer 294
contains both the video and the keyboard signals interleaved with each other.
The output signal of the summer 294 is then combined with the signal of the
microphone 230 by the combiner 238 and transmitted via the transmitter 240 to
a remote receiving station 206A in the same fashion as was described for the
system 200 of FIG. 6.
The broadcast transmission from the central station 202A is received by the
receiver 262 and applied to the demodulator 264 which separates the audio and
video portions of the broadcast transmission, the audio portion being applied
to the speaker 270, and the video portion being applied to a television monitor
304 which includes the television screen 208. The monitor 304 includes well-known
synchronization and timing circuitry 306 which is employed in converting the
broadcast video to a picture presented on the screen 208, the timing circuitry
306 also providing a gate pulse signal on line 308 which is to be used for identifying
the retrace interval so as to enable extraction of the designated response signal
of the keyboard 224 and the scoring mode signal of the keyboard 226.
The television system 220A further comprises a clock 310, two gates 312 and
314, a demodulator 316, a register 318, a switch 320, a flag detector 322, and
two registers 324 and 326.
In operation, the video signal outputted by the demodulator 264 is applied also
via the gate 312 to the demodulator 316 which operates in conjunction with a
carrier reference signal provided by an oscillator 328 to demodulate the signals
of the keyboards 224 and 226. The operation of the demodulator 316 is opposite
to the operation of the modulator 292 in the sense that, by way of example,
if the modulator 292 employs phase modulation, then the demodulator 316 demodulates
phase modulation.
The signal on line 308 activates the gate 312 to pass the modulated keyboard
signals occurring during the retrace intervals, and to block the video signal
appearing at all times other than during the retrace intervals. If desired,
a similar gate (not shown) may be included within the monitor 304 for excluding
the modulated keyboard signals from the monitor 304. Such signals appearing
during the retrace intervals should not interfere with the operation of the
monitor 304 because of the synchronization signals normally present in televised
transmissions, which signals gate off the screen 208 during retrace intervals,
as is well known.
The signal on line 308 also activates the gate 314 to conduct clock pulses from
the clock 310 to the register 318 during each retrace interval. The clock pulses
are employed to clock the digitally encoded keyboard signals from the demodulator
316 into the register 318. Included within each of the digitized keyboard signals
is a digital flag which identifies whether a signal is the designated response
signal of the keyboard 224 or the scoring mode signal of the keyboard 226. The
keyboard signals are communicated from the register 318 via a switch 320 to
the registers 324 and 326. The detector 322 detects the presence of the flag
on digital signals outputted by the register 318, and operates the switch 320
to steer the designated response signals of the keyboard 224 to the register
324, and the scoring mode signals of the keyboard 226 to the register 326. The
registers 324 and 326 provide the keyboard signals to the response unit 210
for operation of the response unit 210 in a manner to be described.
With reference to FIG. 8, the response unit 210 receives the designated response
criteria signals and the scoring mode signals, the signals being stored in memory
for evaluating answers of the members of the remote audience 216 (FIG. 6) in
responding to tasks set forth in the studio 204. In order to facilitate explanation
of the response unit 210, the memory which stores data of the designated response
criteria and the scoring mode, is shown as three separate memories, namely,
a program memory 330 which stores instructions for operation of the response
unit 210, a response-criteria memory 332 which stores a set of data-defining
acceptable or designated responses to be used as a reference against which audience
response is to be judged, and a further scoring program memory 334 which stores
coefficients or values of difficulty levels employed in the scoring of audience
responses. A timing unit 336 is employed for interjecting a scoring factor based
on the amount of time required or allowed to generate the response, and to apply
zero credit in the situation wherein a member of the remote audience fails to
respond within a predesignated time interval. The response unit 210 includes
four decoders 338, 340, 342, and 344 which extract various portions of the digitized
designated response criteria signal and scoring mode signal for application
to individual ones of the memories 330 and 332, the timing unit 336 and the
memory 334. The decoders 338 and 340 connect lines 348 and 346, carrying the
scoring-mode and response-criteria signals, respectively, to the memories 330
and 332. The decoders 342 and 344 connect from line 348, carrying the scoring
mode signal, respectively to the timing unit 336 and the memory 334. The decoder
344 may be coupled directly to the memory 334, or via an OR gate which will
be described with reference to FIG. 23. To facilitate the present explanation
of this embodiment of the invention, it is presumed that the decoder 344 is
connected directly to the memory 334.
Also included within the response unit 210 is a control logic unit 350, a clock
352 which provides clock pulse signals to the control logic unit 350 and the
timing unit 336 and an OR circuit 354 which couples the decoder 342 to the timing
unit 336. A keyboard 356 and, if desired, a display 358 coupled thereto interact
with the control logic unit 350 for the entry of responses, the display 358
showing a member of the remote audience what symbols have been typed on the
keyboard 356 during the generation of a response.
The response unit 210 further comprises a dispenser 360 of cards 362 and/or
tape 364, or similar recording medium, which are imprinted with marking reflecting
awards, if any, for responses entered by a member of the remote audience upon
the keyboard 356. For example, the dispenser 360 can accept a preprinted form
which may be inserted by a respondent and removed from the dispenser 360 after
imprinting. Also, the response unit 210 comprises a buffer store 366, a register
368, a scoring logic unit 370, two comparators 372 and 374, two registers 376
and 378, two multipliers 380 and 382, a summer 384, an accumulator 386 for accumulating
scores, and an accumulator 387 for accumulating values of a succession of awards.
In operation, the program memory 330 and the control logic unit 350 operate
together in a manner similar to that of the program memory 108 and the control
logic unit 118 of FIG. 4. The program memory 330 stores information as to the
number of possible responses, the number of questions, and also stores instructions
for commanding the dispenser to print out messages in accordance with scores
based on responses to questions and other tasks set forth in the studio 204.
The memory 332 stores possible answers to questions and tasks, such as colors
of objects displayed in the studio 204, sizes of such objects, sentences or
phrases describing events in history, science, music, art or literature, listings,
names and similar information which may be transmitted via the response criteria
signal to the remote stations. The timing unit 336 includes counters and memories
as will be described with reference to FIG. 9 for outputting appropriate factors
or coefficients for use in scoring responses based on time of response. The
memory 334 stores designated time intervals which are to be inputted as preset
signals to the counters of the timing unit 336, and also stores factors to be
applied in the scoring or grading of responses based on level of difficulty.
Such level of difficulty information is transmitted from the central station
via the scoring mode signal to the remote stations. After presentation of a
task in the studio 204, the host 212 indicates the beginning of a time interval
for audience response by pressing a key on the keyboard 226, this resulting
in the transmission of a start signal to the response unit 210. The decoder
342 decodes the start signal and applies the start signal via the OR circuit
354 to initiate timing in the timing unit 336, the start signal proceeding through
the timing unit 336 to the control logic unit 350 to initiate operation of the
logic unit 350. Operation of the three memories 330, 332, and 334 is under control
of the logic unit 350.
In one type of question-response situation, the host 212 gives a contestant
a choice of questions to which the contestant is to respond. For example, two
or three groups of questions may be presented on the television screen 208.
The answers to all of the questions are loaded into the memory 332. The contestant
indicates a selection of a group of questions by means of the keyboard 356,
a selection signal then being outputted by the keyboard 356 to the logic unit
350 to address the memory 332 to provide the desired set of answers for evaluating
the contestant's response.
While various forms of responses may be desired for specific situations which
may be depicted in the studio 204, two situations of particular interest are
those wherein a response is to be evaluated based on a significant element of
the response such as a series of words, as in a phrase, or by examination of
key words present in a phrase or sequence of sentences to be provided as a response.
The response unit 210 is provided with dual channel comparison to score responses
based on observation of key words or on observation of full text. One of these
channels is composed of the comparator 372, the register 376, and the multiplier
380. The other of these two channels is composed of the comparator 374, the
register 378, and the multiplier 382. Both of these comparator channels operate
in the same fashion.
The first comparator channel is employed for evaluating responses based on the
presence of a key word. This is accomplished as follows. A member of the remote
audience presses a key-word logic unit the keyboard 356 to alert the control
logic unit 350 that a key word is to be entered. The key word is typed on the
keyboard 356 which then places the key word in the buffer store 366 and, preferably,
also presents the key word on the display 358 to ensure that the key word is
spelled correctly. The buffer store 366, under control of the logic unit 350,
presents the key word to one input terminal of the comparator 372. The memory
332 presents the designated key word to the other input terminal of the comparator
372. The comparator 372 compares the designated key word with the response,
and outputs a logic-1 signal to the register 376 to indicate a favorable comparison.
If the key word of the response differs from the key word of the memory 332,
then the comparator 372 outputs a logic-0 signal to the register 376. The memory
334 outputs a predetermined number of points of credit to the register 376 for
an at least partially correct or acceptable response. The outputting of the
logic-1 signal from the comparator 372 strobes the register 376 to receive the
credit from the memory 334. The number of points of credit are outputted by
the register 376 to the multiplier 380 to serve as a factor or coefficient in
computing the score for a correct answer. The timing unit 336 outputs a further
factor to the multiplier 380 based on the amount of time consumed to produce
the response. The multiplier 380 multiplies together both the acceptable-answer
coefficient and the time-consumption coefficient to output a product to the
summer 384, which product is the score for the response. The amount of credit
in the credit factor outputted by the timing unit 336 is dependent on the amount
of time; in the event that a maximum time interval is exceeded, the timing credit
is zero which results in a score of zero being outputted by the multiplier 380.
By way of alternative embodiments, it is noted that the multipliers 380 and
382 may be replaced with summers, in which case the score would be based upon
the sum of the acceptable-answer coefficient and the time-consumption coefficient.
The actual range of numerical values of the score will differ, depending on
whether multiplication or addition of the acceptable-answer coefficient and
the time-consumption coefficient is to be employed in the construction of the
response unit 210. Either embodiment of the response unit 210 produces a readily
understandable score; the embodiment to be employed is simply a matter of preference
in desired range of score values.
In the same fashion, the comparator 374 compares a full text, as in a series
of words composing a phrase, which text is compared by the comparator 374 against
the text entered at the keyboard 356 by way of response. The corresponding scoring
factors are applied by the memory 334 and the timing unit 336, respectively,
to the register 378 and the multiplier 382. The comparator 374 strobes the register
378 to apply a scoring factor to the multiplier 382 to apply a scoring factor
to the multiplier 382 to the summer 384. A sequence of scores outputted by the
summer 384 in response to a sequence of responses to a task or game situation
presented in the studio 204 are accumulated by the accumulator 386. The output
of the accumulator 386 is the total score, which total score is inputted both
to the dispenser 360 and to the scoring logic unit 370. The accumulator 386
is reset by the control logic unit 350 (at terminal R) in accordance with commands
of the scoring mode signal. Thus, the total score outputted by the accumulator
386 may be the result of response to questions of a single task or of a sequence
of tasks as may be commanded by the program host.
In the scoring logic unit 370, the total score is program memory 330. The scoring
logic unit 370 outputs a command signal to the dispenser unit 360 when the respondent's
score meets the response criteria or is in a designated range, and the dispenser
360 prints the total score. Also, when the total score is within an acceptable
range of score, the logic unit 370 directs the dispenser 360 to print a monetary
award, or other designation of award on either the card 362 or the tape 364,
and may activate a bell to signal success. Sounding of the bell may also be
used to direct a respondent to begin the next task. Dispenser 360 may be designed
for either one or both types of printouts. If desired, the tape or card may
be perforated to allow a portion thereof to be retained by a contestant while
the balance would be presented at a redemption center for an award. The award
and other information, such as time limits for redemption, instructions to the
merchant and a coded validation signal, are applied by the memory 330 to the
register 368 for inclusion in the printout of the dispenser 360. By way of example,
the validation signal may be encoded with the time of day and date of the television
program and be combined with a number identifying the remote station or user.
The identity of the remote station is supplied by an encoder 388 (which may
a thumbwheel digital encoder) to the register 368 for inclusion within the printout
of the dispenser 360. The buffer store 366 also connects to the register 368
to permit imprinting at least a portion of the actual response in a printout
of the dispenser 360. Printers 390 and 392 within the dispenser 360 can provide
for imprinting in the form of alphanumeric and symbolic indicia, or by means
of bar code or color code. By way of example, the printers 390 and 392 may be
constructed as dot-matrix printers. If desired, printer 390 may be constructed
to output the printed message on a magnetic strip (not shown) of the card 362.
The keyboard 356 is provided with a "text" key as well as a "word" key to enable
a respondent to answer in the text mode or in the key-word mode. By the inclusion
of alphanumeric keys, as in a standard typewriter keyboard, a person may respond
by entering key words or phrases. A respondent may answer a question in significantly
less time than is allocated for the question, in which case the respondent may
wish to indicate task completion before the full allotted time has elapsed,
or before the host 212 (FIG. 6) tells the audience to proceed to the next question.
In this case, the respondent pushes the "next answer" key or button on the keyboard
356 resulting in the transmission of a strobe signal along line 394 to an input
terminal of the OR circuit 354 to restart the timing unit 336 for the next question
and answer. Also, in the event that there is a choice of questions and responses,
each at a different level of difficulty, the respondent employs the "difficulty
level" button on the keyboard 356 to signify, via the control logic unit 350,
to the program memory 334 that an answer of a designated difficulty is being
attempted. Thereby, the memory 334 in conjunction with the timing unit 336 can
provide proper scoring factors for various conditions of response such as accuracy
and a shortening of the time interval set by the host. Generally, in determining
the value of award to a successful contestant, some or all of the following
factors are taken into consideration, namely, the quality of response as evidenced
by accuracy, responsiveness, comprehension and comprehensiveness, as well as
speed of response and difficulty level.
Normally, the difficulty level announced by the host will be "difficulty level
one", with which a certain award is associated. Correspondingly greater awards
may be announced for correct answers at higher difficulty levels. The choice
of selecting such higher difficulty level rests with the contestants and may,
where a choice of subject matters is offered, be made after the host has announced
the general subject matter or the nature of the next question.
After participating in a number of games or other projects, each of which has
resulted in the awarding to the respondent of a prize or award of significant
monetary value, it may be desirable to total the value of all of the awards
for a grand total award. The accumulator 387 provides this function. The accumulator
387 is connected to the scoring logic unit 370 to receive success ones of the
dollar amount of the respective awards, or other measure of value of the awards
such as a credit toward free trips by an airplane or days on a cruise. The accumulator
387 sums the values of the successive awards and, upon demand from the scoring
logic unit 370, outputs the grand total award via the logic unit 370 to the
dispenser 360 to be imprinted on a hard copy record dispensed by the dispenser
360.
FIG. 9 shows details of the timing unit 336 of FIG. 8, the timing unit 336 comprising
two counters 396 and 398, and two memories 400 and 402 wherein each of the memories
400 and 402 is preferably a read-only memory (ROM). The counters 396 and 398
are preset, as noted above, by signals from the program memory 334 of FIG. 8.
The counters 396 and 398 count clock pulses supplied by the clock 352. Each
of the counters 396 and 398 counts down from address, respectively, the memories
400 and 402. Output counts of each of the counters 396 and 398 also serve as
address signals for operating the program memory 330. Counting by the counters
396 and 398 is initiated upon application of the start signal from the OR circuit
354, the start signal being outputted to the control logic unit 350. Each of
the memories 400 and 402 is loaded with appropriate values of credit to be applied
to responses, respectively, for key words or numbers and full text. For example,
a question answered by a key word in ten seconds might receive a time credit
factor of ten points, while a 20-second response time might receive only three
points, and any response beyond a half minute might receive a zero points resulting
in a zero score. It is noted that a count by either of the counters 396 or 398
from its preset value down to zero automaticallay terminates an allocated predetermined
time interval and results in an outputting of zero score.
The foregoing circuitry allows the
response unit to operate, if desired, by presenting a predetermined credit,
based on time to respond and on accuracy of response by way of example, to a
contestant at the time when a question is asked. Deductions in score are made
for excessive time, incomplete answers or inaccurate answers, by way of example.
This is accomplished by the counters 396 (FIG. 9) which count down with increasing
time to address the memories 400 and 402 to output a time dependent credit.
Inaccuracies effect the final score by virtue of the operation of the comparators
372 and 74 (FIG. 8). An incomplete answer, due to a failure to answer certain
parts of a question, results in a reduced output from the accumulator 386.
With respect to the system and methodology of the invention, communication with
the home audience by the normal television channels of electronic transmission
includes signals broadcast on television frequencies via cable including fiber
optics or satellite. A typical example in the propagation of such electronic
signals would be that transmission to a communication satellite which, in turn,
transmits the signals to ground receiving sites adapted to send the signals
either from broadcast stations over the air or via cable to cable subscribers.
These signals include the first two signals of Group One mentioned hereinabove,
namely the program and the task signals, received by the television receivers
at each of the remote locations at which a television viewer is located. Encouragement
of as many viewers as possible to participate is accomplished by allowing the
television viewers to become contestants who participate in a quiz program or
other audience-participation program on the spur of the moment and in the middle
of a program wherein the participants win prizes.
A number of versions of the invention in the operation of a sweepstakes system
will now be described. According to one embodiment, instructional signals transmitted
to all remote locations include signals which, if matching, or bearing a correlation
to, symbols on said hard copy record, qualify a participant for a special or
sweepstake prize. If, for example, a coupon having previously provided alphanumeric
or other symbols is issued to a participant who has entered an acceptable response,
such participant qualifies for a sweepstake prize if the said symbols on such
coupon are the same or have a correlation, namely, a defined relationship to
certain sweepstakes symbols. The symbols on the coupon may be in the form of
preprinted sequential numbers, and the sweepstakes symbols may be transmitted
from a central location as part of the instructional signals directing the printer
to print the sweepstake symbols. In that event, a successful contestant discerns
immediately whether he or she has qualified for a sweepstakes prize. Alternatively,
the sweepstakes symbols are provided to a place where winning records are redeemed,
such as banks or supermarkets, and a person presenting a coupon for redemption
learns only at this place and point in time that he or she has won a special
prize or sweepstake.
The term "correlation" refers to a predetermined relationship of alphanumeric
or other symbols provided on hard copy records and identifying sweepstake awards,
whether or not such relationship is expressed in mathematical terms. Thus, the
indicia identifying a winning coupon and a sweepstake award may be deemed to
be correlated if they are identical or if they meet a predetermined mathematical
formula or other definition. The specific correlation entitling a coupon holder
to a sweepstakes prize may be known or discernible only at a redemption center.
In such an instance, a contestant having been issued a winning coupon will ascertain
whether or not a a sweepstake prize has been won only after presenting a winning
coupon at a supermarket or other redemption center.
Even if the sweepstakes symbols are transmitted to the home of a contestant
and are immediately printed on a winning coupon, the following method may be
employed to compel such contestant to visit a redemption center, such as a supermarket
in order to ascertain whether he or she has won a sweepstakes prize. This is
achieved by selecting and providing sweepstakes symbols which are not identical
to the symbols of a winning coupon, but bear a previously identified relationship.
As an example, if a stipulated percentage of a plurality of alphanumeric elements
on a winning coupon matches the elements of sweepstakes symbols, a sweepstakes
prize may be awarded. Such prize can be larger, if a larger number of elements
comprising the award symbols is matched by the sweepstakes symbols.
In another modification of the method, the winning coupon symbols and the sweepstakes
symbols may have no discernible relationship. Any desired correlation between
the sets of symbols may be devised, such as a zero relationship, wherein the
two sets of symbols have no common elements, or a previously defined formula
may be employed wherein for example the symbols are numbers and the sweepstake
number is half the winning coupon number.
Sweepstakes symbols determined at a central location may be provided electronically
or otherwise to redemption centers, together, when required, with a formula
for identifying an acceptable correlation with symbols on a winning coupon,
thus identifying such a coupon as one qualifying for sweepstakes prize.
According to the method of the invention, the number of prizes awarded and their
values are set by the sponsor of the program, and normally are set so as to
optimize the financial return to the sponsor or broadcaster. Normally, in a
quiz program, a plurality of tasks will be presented. Each task is formulated
in such form that the task setting message may be electronically transmitted
from the central location as the second signals or second set of signals of
the aforementioned Group One to be received by the viewers at the remote locations.
It is noted that all of the signals comprising Group One may be transmitted
at the same time, such as by being part of the same pictorial presentation.
A simple illustration of such presentation would involve a celebrity appearing
before a television camera, holding a sign reading "Who am I?".
Typically, these tasks comprise questions to be answered by viewers who wish
to become contestants. The tasks may differ with respect to fields of knowledge,
memory skills and reaction speed, literacy, comprehension, expression and experience
required, and other aspects. The time allowed viewers to respond to a task may
vary. The task may take any form of questions including single-answer questions
and multiple-part questions. The questions may also call for one or more multiple
choice answers. There may be a requirement that, with respect to a specific
task, a minimum number of responses must be provided by participants. The questions
may also be open-ended in the sense that viewers can not completely answer a
question within an allotted time, a practice common in aptitude tests. A task
could, for instance, involve a listing of a large number of names or other data
in response to a question to which the answers are more numerous than can be
answered within the prescribed time. Normally, the host announces the period
of time allowed for entering answers at the time a question is posed. At substantially
the same time, the host or other person aiding in the program, may also announce
or hint at the general subject area of the next question, the purpose of such
announcement being to enable a contestant to elect a higher difficulty level
to apply to a favored subject area. Thus, the response criteria may consist
of a simple requirement to be met by a respondent, or may comprise a plurality
of independently variable elements.
Questions may also be asked by a host in conjunction with television advertisements
or "commercials". In such an event, a host or off-camera announcer may first
direct the attention of the audience to the fact that the next question will
deal with an aspect or feature of the product or service about to be displayed
or offered. Awards may also be announced. This type of incentive will significantly
increase viewers' attention and recall.
Questions may also be visually posed to the television viewers by displaying
the questions on electronic boards or on other display means. Alternatively,
the host may silently point to an advertised item of merchandise to insure that
participants are paying attention to the television commercial, in which event
a question may relate to such merchandise. The awarding of prizes to viewers
who correctly answer questions relating to goods or services shown in a preceding
commercial is believed to greatly enhance consumer recall.
It is noted that a question asked with reference to an offered item may call
for no more than a simple mention of the specimen displayed, or of specific
features thereof. There is little or no difficulty in responding to such question
posed to the viewers, so that in effect, the viewers are simply verifying that
they are tuned in to the desired program. This method can be employed when discontinued
items, or "loss leaders", are intended to lead customers to a store, in which
case more valuable prizes ar awarded for relatively easy answers.
The range of difficulty levels needs no specific limitation. As an illustration,
one may consider the task of listing within a period of 20 seconds as many countries
as possible that are members of the United Nations.
The award or prize won by a successful contestant is computed in accordance
with the response criteria and the scoring basis or mode which may be formulated
by the host or program conductor. As noted above, the response criteria and
the scoring mode or basis are transmitted from a central station to remote locations
through the response-criteria and scoring-mode signals of the aforementioned
Group Two. Specific and different response criteria may be set for each question,
and may include a different time period allowed for such response. The instructional
group of signals, Group Two, conveys the data constituting an acceptable answer
or range of answers, as well as the value of the award to be given a successful
contestant based on the applicable difficulty level, the accuracy and completeness
of the answer to be provided. The elements of the response criteria may be varied
from question to question.
The instructional group of signals, Group Two, may also contain, as a subset,
additional command signals such as the above-noted validation signal to permit
certification and verification of an award claimed by a contestant or member
of the remote audience. Such data typically consists of alphanumeric information
appearing on the contestant's printout to facilitate verification, but may also
consist of coded data or symbols which are machine-readable in the place of
redemption.
The instructional group of signals may also contain, as another subset, further
additional command signals addressed to the scoring circuitry, which additional
signals convey data governing the issue of the printout and its terms, including
place of redemption and time limitations. A printout from the dispenser 360
may also serve as a voucher to be exchanged for a ticket at a theater or sporting
event.
The invention may be employed for conducting a sweepstake with results dependent
on skill and knowledge of contestants. The printout provides a record of responses
to insure that those who have successfully responded to an earlier question
are properly responding to a later question. Awards for the sweepstake can be
based on a selected difficulty level, so that those who are more knowledgeable
get higher winnings.
As an example of various forms of programming which may be employed, questions
are displayed on an electronic board seen by the television viewers. Alternatively,
a question appears on a display board in the television studio and a plurality
of numbered answers appear on a separate display so that a television contestant
only needs to enter the number of the selected answer believed to correspond
to an acceptable answer and to the response criteria. The latter type of visual
presentation is particularly suitable for game shows involving multiple choice
answers. Particularly successful, or otherwise selected participants, may engage
in a personal dialogue with the host.
It is noted that members of the studio audience may also participate in the
quiz program. In such event, one display may contain questions for the home
viewing audiences, while the studio contestants may be asked a different set
of questions. In such a situation, effectively, two separate quiz programs are
being conducted substantially concurrently.
In conducting such television program, provisions may also be made to announce
and/or display to the television audience information regarding awards that
are to be won at different difficulty levels. This information may be provided
before, during, or after the corresponding question has been asked, although
it normally is made known to viewers at approximately the time that the question
is asked. As an illustration, a split television screen technique may be employed
wherein part of the screen displays information and/or pictures relating to
the question being asked, and another part of the screen displays a table having
tabulated information showing a relationship between difficulty levels, and
available prizes or discounts from the base price towards the purchase of certain
merchandise. If desired, a portion of the split-screen presentation may be hidden
from the studio audience. The host announces the number of difficulty levels
and the general subject area relative to each question. The host may also announce
the base or minimum difficulty level applicable to a specific question so that
each contestant has sufficient time to elect to respond under the conditions
of the difficulty level set by the host or under conditions of a higher difficulty
level. In accordance with the foregoing elected situations, requisite command
signals of the instructional signal group, Group Two, are transmitted for directing
the dispenser to print out such tabulated award data. Successful participants
may be informed of the fact that they have won an award via the audio or video
portion of the television signal, or by directing the dispenser to print out
a message describing the award. The record or other signal by which a contestant
is informed of the outcome of his or her response may be simply "award" or "no
award" announcement, or a similar simple notification.
As a further feature in the construction of the invention, the scoring-mode
signal generated at the keyboard 226 (FIG. 6) for use in the program memory
330 and scoring logic unit 370 (FIG. 8) may include a delay signal interposed
by the host which delays operation of the bell as well as a printing out of
notification of award by the dispenser 360 until after a determined time interval.
This encourages contestants and viewers to continue watching the television
program until the program, or a portion thereof, has been completed.
It is also noted that the card 362 with data encrypted by use of bar code or
color code or magnetic recording can be machine readable. This permits use of
the card in an automatic dispenser of merchandise at a store wherein such merchandise
is dispensed. The dispensing machinery would include a well known card reader
and verification circuitry which may operate with a personal identification
number known only to the contestant to insure that the merchandise is dispensed
to the correct person. It is also noted that the pertinent information can be
given over the telephone to allow for purchases by mail.
Another interaction between members of the remote audience and the host is accomplished
by means of the optional two-way communication afforded by use of the telephone
circuit 280 (FIG. 6) in combination with the signal channels of the television
transmission. For example, the host 212 may be a professor conducting a home-study
course. The host presents a set of examination questions to home students via
the television screen, and transmits various possible responses and scoring
criteria via lines 346 and 348 (FIG. 8) to the response unit 280. Students may
call in via the telephone circuit 280 to inform the host that the questions
relate to material not yet fully covered in the course. The host then operates
the keyboard 224 (FIG. 6) to reformat or modify the possible responses, transmitted
via line 346, so that the students can give an acceptable response based on
the material already covered in the course. In addition, the host operates the
keyboard 226 to reformat the mode of scoring to provide a different distribution
of score points for various key words and phrases. Further alteration in the
mode of scoring can accomplished, by the host, by operation of the keyboard
226 to alter the amount of time allocated to each question. The difficulty levels
stored in the memory 334 may also be altered or reformatted by the host so as
to provide a curving of the score distribution to give extra credit to those
students who studied course materials in advance of the present curriculum.
The foregoing example in the teaching of a home-study course shows an aspect
in the methodology of the invention in which a succession of instructional signals
relating to designating acceptable responses and scoring criteria to be applied
to responses may be transmitted from the central station 202 to remote receiving
stations 206. In a general case, such a succession of instructional signals
would be interleaved with communications from persons at the remote stations
206 to the central station 202 to enable the response criteria to be modified
to fit the needs of the remote audience. This provides further interaction between
the host and the remote audience. Similar interaction is possible between a
person conducting research and members of a focus group or other sample populations.
This type of interaction is helpful in eliciting consumer reactions in qualitative
research and other reaction eliciting programs.
As a further example in the modification of scoring criteria, the studio audience
and the remote audience may be engaged in a program for the development of foreign
language skills. The host, in this case a language instructor, may submit a
set of questions requiring responses in the form of phrases for describing situations
depicted in a studio game. If members of the studio audience experience difficulty
in answering the questions, then the host would use the keyboards 224 and 226
to modify the scoring criteria, before complaints from the remote audience arrive
via the telephone circuit 280. In this example, a succession of instructional
signals may be transmitted without direct interaction with the remote audience,
and with modification of response criteria and/or scoring mode being based on
response of the studio or external audience. In this way, the format of acceptable
responses can be updated at the response units 210 in the remote stations 206
in anticipation of remote audience needs. The response unit 210 stores the modified
scoring criteria in the memories 330, 332 and 334, the contents of these memories
being updated with each transmission of an instructional signal. The operation
of the response unit 210 in scoring answers entered by a contestant to a language
development game, or other form of game, is based on the most recently transmitted
instructional signal.
By way of further embodiment to the invention, it is noted that the tape 364
(FIGS. 6 and 8) outputted by the dispenser 360 of the response unit 310 may
be imprinted with a bar code, as portrayed in FIG. 6. The bar code may be read
by a scanner 404. The reading of the scanner 404 may be transmitted to a receiver
406 at the central station 202 via modems 408 and 410 connected to the telephone
circuit 280. Further example in the communication from a receiving station at
a remote location to a central station will be described with reference to FIG.
22 wherein information as to a person's response can be outputted from the response
unit 210 as digital signals and transformed by a modem to a signal format suitable
for transmission via a telephone circuit, such as the circuit 280. The use of
modems and a telephone circuit serves as an example in the practice of the invention
for communication electronically from a remote receiving station to a central
station, it being understood that other forms (not shown) of electronic or electro-optical
communication may be employed.
The foregoing examples in the use of the invention show that the system and
methodology of the invention are adaptable to the needs of members of the remote
audience. Adaptation can take place by interaction with members of the remote
audience, as well as by anticipation of the needs of the remote audience based
on observation of responses of the studio audience. This enhances the quality
of audience participation, ensures better success in accomplishing the purposes
of the television games, and elicits greater satisfaction on the part of both
studio and remote audiences.
With reference to FIGS. 1 and 6, it is noted by way of alternative embodiments
of the invention that the use of both audio and visual channels, and the use
of both television and radio transmissions permits various transmission arrangements
to be employed. For example, instead of employing one central television transmitter
and one central radio transmitter, as shown in FIG. 1, a network of such transmitters
can be employed for transmitting the program from the studio 14 throughout an
entire country. In the case of the transmission of the instructional signal
by radio, in a network transmission, individual radio stations might alter the
instructional signals for different scoring criteria and rewards in different
geographic areas while all geographic areas would receive the same television
program and task-setting messages. By way of further variation of transmission
arrangements, the voice signal of the announcer at the studio can be be stopped,
and replaced by voice signals at the radio transmitters of the various geographic
areas to allow different task-setting messages to be generated audibly at the
different geographic areas along with the different instructional signals at
the various geographic areas. These variations of transmission arrangements
provide a flexibility to the implementation of the invention so as to adapt
the task-setting and scoring to needs of local areas.
It is also noted that the invention can be employed even in the situation wherein
television may not be available to some members of the remote audience. With
reference to the receiving station 16 of FIG. 1, in the absence of any television
transmission (possibly due to mountains) or in the absence of television sets,
the host 50 (FIG. 3) would describe audibly and fully the program situation
by use of the microphone 56, and would also present the tasks audibly by the
microphone 56. Thereby, both the audio description and the instructional signals
would be transmitted by radio channel.
Also, the microphone 56 may be shut off in which case all task-setting messages
would be indicated visually, as by signs and posters, on the television screens
of the receiving stations. In this case, the audio channel would be used only
for the instructional signals while the program would be conducted silently
on the television screens.
Furthermore, the program can be conducted silently, as above, with occasional
audio commentary and/or background music, a television format commonly employed
by cable television news services. In this case the program and task-setting
messages would be transmitted by television with visual presentation of the
tasks by signs or posters with the microphone 56 being used only for the occasional
comment and playing of background music.
The foregoing situation can be modified further by the substitution of the normal
television program format by presentation of a television screen showing only
lines of alphanumeric characters, similar to that of a printed portion of a
magazine or newspaper. Such a format is used frequently in cable television
news by broadcasts employing a channel known as an automated channel. With reference
to FIG. 6, the automated channel can be implemented, by way of example, by use
of a display system including a character generator (not shown) for generating
the text, and a screen (not shown) for presenting the text in front of the camera
228 to be televised. Or the television signals may be generated by a suitably
programmed computer (not shown). With respect to the implementation of the invention
for broadcast of a quiz program by use of an automated channel, the following
observations are noted.
Normally, automated channels are used in cable television to provide information
in visual alphanumeric or graphic form, utilizing a character generator, and
transmitting news updates, financial news, program guides, catalog-shopping
and price information, weather information and the like. If computer type storage
is provided at receiving stations, text displayed in this manner on screens
at receiving stations may be scrolled in a desired direction. A voice or music
audio portion accompanies the visual information.
The automated channel type of television broadcast lends itself well to the
presentation of questions and falls within the scope of the present invention.
A program of the type described, which soon will be available as HOMEQUIZ, a
trademark of Response Reward Systems of Vero Beach, Fla., and may consist entirely
of questions, or the questions may be interspersed with the types of information
listed above. As an example, a question is displayed on the screens at remote
locations for the period of time allowed for answering the question, after which
the data entering devices do no accept contestants, responses. The correct of
a series of acceptable answers then appear on the screens for an interval of
time enabling contestants to ascertain whether they have won an award as evidenced
by a printout emitted by the dispenser. Alternatively, correct answers may be
provided orally by a program conductor. Such broadcast requires only very limited
studio facilities and is economical to produce. In this and other types of programs,
the electronic equipment at remote locations can be very simple, providing only
for "yes" or "no" answers, or can be as complex as is desired.
The type of question and answer broadcast on automated channels lends itself
particularly well to education and research. In the field of education, after
a time interval allowed for answering a question has expired, a correct answer
may be provided orally or visually by the program host, and may be accompanied
by extensive explanations and narratives. This method still enables students
to mail or deliver examination papers dispensed to them by the electronic printer
in the above-described dispenser to an educational institution conducting the
test. Such examination forms have printed thereon each student's scored answers.
The use of automated channels permits the implementation of the methods described
in a highly economical manner, particularly in the area of education of children.
Incentives can be provided to children to take an interest in subjects to be
taught by rewarding successful answers to questions which dispenses tokens,
such as coupons, carrying an award of interest to children of the age group
addressed. The increasing familiarity of children with computer keyboards makes
the use of data entering devices a simple task. In the field of use of research,
free-standing questions on automated channels may be interspersed with questions
pertaining to research conducted. Some questions on automated channels are phrased
so that the answers will provide statistically or otherwise meaningful responses,
while other questions contain a challenge inherent in answering such a question.
For example, a question may require personal judgment, special knowledge, or
characterization.
As a further example, a demographic researcher may intersperse between questions
regarding respondent's income and expenditures the question "What is the average
annual per capita income in your county?". A successful respondent wins an award
in order to encourage wider participation in such a survey. In market research,
the ability to leave a printed text on a cable television screen for a period
of time, and to accompany a question with an oral explanation will not only
make respondent's answers to such questions easier and therefore more reliable,
but will make the conducting of surveys or automated channels a very economical
method of reaching unprecedented numbers of respondents.
The methods and systems described above may advantageously be employed to attract
television viewers to interactive programs, sometimes referred to as "Videotex"
programs, in which prerecorded listings and information pertaining to merchandise
and services are displayed on the TV-screens of viewers.
Typically, in the operation of such programs, prerecorded listings of available
products would be televised and displayed on the TV-screens of remote viewers.
The homes of such viewers would be wired, permitting individual ones of said
viewers, utilizing well-known means for electronically transmitting signals
to a central receiving station, to indicate a category or item of merchandise
or services of particular interest, regarding which a viewer wishes to receive
additional information. Such interactive means may transmit viewers request
signals over wires or over the air. The additional information may include pictures
of merchandise selected, prices, costs, performance characteristics, capacities,
capabilities, sizes, colors, accessories, warranties and descriptions. Viewers
might also select listings of product groups, similar products within a specified
price range, products offered by one company or in one retail outlet, or firms
offering a specified product within a geographic area. A request for more detailed
information may, for example, produce a full page of specifications, along with
a picture or pictures of one specific item of merchandise.
In a typical embodiment of implementing such a method, a manufacturer of goods
or a supplier of services is given the opportunity to contract with the producer
of an interactive broadcast program for the insertion of questions among the
product data and offerings comprising the television program. Such questions
can for example be interspersed between announcements pertaining to products
offered by suppliers. The knowledge on the part of TV-viewers that meaningful
prizes will be awarded for satisfactorily answering questions will result in
attracting additional TV-viewers. Commercials by suppliers of products may be
inserted into the listings and questions may relate directly to the commercial
shown, which commercial may be a still photograph, A question may follow such
a commercial. TV-viewers may be informed prior to the commercial that a question
will follow the next commercial and will deal with the commercial. This technique
will ensure that the television audience will pay close attention to such a
commercial, especially if a valuable prize may be won at one of the aforementioned
difficulty levels. Thus, the method described can be a potent advertising and
promotional tool in the context of such an interactive program. Prizes awarded
TV-viewers may be discounts on the products offered during the show.
Frequently, in television programs listing items of merchandise and services
available to viewers, sometimes referred to as Videotext, interested viewers
who are potential buyers have the opportunity to request additional or supplemental
information over cable connections such as cable or telephone connections used
for home computers. The purpose of such additional information is to help potential
buyers to make up their minds whether the item is of interest. Additional listings
requested can be progressively more detailed and can provide information of
interest pertaining to an item of merchandise or services, such as information
where such merchandise or services may be obtainable, alternatives and competitive
items and specifics such as prices, size, colors, capacities, performance, and
other related information. It is in the interest of the producers of such shows
which are frequently sponsored by advertisers, to induce viewers to call up
additional information in the form of lists, specification sheets, pictures
and other pertinent data. It therefore is an object of the method described
to hold viewers interest and to induce them to request more detailed and specific
information which may lead to a purchase decision. To achieve this, one or more
questions are interspersed in successive presentations of said items of merchandise
or services. The method follows and employs the steps enumerated in connection
with the methods hereinbefore described. The question and the response criteria,
as well as the ultimate answer to such a question are transmitted over the cable
connection used in the television transmission.
In order to further induce participation in such television shows, the methodology
of awarding prizes can be based on the required accumulation of credits for
acceptable answers, i. e. on the requirement that, in order to win a prize,
a participant must enter an acceptable answer to two or more questions. In such
an instance, if a viewer answers a question correctly, the credit for such an
acceptable answer is computed and stored at a viewer's remote location. If the
producer of the show has determined that more than one acceptable answer is
required to win a prize, viewers are informed, as part of the television program,
that either a certain number of acceptable answers must be entered or that a
certain cumulative total of credits must be earned to qualify for a prize. The
scoring mode in this instance provide for coefficients in computing a total
score which becomes progressively larger with each subsequent question. For
instance, a viewer who continues to watch the program and ultimately answers
three questions in an acceptable fashion, which can only be accomplished having
called up at least two additional presentations of the offer, may win ten times
the amount of the prize that would have been won for answering only the first
of the three questions correctly.
The system provides for storing and accumulating credits for acceptable answers
until either the end of the program or until either the end of the program or
until the total number of questions has been reached. The producer of the show
may announce to the viewers at any stage of the program how many questions will
be asked and what scoring mode will be employed in the event more than one question
is answered, including additional credits earned by answering questions at higher
difficulty levels.
By way of further example, a television game show is conducted by another method
providing at a central location the previous described transmitting facilities
and providing at TV-viewers' remote locations response units, including comparison
and scoring circuits with provisions for allocating credits at different difficulty
levels. A plurality of questions is asked in the course of the show, acceptable
answers being defined by response criteria at a basic difficulty level and at
least one higher difficulty level, at which an acceptable answer earns a larger
number of credits. Negative credits are allocated to answers not meeting the
response criteria at a higher difficulty level elected, even if doing so at
a lower level.
The method is further characterized by not instantly awarding prizes for each
accepted answer, but to accumulate credits for all of the accepted answers entered
by a TV-viewer in the response unit, based on the scoring mode which allocates
a predetermined number of credits to each acceptable answer at the applicable
difficulty level. A TV-viewer, by not specifically electing a higher difficulty
level, in effect elects to respond at the basic difficulty level. Individual
ones of the TV viewers are informed of credits earned or lost and also are informed
of the monetary value of credits. At the end of the question and answer period,
a recording device in the response unit provides winners with a record of total
credits, which record may be a printed token, such as a coupon, or may be a
magnetized card.
The method provides for penalizing a contestant for not answering or for unacceptably
answering a question, irrespective of the difficulty level by deducting credits
determined in accordance with the scoring mode from the accumulated credits
of such viewer. The response criteria may be transmitted as an unobtrusive portion
of the TV-signals, by optical means, over voice channels, or other means. The
total number of credits earned by a viewer and a verification number or code
provided on said record in accordance with instructional signals transmitted
as fourth signals, may be phoned in by a contestant and the host announces a
winner or winners near the end of the show.
FIGS. 11-18 disclose an alternative system of the invention wherein material
generated at the studio of the central station is recorded for later playback
to one or more receiving stations. By way of example, the receiving stations
may be located in hotel rooms or at desks in a classroom wherein the program
deals with educational material. As further examples, the receiving stations
may be located at seats in a vehicle of public conveyance such as an aircraft,
or in an auditorium. The receiving stations may be equipped with television
receivers in which case the recording may be a video recording in the form of
the widely-used video cassette recording. The sound portion of the program would
be heard by earphones. Alternatively, the receiving stations may be equipped
for audio playback only, as by use of earphones in an aircraft, in which case
the program at the studio must be formatted by audio description of the task
so as to adapt the program for audio recording. In the case of the video recording,
the circuitry employed at the central station and at the receiving station,
as disclosed in the foregoing embodiments of the invention, may also be employed
in this embodiment of the invention. In the event that an audio-only recording
is to be utilized, then the equipment of the central station and of the receiving
stations must be modified slightly so as to accommodate this embodiment of the
invention modified for audio-only. In the case of a video recording, the video
signals include synchronization signals which ensure that a playback of the
recording is an accurate representation of the original program. However, in
the case of an audio-only recording, the system of the invention is modified,
preferably, to include a synchronization signal to insure accuracy of a playback
even if the playback recorder speed differs somewhat from the recorder speed
during the recording of the program.
In the ensuing description, FIG. 11 shows the use of a prerecorded edition of
a program performed in a studio as disclosed above in FIGS. 1, 3, 6 or 7. The
receiving stations of FIG. 11 are equipped for a video playback or an audio-only
playback. FIG. 12 shows a system employing equipment, previously described in
FIGS. 6 and 8, by way of example, to provide a video playback to the receiving
stations of FIG. 11. In FIGS. 13 and 14, there is disclosed an alternate system
for providing an audio-only playback to the receiving stations of FIG. 11, the
system of FIGS. 13 and 14 also employing the equipment previously disclosed
in FIGS. 6 and 8, but including further the addition of a fixed-frequency tone,
F.sub.3, for use as a synchronization signal and which is located in the upper
end of the audio spectrum along with the frequencies F.sub.1 and F.sub.2 previously
disclosed in FIG. 10. FIGS. 15, 16 and 19 show a further modification of the
audio-only system wherein the scoring and response criteria signals of FIGS.
6 and 8 are transmitted as unintelligible burst code signals between intelligible
voice signals, rather than by modulation of the scoring and response criteria
signals on set carrier frequencies as disclosed in FIG. 10. FIGS. 17, 20 and
21 show a further modification of the audio-only system wherein voice signals,
a synchronization signal, and the storing and response criteria signals may
be transmitted simultaneously on separate tracks of a recording medium. With
either the video or audio-only recording and playback, it may be desirable to
employ a central dispenser of hard copy of respondents' answers as at a central
console disclosed in FIG. 11; a system for connecting individual response units
to the central dispenser being disclosed in FIG. 18. The systems of FIG. 11-20
will now be described in further detail.
With reference to FIG. 11. there is shown an aircraft cabin 500 provided with
receiving stations 502 and a central console 504. While numerous receiving stations
502 may be present in the cabin 500, three such stations are shown by way of
example. FIG. 11 also shows a floor 506 and a vertical partition 508 of the
cabin 500. Each receiving station 502 comprises a seat 510 supported by legs
512 upon the floor 506. The partition 508 separates the console 504 from the
stations 502.
The console 504 includes the television system 220 and viewing screen 208, described
above with reference to FIG. 6, and the dispenser 360 described above with reference
to FIG. 8. Included with the dispenser 360 is electrical circuitry 514 which
includes a digital communication system 516 (FIGS. 11 and 18) which connects
the dispenser 360 to the receiving stations 502. The screen 208 permits an aircraft
attendant to monitor the program being played back for passengers sitting in
each of the receiving stations 502. The program is recorded initially by a video
cassette recorder 518 (including a playback capacity), also shown in FIGS. 3
and 6, connected at an input to the television system 28 or the television system
220 for providing video recordings of the program produced at the central station
12 (FIG. 3) or the central station 202 (FIG. 6). If desired, the recorder 518
may be connected to an output of the central station 12 or 202. Alternatively,
the recorder 518 can be formed in a more simple fashion without the need for
demodulation and modulation circuitry if the recorder is to be connected to
the output terminal of the combiner 70 (FIG. 3) or the combiner 238 (FIG. 6).
With the alternative form of recorder, playback is accomplished by connecting
output terminals of the recorder directly to the television station 208 and
to the speaker 270 in FIG. 6.
In the case of an audio-only recording, an audio recorder 520, which includes
a playback capacity, would be connected to the output terminal of a summer 236A
as will be described with reference to FIG. 13. Either the recorder 518 or the
recorder 520 is to be employed with the console 504 in FIG. 11, depending on
whether a video or audio-only recorder is to be employed. By way of example,
the video recorder 518 is shown in FIG. 11 connected by an input cable 502 to
an input terminal of the television system 220. Knobs 524 are provided on the
console 504 for operation of the television system 220 and for selection of
operating functions of the dispenser 360.
Each receiving station 502 further comprises a television screen 208A which
is mounted upon the back of a seat 510, or on the partition 508, for viewing
by a passenger sitting in a seat 510. The screens 208A function in the same
fashion as does the screen 208. The mounting of a screen 208A to the back of
a seat 510 may be accomplished by means of a swivel mount 526 which enables
the screen 208A to be swung to a stowage position conveniently located away
from a passenger. The screen 208A is employed only for the video playback, and
is not needed for an audio-only playback. Also included within each receiving
station 502 is a dispenser 210A which employs components previously disclosed
in the description of the response unit 210 of FIG. 6, and may be modified as
will be described hereinafter to facilitate its use in a receiving station 502.
Also provided in each of the receiving stations 502 is a set of earphones 528
by which a passenger listens to the audio portion of the program produced at
the central station 12 (FIG. 3) or 202 (FIG. 6).
The earphones 528 are connected to the TV system 220, in the case of a video
playback, in the same manner as is the speaker 270 (FIG. 6) or, connected to
the TV system 28 (FIG. 3) as is the speaker 86. This interconnection will be
described in further detail in FIG. 12. The TV screens 208A are connected electrically
via coaxial cable 530 to the TV system 220. Connection of the console 504 to
the earphones 528 is made by an electrical line 532, the line 532 being connected
via an armrest of a seat 510 to the corresponding earphone 528. Signals for
activating the response unit 210A in each of the stations 502 is provided by
an electric line 534 which connects with the console 504, connection of the
line 534 being made by way of the armrest of a seat 510 to the respective response
unit 210A. Both the earphones 528 and the response unit 210A are connected via
flexible lines 536 and 538, respectively, to an armrest of a seat 510. The line
538 is an electric line, while the line 536 may be either an electric line or
an acoustically conducting tube, connected by a transducer of electric to sonic
signals in the armrest, as is frequently employed in passenger aircraft.
The connections of the screens 208A, the earphones 528 and the response unit
210A to the T.V. system 220 of the console 504 are disclosed further in FIG.
12. Therein, it is seen that each of the earphones 528A is connected in parallel
to the speaker 270 so that a passenger can hear in the same fashion as was disclosed
for a respondent in the description of FIGS. 3 and 6. Similarly, the screens
208A are connected in parallel with the screen 208 to enable a passenger to
view a televised program in the same fashion as was described for a respondent
with reference to FIGS. 3 and 6.
Each of the response units 210A is connected via the two lines 346 and 348 to
the TV system 220 in the same fashion as was disclosed for connection of the
response unit 210 to the television system 220. In this way, in the viewing
of the program, the listening to the host of a program, and the entering of
responses is accomplished in the cabin 500 in the same fashion as was disclosed
for respondents at the remote receiving stations disclosed hereinafter with
reference to FIGS. 3 and 6. The connection of the video recorder 518, during
playback, is the same as was disclosed with reference to FIGS. 3 and 6 during
a recording mode. FIG. 12 also shows that a response unit 210 may be connected,
if desired, to the TV system 220 in the console 504 to enable the attendant
to practice responses along with passengers who are playing TV games. Alternatively,
if desired, the response unit 210 may be deleted from the central console 504.
It is noted also that the screens 208 and 208A and the interconnecting cable
530 would not be employed in the case of an audio-only playback of the program
of the central station 202 (FIG. 6).
By way of alternative embodiment, it is noted that recording/playback apparatus,
such as the recorder 518 could be combined with a response unit 210A in the
manner of a small, portable unitary structure to allow a person to play a game
or other subject matter privately at a location of convenience. A similar, but
larger, unitary structure is provided, as discussed above, in the connection
of the response unit 210 to the TV system 220 in the console 504 for enabling
the attendant to practice responses along with passenger who are playing TV
games.
In a typical embodiment of the invention, a video tape is employed to display
a map of the general area over which a plane is flying. An accompanying audio
message provides questions to passengers wishing to participate, the questions
pertaining to the geography, topography, demography, history, industry, resorts,
sports and any other aspect of the region. It is an advantage of this method
that the ground does not have to be visible to passengers, who will see the
ground by video-tape presentation. Such programs can be sponsored by groups
interested in promoting one or another aspect of natural or man-made resources
of the area, such as Chambers of Commerce, historical societies, resorts, airlines,
commercial sponsors, tourist offices of states and the like. A plurality of
audio tapes pertaining to the same map, but containing different questions,
may be prepared and used alternatively. Other variations and combinations may
be devised.
In the foregoing embodiment, the video or audio tape serves as the recording
medium upon which the program, tasks to be performed, appropriate answers against
which responses are to be gauged, and scoring criteria are stored. However,
in the practice of the invention, it is contemplated that other forms of data
storage may become available to serve as the storage medium, such as optical
discs and electronic circuitry such as a read-only memory.
According to another embodiment, each passenger is given a printed topographic
map, which may or may not be of the region over which a plane flies or through
which a mass transportation vehicle is traveling. Audio questions pertaining
to the names or any other features not shown on the map have been prepared and
stored on alternative tapes. The audio questions are received through headsets.
Travelers responses can be marked on the maps, which can be evaluated and scored
as described in the context of educational tests. Alternatively, contestants
may enter their answers on a keypad, and the individual answers are evaluated
and scored as described hereinabove. The methods described can easily be adapted
for use in a variety of public locations, such as hotel rooms, restaurants,
game arcades, auditoriums, trains, buses, and airplanes.
With reference to FIGS. 13 and 14,
there is shown a modification of the central station 202 (FIG. 6) and the interconnection
with the response unit 210 (FIG. 6 and 8) which enable the response unit 210
to operate with an audio-only recording of the program provided in the studio
of the central station 202. The single host 212 of FIG. 6 is replaced in FIG.
13 with an announcer 540 and an instructor 542. The announcer 540 provides a
verbal description of a scene in the studio, such as a description of the specimen
214 (FIG. 6) by speaking into a microphone 230A. This verbal description takes
the place of the televised picture provided by the camera 228 (FIG. 6). The
instructor 542 (FIG. 13) explains the task and instructions for responding to
the studio situation by speaking into a microphone 230B. It may be advisable,
in order to facilitate response by respondents in the aircraft cabin 500 (FIG.
11) to employ both male and female voices at the microphones 230A-B so that
a respondent can more readily distinguish between a description of the scene
and an instructional message. For example, the instructor 542 may be a male
and the announcer 540 may be a female. Electric signals outputted by the microphones
230A-B are combined together in a summing amplifier 544 and applied to an input
terminal of a summer 236A which functions in the same manner as the summer 236
of FIG. 6. Also included in the system of FIG. 13 are the keyboards 224 and
226 of FIG. 6, as well as the signal processors 232 and 234 of FIG. 6. In FIG.
13, an output terminal of the summer 236A connects with an input terminal of
the audio tape recorder 520 for recording the verbal messages of the announcer
540 and the instructor 542. The tape recorder 520, in this embodiment of the
invention, may employ a recording medium having only a single recording track.
In the central station 202 of FIG. 6, oscillators 242 and 244 were employed
to provide reference signals at frequencies F.sub.1 and F.sub.2 for operation
of modulators 252 of the signal processors 232 and 234. Additional oscillators
236 and 278 were employed in the TV system 220 (FIG. 6) to provide the corresponding
reference signals for demodulation of the response and scoring criteria signal.
However, in the audio-only system of FIGS. 13 and 14 wherein the playback speed
of the tape recorder 520 may vary during playback from the speed employed during
recording, it is desirable to synthesize the reference signals at the frequencies
F.sub.1 and F.sub.2 from a single reference signal recorded on the recording
medium. Thereby, demodulation is accomplished accurately independently of playback
speed. The single reference signal which serves to synchronize the playback
and recording functions is provided by a clock 546 (FIG. 13) and a filter 548.
The clock 546 outputs a periodic train of rectangular clock pulses, which clock
pulse train is filtered by the filter 548 to transform the pulse train into
a sinusoidal waveform at the pulse repetition frequency of the pulse train.
This frequency is designated F.sub.3 in the drawing.
The system of FIG. 13 further comprises frequency divider 550, a mixer 552,
and two filters 554 and 556. The frequency divider 550, which may include a
pulse counter (not shown), operates in a well-known fashion to output a pulse
train at a lower frequency, designated F.sub.d. The signals at the frequencies
F.sub.3 and F.sub.d are applied to input terminals of the mixer 552 to output
signals at the sum and difference frequencies, these signals being captured
by the filters 554 and 556 to provide the reference signals at the frequencies
F.sub.1 and F.sub.2. The frequency F.sub.d is equal to the difference of frequency
between the frequency F.sub.3 and either of the frequencies F.sub.1 and F.sub.2.
The signals at the frequencies F.sub.1 and F.sub.2 are applied to the processors
232 and 234 which operate in cooperation with the keyboards 224 and 226 to output
coded modulated signals to the summer 236A in the same fashion as has been described
earlier with reference to FIG. 6. The synchronization signal at frequency F.sub.3
is also applied to an input terminal of the summer 236A. These signals are summed
together along with the signals of the microphones 230A-B to provide a composite
signal which is outputted by the summer 236A and recorded on a recording medium
of the recorder 520.
In FIG. 14, a receiving system 558 interconnects a response unit 210 with an
output terminal of the audio recorder 520. The receiving system 558 of FIG.
14 takes the place of the TV system of FIG. 6 in providing an interconnection
between the response unit 210 and a televised signal received at either the
antenna 282 or from the video recorder 518. In FIG. 14, the receiving system
558 employs the synchronization signal at frequency F.sub.3 to regenerate the
reference signals at frequencies F.sub.1 and F.sub.2 for use by the demodulators
266 and 268. Both the receiving system 558 and the TV system 220 include the
band-pass filters 272 and 274 and the demodulators 266 and 268 which function
in the same manner in both the TV system 220 and the receiving system 558. In
FIG. 14, the receiving system 558 further comprises the filters 548, 554, and
556, the frequency divider 550 and the mixer 552, all of which have been described
previously with reference to FIG. 13. Also included in the receiving system
558 is the speaker 270 which has been described previously with reference to
the TV system 220 of FIG. 6.
In operation, an output signal of the recorder 520 is applied simultaneously
to the filter 548, to the filters 272 and 274 and to the speaker 270. The filter
548 extracts the synchronization signal at the frequency F.sub.3 from the composite
signal outputted by the recorder 520. The filters 272 and 274 extract the spectral
bands of the response and scoring criteria signals, respectively for applying
the signals to the demodulators 266 and 268, respectively. An output signal
of the filter 548 is applied as the synchronization signal for operation of
the response unit 210, and is also applied to the frequency divider 550 and
the mixer 552. The frequency divider 550 operates to provide the lower frequency
F.sub.d to the mixer 552 which outputs sum and difference frequencies to the
filters 554 and 556 to attain the reference signals at frequencies F.sub.1 and
F.sub.2. By way of example, in the construction of the frequency divider 550,
a division ratio of 40 may be employed such that, by way of example, if the
frequency F.sub.3 has a value of 20,000 Hz, then F.sub.d has a value of 500
Hz and the frequencies F.sub.1 and F.sub.2 are separated by 1,000 Hz. The division
ratio of 40 is given only by way of example, it being understood that other
ratios may be selected in accordance with desired spectral bandwidth and separation
of the response and scoring criteria signals. The reference signals at the frequencies
F.sub.1 and F.sub.2 are employed by the demodulators 266 and 268 in the same
manner as was described with reference to FIG. 6 for outputting the response
and storing criteria signals on lines 346 and 348, respectively, to the response
unit 210. The response unit 210 and the speaker 270 may be located in the console
504 of the aircraft cabin 500 (FIG. 11) if desired for convenience of an aircraft
attendant, but need not be provided in the console 504 insofar as the practice
of the invention is required. For simplicity, the response unit 210 and the
speaker 270 have been omitted from the console 504 in FIG. 11. In FIG. 14, output
signals of the receiving system 558 are provided along lines 532 and 534 respectively
to the earphones 528 and response units 210A at the receiving stations 502 of
the cabin 500. The audio recorder 520 may be provided with a speed control knob
560 so as to match the playback speed to the recording speed for accurate reception
of the voice signals from the speaker 270.
During playback of the game program of the aircraft cabin 500, the announcer
540 provides a detailed description of the scene in the studio. The instructor
542 asks the questions and sets an interval of time for response. During the
response interval, neither the instructor 542 or the announcer 540 are speaking.
Thus, there would be the absence of any sound during the response interval,
which situation might possibly confuse a respondent as to whether or not his
earphones were still operative. Accordingly, it may be desirable to play softly
background music from a music source 562, such as a tape recorder, the music
being received by the microphones 230A and 230B for transmission to the respondents.
Either the announcer 540 or the instructor 542 may operate the keyboard 224
and 226.
In FIG. 6, a telephone circuit 280, as has been described previously, serves
as a means for interaction between a respondent and personnel at the central
station 202. Also, in the case of FIG. 11 with the recorded playback in the
aircraft cabin 500, a form of interaction is possible. Such interaction is attained
by a respondent commenting to a flight attendant that the questions are too
hard, or that the response intervals are too short, or that further description
of the specimen 214 (FIG. 6) is required. The flight attendant then responds
by replaying a portion of the recorded program to provide the additional description,
or alternatively, advances to another portion of the recording medium to provide
for simpler questions. As a further alternative, the flight attendant may insert
another audio tape cassette into the recorder 520 to provide a further version
of a recorded program in which longer response intervals have been provided,
or wherein other forms of questions have been provided.
FIGS. 15 and 16 show an embodiment of the system wherein encoded response and
scoring-criteria signals are transmitted as rapid bursts of sound, which are
unintelligible to a respondent. The burst of sound is transmitted between intervals
of speaking by the announcer 540 and the instructor 542. A time sequence demonstrating
the transmission of such response and scoring criteria between spoken messages
of the announcer 540 and the instructor 542 is presented in the timing diagram
of FIG. 19. The system of FIG. 15 includes the two microphones 230A and 230B,
the summing amplifier 544 and the keyboards 224 and 226 which have been described
with reference to FIG. 13. Output signals of the keyboard 224 and 226 are applied
respectively to encoders 248A and 248B which function in the manner described
for the encoder 248 of FIG. 6. The encoders 248A and 248B also incorporate identifying
signals for digital words to distinguish between response criteria of the keyboard
224 and the scoring criteria of the keyboard 226. The identifying digital words
are attained from digital signal sources 564 and 566, respectively. Output signals
of the encoders 248A-B are applied to memories 568 and 570, respectively.
The system of FIG. 15 also includes the clock 546 and the filter 548 which function
in the manner previously described with reference to FIG. 13. Two read-out circuits
572 and 574 connect between an output terminal of the clock 546 and input terminals
respectively of the memories 568 and 570. The memories 568 and 570 may be constructed
as shift registers or random-access memories. Each of the read-out circuits
572 and 574 is responsive to clock pulses of the clock 546 for reading out data
store in respective ones of the memories 568 and 570 at a rapid rate, for example,
1200 bytes per second wherein each byte is composed of eight bits in a well-known
fashion as is commonly employed by modems in the transmission of computer signals
over telephone lines. Such digital signals are clearly audible but unintelligible
to a person listening to a telephone line carrying the signals. Answers to questions
can be given in a relatively few seconds, the transmission of which may be divided
up among several bursts each of which is less than one second duration. Similarly,
scoring criteria can be transmitted via a relatively few number of short-duration
bursts of the coded signals.
The bursts of data transmitted from the memories 568 and 570 are coupled via
a section 576A of a switch 576 to a summer 236B which functions in the same
manner as the summer 236 in FIG. 6. Switch section 576A is operative to select
alternatively output voice signals of the summing amplifier 544, output data
of the memory 568 or output data of the memory 570. A second section of the
switch 576, namely section 576B, is ganged to the section 576A to be operative
therewith for activating one of the readout circuits 572 and 574. Activation
of a readout circuit 572 or 574 is accomplished by grounding a control terminal
of the readout circuit by the switch section 576B. The switch 576 is operated
either by the instructor 542 or the announcer 540 when either one of them pauses
in speaking. An earphone 528 connected to an output terminal of the summer 236B
enables the instructor 542 or the announcer 540 to hear the burst code sound
so as to operate the switch 576 upon completion of a data burst. The synchronization
signal outputted by the filter 548 is also applied to an input terminal of the
summer 236B. The output signal of the summer 236B is applied to the audio recorder
520 for a recording of the audio addition of the program.
FIG. 16 shows interconnection of an output signal of the audio recorder 520
with a response unit 210B which is a modification of the unit 210 adapted for
receiving the response and scoring-criteria signal within a common spectral
portion of the audio band. Also included within the system of FIG. 16 are a
low-pass filter 578 and a high-pass filter 580. The two filters 578 and 580
separate the relatively high frequency synchronization signal from the data-burst
signal outputted by the memories 568 and 570. The data-burst signal is coupled
via the low-pass filter 578 to the response unit 210B. The input circuitry of
the response unit 210B is similar to that of the response unit 210 of FIG. 8
in that four decoders are employed. However, in FIG. 8, the four decoders connect
with data on two input signal lines 346 and 348 while, in the case of the system
of FIG. 16, all of the decoders are coupled to a single input data line 582.
In the response unit 210B, the four input decoders 338A, 340A, 342A, and 344A
operate in the same fashion as the corresponding decoders 338, 340, 342, and
344 of FIG. 8; however, the decoders 338A, 340A, 342A, and 344A of FIG. 16 also
are responsive to the identifying words obtained from the digital source 564
and 566, (FIG. 15) to identify signals as being response or scoring-criteria
signals. Data signals outputted by the low-pass filter 578 and the synchronization
signals outputted by the high-pass filter 580 are applied via line 534 to the
response unit 210B in the same fashion as has been described earlier with respect
to the response units 210A of FIGS. 12 and 14. Audio signals outputted on lie
532 from the recorder 520 are applied to the earphones 528 in the same fashion
as has been described above in FIGS. 12 and 14.
Synchronization of the response units 210, 210A and 210B are accomplished, as
shown in FIG. 8, by applying synchronization signals to an input terminal of
the clock 352. In the absence of the synchronization signal, the clock 352 is
a free-running clock. However, in the presence of the synchronization signal,
an output pulse train of clock pulses of the clock 352 is generated in synchronism
with the synchronization pulse. FIG. 17 shows the use of an audio tape recorder
520A having a recording tape medium with a plurality of recording tracks thereon.
The stylized representation of the recorder 520A includes four recording/playback
heads 584 connected respectively to upper terminals of the summing amplifier
544, the clock 564, the encoder 248A, and the encoder 248B which have been described
above with reference to FIG. 15. Each of the heads 584 is located above a corresponding
recording track 586 in a tape recording medium 588. The medium 588 is rolled
upon a roll 590 driven by a transport (not shown) for passing the medium 588
beneath the heads 584. Playback circuitry 592 connects with the heads 584 and
to the transport for operating the recorder 520A to play back recorded signals.
The signals played back are outputted by the circuitry 592 to the earphones
528 (one of which is shown in FIG. 17), and via lines 346 and 348 and the synchronization
signal line to the response units 210A (one of which is shown in FIG. 17). Herein,
the response-criteria signal and the scoring-criteria signal have been recorded
on separate tracks so as to be coupled via lines 346 and 348 to the response
unit 210A. Similarly, separate tracks are employed for the synchronization signal
and the voice signals. The use of the four separate tracks 586 permits the voice
signals outputted by the amplifier 544, the synchronization signal of the clock
564, the response criteria signal outputted by the encoder 248A, and the scoring
criteria signal outputted by the encoder 248B to be transmitted during time
intervals which are independent of each other, including a combination of both
serial and concurrent transmissions. This is demonstrated in the timing diagram
of FIG. 20 in which the synchronization signal at the second trace of the graph
is shown to be continuously present while the response and scoring criteria
signals, respectively in the third and fourth traces of the graph, overlap the
transmission of the verbal description of the scene and the instructions.
FIG. 18 shows circuitry of the response unit 210A which permits the response
unit to communicate via the digital communication system 516. The response unit
510A has the same components as the response unit 210 and operates in the same
fashion as the response unit 210, except for the inclusion of the additional
circuitry of FIG. 18. The additional circuitry of FIG. 18 may also be included
within the response unit 210B. Comparison of FIGS. 8 and 18 show that the dispenser
360 receives input signals from the register 368, the scoring logic unit 370,
and the accumulator 386. The additional circuitry comprises a memory 594, a
modem 596, a decoder 598, and read-out circuitry 600.
In operation, the memory 594 stores the signals of the registers 598, the scoring
logic unit 370, and the accumulator 386. The stored signals are subsequently
read out, upon command of the read-out circuitry 600 to the modem 596 which
converts the signals into a form suitable for transmission via the communication
system 516. The modem 596 operates in both directions, namely, to transmit signals
from the memory 594 into the communication system 516, and to direct command
signals from the communication system 516 to the decoder 598. By command of
the communication system 516, the decoder 598 identifies the command as applying
to the response unit 210A at a particular seat 510 of the cabin 500 (FIG. 11),
and then directs the read-out circuitry 600 to initiate a reading out of the
stored data from the memory 594 via the modem 596 into the communication system
516.
Also included in the circuitry of FIG. 18 is a modem 602 and a buffer store
604 which comprise a part of the circuitry 514 of the console 504 (FIG. 11).
Signals traveling from response units 210A of the receiving stations 502 via
the communication system 516 are applied to the modem 602 which reforms the
signal into a form suitable for storage in the store 604, after which the signals
are applied to the dispenser 360 in the console 504. The buffer store 604 allows
the signals received from remote response units 210A to be stored until the
dispenser 360 is available for printing hard copy of the results of responses
entered into the respective response units 210A at the receiving stations 502.
Also, the buffer store 604 allows the signals received from the remote response
units 210A to be outputted to the dispenser 360 at a rate commensurate with
the operational characteristics of the dispenser 360, which rate may be different
from a rate at which signals are communicated via the communication system 516.
Thereby, the circuitry 514 including the digital communication system 516 enables
a common central dispenser 360 at the console 504 to be employed for printing
out a hard copy of the responses produced at the various receiving stations
502. By use of the central dispenser 360 at the console 504, the apparatus of
the response unit 210A at each of the receiving stations 502 may be simplified
by deletion of their respective dispensers 360. The deletion of the dispensers
360 from the individual receiving stations 502 simplifies the complexity and
physical size of each response unit 210A, and may also reduce the cost of the
installation, particularly in aircraft having many receiving stations 502.
A further advantage of the embodiments of the invention employing a prerecorded
program is that various versions and formats of the program may be recorded.
Thus, a recording with difficult-to-answer questions and a recording with easy-to-answer
questions can be prepared. Questions involving a prior knowledge of history,
economics, sports or other subject matter can be prepared on the same or separate
records. Thereby, the flight attendant has the capacity, in essence, to reformat
questions and instructions, as well as the subject matter being described, in
response to preferences stated by respondents at the receiving stations. The
reformatting of the program, instructional signals, and/or response and storing
criteria are accomplished simply by fast-forwarding the recording tape to a
further position, or by replacing the recording tape with another tape. The
system of the invention may be installed in schools and hotels, as well as in
homes.
An aspect of the invention combines the eliciting of an answer with the eliciting
of a prediction. An example would be a sports event which has taken place a
relatively long time prior to such a broadcast, say the U.S. Open Golf Championship
held 10 years prior to the broadcast. A film of the tournament is shown and
the prediction/response solicited pertains to the number of strokes taken by
the eventual winner of the Championship on the third, par three hole, by way
of example. This method permits a person with a good memory to recall the outcome
of this event, i.e. responding to a question, the answer to which is known.
But at the same time, the method permits a person not having observed the Championship,
but having a knowledge of the game and the players, to make an educated guess
or prediction.
FIG. 21 shows an audio recorder 520B which is an alternative embodiment to the
recorder 520A on FIG. 17. The recorder 520B includes a recording medium 588A
having five tracks 586 as distinguished from the four tracks 586 on the medium
588 in FIG. 17. FIG. 21 has many of the components present in FIG. 17, namely,
the two microphones 230A and 230B, the clock 564, the keyboards 224 and 226,
the encoders 248A and 248B, the earphones 528 and the response unit 210A. In
FIG. 21, a set of five heads 584 are employed for recording electric signals
on the five tracks 586. A second set of heads 584 are provided for playback
of the signals recorded on the track 586. The same or a different set of the
heads 584 may be employed for recording and playback as may be convenient in
the construction of the audio recorder 520B. The two microphones 230A and 230B
are connected by amplifiers 606 and 608 to the respective heads 584 for recording
signals of the microphones 230A-B. Another two amplifiers 610 and 612 are connected
to the corresponding playback 584 for coupling recorded signals of the microphones
230A and 230B, respectively, via a switch 614 to an earphone 528. Also provided
is a summing amplifier 616 which sums together the signals of the microphones
230A-B, as outputted from the recorder 520B, and applies the sum signal via
the switch 614 to the earphone 528.
The switch 614 provides a respondent at the receiving station 502 with the option
of listening to either the description of the scene as provided by the announcer
540 (FIG. 13) at the microphone 230A, or the instructions for responding to
the task as set forth by the instructor 542 at the microphone 230B, or to a
composite of the two speeches of the announcer 540 and the instructor 542. The
embodiment of FIG. 21 allows statements by the announcer and the instructor
to be made independently of each other such that these statements may be made
serially or concurrently. In addition, the respondent has the option of listening
to either one of these statements independently. It should be noted also, that
while FIG. 11 demonstrates the use of only a single recorder for all of the
respondents, in the case of the audio recorder, it is possible to provide a
separate audio recorder for each respondent whereby each respondent can play
back those portions of the recording requiring further attention. In such case,
connection will be provided as shown in FIG. 21 wherein each recorder is outputted
to a single earphone and a single response unit rather than to a set of earphones
connected in parallel and a set of response units connected in parallel.
FIG. 22 shows a further embodiment of the invention employing recording apparatus,
such as the recorder 520 of FIGS. 13-15, for prerecorded tasks and instructional
signals. This embodiment employs a call-up system 618 wherein a person, or contestant,
wishing to play a game or involved with an educational experience, by way of
example, simply employs a telephone 620, preferably a push-button telephone,
to call a number, such as a so-called "900" number employed by telephone companies
in the United States (public telephone service wherein the caller is automatically
billed for the call plus other charges relating to the nature of the service
being provided by the called party for the caller). After connection is made
via a private switchboard 622, the contestant activates buttons 624 on the telephone
to start the tape recorder 520, stop, rewind and fast forward the tape recorder
520. Also included within the system 618 is the receiving system 558 previously
described with reference to FIG. 14, and the response unit 210 of FIG. 8. Outputted
signals from the tape recorder 520 are received by the system 558 and applied
to the response unit 210.
The recording is based on the system described in FIGS. 13 and 14 wherein all
control signals (instructional signals) for the response unit 210 are transmitted
in the upper spectral portion of the audio band, this being above the spectrum
of the tone signals generated by the telephone. Therefore, both types of signals,
the tone and the instructional signals, can coexist at the same time without
interfering with each other. Each channel of the switchboard 622 includes, in
addition to the recorder 520, a decoder 626, a low pass filter 628, a modem
630 and a receiver 632. In each channel, the low-pass filter 628 protects the
decoder 626 from the instructional signals, and allows only the tone signals
to reach the decoder 626. The decoder 626 translates the tone signals into digital
command signals to activate the recorder 520 for responding to commands from
the telephone push buttons 624 in a manner similar to the operation of an automatic
telephone message recorder.
A private home or other location of a contestant may serve as a remote station
which includes a telephone 620, a response unit 210, and a receiving system
558 as described above. Also included is a modem 634 for connecting the response
unit 210 to a telephone line 636 which interconnects the telephone 620, as well
as the modem 634 to the switchboard 622.
The system 618 of FIG. 22 operates in a manner analogous to the operation of
the airborne system of FIG. 11 except for the primary difference that, instead
of relying on the aid of a flight attendant to set up and activate the equipment,
the system 618 of FIG. 22 allows a caller who wishes to be a contestant to activate
a playback of tape recorder/playback apparatus by simply placing a telephone
call. Thereupon, the caller hears the task setting message, and may operate
buttons on the telephone to replay any portion of the message which he may have
not thoroughly understood. Once a question has been asked along with the transmission
of a timing signal to the response unit 210 indicating the start of a response
interval, any delay on the part of the caller, such as a replaying of the question,
will elicit a logging in of a longer time for the caller's response by the response
unit 210 with a consequent diminution in a score to be awarded for the response.
If desired, the system 618 may be operated in conjunction with a central station,
such as the central station 202 with studio 204 of FIG. 6. The studio 204 is
connected electrically by a message line 638 and a control line 640 to the switchboard
622 to enable the host 212 to communicate by the telephone lines 636 with the
response units 210 of the contestants. The host 212 also communicates by the
television transmission 222 between antennas 246 and 282 to present a situation,
occurring in the studio 204, upon a television screen 208 at each remote receiving
station 206B of the respective callers. The central station 202 provides additional
flexibility to the operation of the system 618. For example, the host 212 can
provide additional information which supplements a description of subject matter
provided by the prerecorded message in the tape recorders 520. The additional
information may be in the form of a video presentation on the TV screen 208
plus a narrative description.
Further options in the operation are as follows. In the absence of the television
transmission 222, the host 212 can speak directly on each of the telephone lines
636 to provide a supplemental verbal description to the telephone 620 of each
caller. This is accomplished by sending a control signal from the central station
along the line 640 to direct the switchboard 622 to connect the telephone lines
636 to the message line 638. The voice of the host then is carried via the message
line 638 to the switchboard 622 which connects the voice to the telephone lines
636.
Also, by use of the control line 640 and the switch board 622, the host can
send a synchronization tone signal to synchronize the tape recorders 520 to
simultaneously activate the response units 210 of the various callers. For the
foregoing purposes, the central station 202 (FIG. 22) comprises an additional
keyboard 642 and a tone encoder 644 connected thereto, as well as a microphone
646. The control signals are generated by pressing a specific key or keys of
the keyboard 642 to activate the desired function, the keys generating command
signals which are converted by the encoder into tone signals which are recognized
by the switchboard 622 and the decoders 626 to provide a desired switching function
and a desired function of the recorders 520. The microphone 646 is connected
to the message line 638 so that the host 212 in the studio 204 of the central
station 202 can employ the microphone 646 to speak to the callers. Also, by
means of the switchboard 622 a host at the central station 202 can access the
recorders 520 to preset them to a specific portion of the recording tape, thereby
to regulate the presentation of tasks via the system 618 to a desired level
of difficulty. Thus, control of selected portions of the recording tape can
be provided alternatively by respondents at receiving stations or by the host
at the central station.
The modems 634 are connected to the register 368 and the accumulator 386 (FIGS.
8 and 22) in respective ones of the response units 210 for transmitting data
of the responses and the scoring of the respective contestants to the respective
receivers 632. Each modem 634 converts the digital signals of the register 368
and the accumulator 386 to tone signals which can be carried by the telephone
lines 636 and the switchboard 622, the tone signals being converted back to
the digital format by respective ones of the modems 630 to be received by the
receivers 632. As noted in block 388 of FIG. 8, identification of the remote
station is included within the data outputted by the response units 210, so
that the set of receivers 632 can correlate a score with a specific remote station.
Thereby, the host 212, or other persons in charge of the quiz show or operation
of the prerecorded programs, can be provided with response data which may be
used in modifying the questions to be presented at a future time, for announcing
winners of a quiz show, for dispensing prizes to winning contestants, and for
other such purposes.
If desired, the conducting of the quiz or game show, or other type show, can
be accomplished as has been described with reference to FIG. 6, with the switchboard
622 of the system 618 of FIG. 22 being employed only for the recording of test
scores or other results communicated by the modems 634 and 630.
One interesting aspect of the foregoing embodiment of the invention becomes
apparent in a game show wherein remote contestants, namely, the contestants
at the remote receiving stations, participate with the studio contestants in
a game to win prizes, the prizes being awarded to both the studio and the remote
contestants. As a simple example, consider roulette being played in the studio
and observed via television at the remote stations. With reference to FIG. 22,
contestants from the remote stations call in to the switchboard before the game
starts, and establish a telephonic connection. After the wheel begins spinning,
each caller employs the keyboard in his or her response unit to enter numbers,
colors or other predictions of the type made by a player at the side of the
roulette wheel. A timing signal transmitted to each response unit terminates
the interval during which responses may be entered, the interval being terminated
before the wheel stops. The criteria for judging the outcome of the prediction,
namely the correct response, is then transmitted to each response unit by the
instructional signal to enable the response units to compute the scores. The
scores are then transmitted via the modems and the telephone circuits to the
central station so that winners can be announced to both the studio and the
remote contestants. In this way, other games such as chess wherein the next
move is to be predicted, or black jack wherein a card is to be selected, can
be played by both the studio and the remote contestants. The remote contestants
can be located in rooms of a hotel which houses the studio, within a nearby
town, at great distance, or all of the foregoing locations.
In the description of embodiments of the invention disclosed in FIGS. 3, 6 and
7, apparatus has been presented for transmitting the instructional signal, by
way of example, within the spectrum of a voice channel, and within the vertical
blanking interval between frames in the video portion of a television transmission.
Yet another form of transmission of the instructional signal which may be useful
in the practice of the invention may be employed, this transmission being partially
optical and being included within the video portion of the television transmission.
FIG. 23 shows the optical transmission of the instructional signal. This alternative
mode of transmission of the instructional signal can be used instead of, or
to supplement, The modes previously described, if desired. FIG. 3 shows installation
of this optional mode of transmission of the instructional signal. In FIG. 3,
an entry unit 648, to be described in detail in FIG. 23, provides the host 50
an additional facility for entry of an instructional signal. The entry unit
648 outputs a signal in the form of a television video signal which is to be
combined with the video signal outputted by the camera 54. The combining of
the two video signals is accomplished by a video mixing unit 650 which operates
in the well known manner, frequently employed in sporting events, whereby two
video images provided by two separate cameras, such as a view of a tennis player
preparing to serve and a receiver preparing to return the ball, are presented
side by side on a television screen.
The entry unit 648 provides for the encoding of the instructional signal in
the format of a sequence of colored spots which appear on the television screen
20 along with the picture provided by the camera 54. The colored spots are located
at the side of the screen 20 so as to avoid interference with a viewing of the
picture provided by the camera 54. In the TV system 28, an optical detector
assembly 652 is positioned alongside of the screen 20 to read and decode the
colored spots, and to output the instructional signal in the format of an electrical
signal suitable for use by the response unit 22 or 210.
FIG. 23 shows details in the construction of the entry unit 648 and the detector
assembly 652, and shows in simplified fashion the interconnection of these two
elements via a communication link 654 which represents the system connection
of FIG. 3. The TV system 28 of FIG. 3 has been simplified in FIG. 23 which shows
only the television screen 20 and the components of the detector assembly 652.
The entry unit 648 comprises a keyboard 656, an encoder 658 which may be fabricated
of a read-only memory (ROM), a register 660, a clock 662, a matrix 664 of light-emitting
diodes (LED's), and a television camera 666. The LED matrix 664 comprises three
clusters 668 of light-emitting diodes 670. There are three diodes 670 in each
cluster 668, one of the diodes being red (R), a second of the diodes being green
(G), and a third of the diodes being blue (B).
In the TV system 28, the screen 20 shows three of the colored spots, identified
by the numeral 672, and located at a side region 674 of the screen 20. The three
spots are identified further by the legends 672A-C to facilitate identification
of specific ones of the spots 672. Similarly, the clusters are identified further
by the legends 668A-C to facilitate identification of specific ones of the clusters
668. The three spots 672A-C correspond to the three clusters 668A-C, respectively,
and are produced by action of the camera 666 in photographing the three clusters
668A-C. The three clusters 668 are provided by way of example, it being understood
that another number of clusters, such as two or four clusters by way of example,
may be employed with an equal number of spots 672 being produced on the television
screen 20.
The optical detector assembly 652 which is positioned alongside of the screen
20 to read the colored spots comprises three detectors 676, each of which is
provided with a red section (R), a green section (G) and a blue section (B)
for detecting the the corresponding colors transmitted by the red, green and
blue diodes 670 of a cluster 668 to the camera 666. Each of the detectors 676
is coupled optically by a lens 678 to one of the spots 672 for focussing emitted
by the spot upon the detector. The detector assembly 652 includes a set of three
register circuits 680 coupled to respective ones of the detectors 676. Each
of the register circuits 680 comprises a register 682 and an AND gate 684 connected
to a terminal of the register 682 for strobing the register 682 to read signals
outputted to the register 682 by the corresponding detector 676. Each of the
detectors 676 outputs signals on three separate channels corresponding to the
red, the green and the blue colors emitted from a spot 672. The detector assembly
652 further comprises a address register 686, a decoder 688 which may be fabricated
of a read-only memory, and an optional display 690.
In operation, and with reference to FIGS. 3 and 23, the host 50 has the capability
to send an instructional signal or signals by the alternative route of the video
channel, plus the optical link at the interface between the screen 20 and the
detector assembly 652. This alternate route is implemented as follows. At the
entry unit 648, the host enters an instruction via the keyboard 656. The keyboard
656 outputs an address to the memory of the encoder 658 which responds by outputting
a code to the register 660. The code may represent a letter of a word, a number,
or any one of a plurality of special terms applicable to a task or prediction
provided by the studio 14 (FIG. 1), such as the terms "fairway", "bunker", "rough"
and "green" as applicable to golf, or "check", "castle" or "capture" in a game
of chess. The register 660 is connected to the LED matrix 664 by nine lines
692 which activate respective ones of the diodes 670. Each word of the code
has nine elements which are stored in the register 660, the nine code elements
being applied respective ones of the lines 692 to activate respective ones of
the diodes 670.
In the use of the code, there are six choices of colors or combinations of colors
in a cluster 668. The choices are red, green, blue, red and green, red and blue,
and green and blue. The combination of all three colors which produces white
is reserved for use as a strobe signal for activating the registers 682 in respective
ones of the register circuits 680. The six choices per cluster 668 provide a
total of 216 color coded words for the matrix 664. Any one of the color coded
words may be accessed by use of the keyboard 656. The color coded words are
photographed by the camera 666 and then are presented by the screen 20 to the
detector assembly 652 for detection of the cluster colors by individual ones
of the detectors 676. Each of the detectors 676 output detected colors via a
set of three lines to its register 682.
As shown in a graph 694 appended to the encoder 658, the colored words are interspersed
among white words. The white words are provided automatically by the encoder
658 after each color word. At each of the register circuits 680, the presence
of all three colors in a white word activates the AND gate 684 to strobe the
register 682. Thereby, the respective registers 682 are strobed to output their
respective color signals to the register 686 to provide the register 686 with
a complete detected code word. The code word in the register 686 is applied
as an address for the memory of the decoder 688 to output the alphanumeric symbol
or word which was intended by the host 50 to be transmitted as part, or all,
of the instructional signal. The alphanumeric symbol or word is presented on
the display 690 to be seen by a contestant at a remote receiving station 18.
The alphanumeric symbol or word is presented also to the response unit 22 (FIG.
4) via line 696 or to the response unit 210 (FIG. 8).
The white and colored code words of the graph 694, are depicted as pulse signals
having a predetermined duration. The duration be selected as a matter of convenience.
However, it is noted that the camera 666 includes a vidicon which scans the
clusters 668 with a sequence of scan lines (horizontal rows with reference to
the screen 20) which extend in the direction from the cluster 668A to the cluster
668B. In accordance with normal television practice, there is an interlacing
of pairs of scans to produce image frames at a rate of thirty frames per second.
The clusters 668 have a width equal to at least a few line scans so that, within
an interval of one sixtieth of a second, a few scans have been made of all the
clusters 668 to provide adequate opportunity for the detectors 676 to detect
the presence of a color. The region 674 extends beyond the spots 672 to provide
a dark apron to prevent extraneous light from the screen 20 from entering the
lenses 678 to impinge upon the detectors 676. The pulse duration for the light
signals outputted by the cluster diodes 670 may be one sixtieth of a second
for maximum data rate, and may be longer if desired. It is possible to have
a still higher data rate by allowing only one scan line for each pulse, but
it may be desirable to use a slower data rate for better signal to noise ratio.
In the response unit 22 of FIG. 4 the instructional signals of the decoder 100
and the detector assembly 652 are applied via an OR gate 698 to the memory 108.
The OR gate 698 allows the instructional signals to be applied alternatively
or in supplementary fashion to operate the memory 108 in the manner described
previously with reference to signals outputted by the decoder 100. In a similar
fashion, the signals from the detector assembly 652 an be applied (not shown)
also to the memory 106 if desired.
In the response unit 210 of FIG. 8 the instructional signals of the decoder
344 and the detector assembly 652 are applied via an OR gate 700 to the memory
334. The memory 334 has been selected by way of example, it being understood
that the signals of the detector assembly 652 can be applied, if desired, to
another of the memories of the response unit 210. The OR gate 700 allows the
instructional signals to be applied alternatively or in supplementary fashion
to operate the memory 108 in the manner described previously with reference
to signals outputted by the decoder 344.
The display 690 (FIG. 23) is useful for a contestant in that it allows the contestant
to have information, in addition to that presented on the screen 20, which may
be significant for determining the contestant's response. For example, there
may be an increase in the amount of scoring points to be awarded for a task
of higher difficulty level which would encourage the contestant to take a chance
and select the higher difficulty level.
With reference again to FIG. 22, it is noted that utilization of the telephone
system therein for carrying out the invention can be accomplished in an advantageous
manner by employing the telephone system to collect and dispense funds for participants
in games, wagers, contests, and other projects by the simple expedient of crediting
or debiting the accounts of telephone subscribers who participate in the practice
of the invention. This permits virtually instantaneous payment of an entry fee
to a game, or a bet on the outcome of an event, by way of example, and dispensing
of an award in the form of a token or card having a monetary value or by crediting
a player's telephone account with cash. The use of the telephone system for
this purposes will be described now with reference to FIG. 24.
FIG. 24 presents a diagram useful in explaining the use of the system of FIG.
22 for transference of funds in the practice of the invention. A central telephone
facility 702 connects via a communication link 704 with a telephone subscriber's
station 706 (typically the subscriber's home) and to the subscriber bank 708
or other financial institution, by way of example. Via line 710, the subscriber
can authorize the central facility 702 to charge the subscriber's account at
the bank 708. A response unit 210 (shown in FIGS. 6 and 8) is located at the
subscriber station 706. A central broadcast and monitoring facility 712 provides
a broadcast presentation 714 with a broadcast signal transmitted to the subscriber
station 706 to be observed by the subscriber. The subscriber responds to the
broadcast transmission by entering a response in the response unit 210. Outcome
criteria signals are transmitted via line 716 directly to the response unit
210. A coded signal transmitted via line 636 (described in FIG. 22) from the
central telephone facility 702 can be employed to activate the response unit
210.
The response unit 210, in terms of the presentation of FIG. 24, may be regarded
as a subscriber subsystem providing functions described hereinabove. These functions
are the decision entry provided by the subscriber-contestant upon use of the
keyboard of the response unit, comparing of the entered response with the criteria
sent by line 716 from the facility 712, the generation of a hard copy card which
serves as a token describing the amount of the award and presenting other information
needed for claiming a prize, and the dispensing of the token by the response
unit 210.
A number of methods in accordance with aspects of the invention will now be
described, the methods utilizing the electronic circuitry described herein.
It is noted that the systems of the various aspects of the invention can be
used to conduct contests, such as quiz shows wherein the answers to questions
are known at the time the questions are asked. The systems however, also lend
themselves to conducting games, contests or tasks involving predictions of the
outcome of future events, including games of chance. While the methods for conducting
such programs on radio or television programs vary, they all have the important
common capability of informing members of the remote audience without delay
whether the responses, predictions or gambles have met with success. The success
may be defined as an acceptable response to a task or question, an acceptable
prediction or the outcome of an event, or the winning of an award in a game
of chance. When desired, each successful member of the audience may be issued
a token or an award or prize virtually instantly after the success becomes known.
The token may include a monetary prize. Its is noted that all of the methods
described utilize electronic equipment at the locations of the viewer or listener
to evaluate responses, and to award successful participants. The system does
not require central computers, thereby obviating the need for simultaneously
processing large numbers of viewer responses at a central location.
Many events, including games, can be implemented by the methodology of the invention.
Such events take place on large and small defined areas ranging for instance
from an 18-hole golf course to a football field and baseball diamond, and to
a chess board. All of these areas have the characteristic in common of being
able to be subdivided so as to identify portions thereof or locations thereon.
Locations can be identified with the aid of grids with coordinates or other
identifying plan to implement the methodology of aspects of the invention.
Frequently, in the course of a game, an object is moved by a person, and a prediction
may be made as to the location to which the object moves. In some sports events
the object moved is the body of the athlete himself. A TV-viewer follows the
progress of such a game or contest and enters a prediction of an outcome on
an entering device by identifying the area or point at which the object is anticipated
to come to rest, or is to be placed by a person addressing the object. Such
an observer normally can follow the unfolding of the event on a TV-screen. Following
the event, such as in a football game, a track and field event, or a move by
a chess player, the producers of the TV-show identify the actual location to
which the object has moved. Coordinates of the location or other identification
signals are transmitted to remote sites of the TV viewers, so as to permit comparing
the actual location with the predicted location entered by television observers.
Response criteria for evaluating the outcome of the predictions are similar
to the previously described criteria of the instructional signals.
The prediction entering device prevents entries at or after the point in time
when the object being addressed, moves, or when a participant, such as an athlete,
commences action. The comparison and scoring circuits of the aforementioned
entering and evaluating devices at remote locations identify and score acceptable
predictions as defined by the instructional signals. A successful participant
is informed, when desired by a dispensing of printed coupons or magnetized cards,
as previously described, immediately following the relevant event or move of
an object.
In televising such an event, the producers superimpose a grid or coordinates
on the television picture for the purpose of enabling observers to identify
areas or points broadly or with as much specificity as is desired or practical
under the circumstances. Such a grid is helpful in making predictions and in
identifying outcome locations. A grid may be subdivided into portions of different
dimensions.
It is advantageous that the above-described predictive method can be applied
to a large variety of events and games in which an object is moved once or repeatedly,
such games including, by way of example, baseball, football, golf, and chess.
Depending on the size and configuration of the playing area, the area may be
sub-divided into larger and smaller portions. A prediction of a smaller portion
of the area to which an object may move, and therefore a more difficult prediction,
is rewarded with a prize of greater value than a prediction pertaining to a
larger portion. For example, a prediction in a golf match may pertain to the
location of a hit ball on large areas, such as a fairway or rough, or on smaller
areas, such as on the green, or even in the cup. Predictions may relate to the
ultimate outcome of two or more intermittent events, such as the location of
a golf ball after three strokes, the position of a chess piece after two moves,
or the total number of hits of a baseball player at the end of five innings.
To provide for such cumulative outcome predictions, data storage means as previously
described, are included in an observer's evaluating device.
Events included in a broadcast contest to which predictions relate may be presented
visually or audibly. In an aspect of the practice of the invention, a host or
commentator asks for one or more predictions and if a plurality of predictions
is available, a TV-viewer selects a prediction. If there exist two or more predictions,
outcome criteria are provided for evaluating the response of an observer or
contestant to all relevant outcomes, the outcome criteria being conveyed to
remote locations after an announced event, or events, has occurred. In another
embodiment, outcome criteria are conveyed relative to outcomes of events not
specifically made known or announced by a host, such as the final order in which
horses cross the finish line at the end of a race. This enables a TV-viewer
to elect to predict an outcome not previously mentioned in the transmission
from a central station, in the hope that outcome criteria relative to the prediction
will nevertheless be conveyed and that a correct prediction of such unannounced
event will be rewarded with a prize.
In case a participating TV viewer elects to predict the outcome of an event
not specifically identified or announced by the host, the participant runs the
risk that there will be no transmission of outcome criteria signals pertaining
to that participant's prediction, thus ruling out all chances of winning a prize.
It therefore is the twofold task of a TV-viewer in such a situation to anticipate
which unannounced event hopefully will be provided with outcome criteria, and
that the participant will correctly or acceptably predict the outcome. Awards
for such successful predictions will be correspondingly higher.
In view of the fact that in the above described example the outcome criteria
are conveyed to remote locations following the event to which the criteria relate,
the success or outcome criteria may be transmitted in uncoded and visually or
audibly intelligible form. When conveyed, in such open language, the response
criteria can serve to inform members of the remote audience of the event which
was selected for inclusion in the contest and to advise the members of the outcome
of the event.
A further use of the invention in conjunction with telephone facilities, as
disclosed in FIG. 22, will now be described. Dedicated telephone lines such
as the so called "900" numbers in the United States, or so-called PIN (person
identification number) or ANI (automatic number identification) lines, are used
with increasing frequency to request and obtain special services. These services
include a wide range of information and data which the telephone systems are
capable of providing, the systems being adapted to automatically playback specific
recordings or to provide answers to specific inquiries.
According to an aspect of the present invention, a tape playing facility is
provided at a central telephone station as a subscriber service. Tapes with
prerecorded audio or audiovisual recordings are played back to receivers at
remote locations over cable or over dedicated telephone lines, using modems
when required.
In a preferred embodiment, a question and answer game is conducted, and a user
of or subscriber to the telephone service who answers a question in an acceptable
manner receives an award as heretofore described. To conduct such a game, the
contents of a tape are formulated and recorded, including one or more sets of
messages. Each prerecorded message set comprises a question and an instructional
signal conveying answer criteria defining at least one correct or acceptable
answer.
The question is received in a form intelligible to humans and normally is accompanied
by an indication of the period of time a respondent has to enter a response
on a data entering device. If the response or answer criteria are transmitted
prior to the expiration of the allowed time interval, they are in coded or unintelligible
form. if the response criteria are transmitted following the time interval,
they can be in open language or other intelligible form. In the latter case,
response or answer criteria may consist of the actual correct answer or answers.
The answer criteria may include scoring instructions. If different levels of
difficulty are available, the scoring instructions convey the methodology or
mode of computing the amount of a prize awarded for acceptable answers at different
levels of difficulty.
At remote locations of members of the telephone audience, as described above,
members are provided with an electronic response and evaluation unit, which
as a minimum, includes a response entering device, means for comparing an entered
response to an acceptable response, a timing device and means for informing
a user of the telephone service of an earned award. It is understood, of course,
that communications equipment is available to a user for contacting the central
facility providing the service, in order to request the playback of a tape.
Appropriate means for audibly and/or visually presenting the contents of the
tape and for informing contestants of an award are provided.
In those instances where response criteria are received at remote locations
after the time interval allowed for responding to a task has expired, the response
criteria can include signals conveying one or more correct or acceptable responses
in both an instructional form and in an informative form. The signals, when
in instructional, normally unintelligible digital form, are capable of activating
and controlling circuits, such as the scoring elements of the response units
and, when converted into informative, intelligible form serve to notify game
participants of winning answers. When response criteria or responses are transmitted
prior to the end of the allowed time interval, transmission is rendered unintelligible
by coding or changing the speed of transmission of the signals. Depending on
the time of transmission before or after the elapsing of the time interval,
the answer criteria therefore may be unintelligible or may comprise the actual
acceptable answers in open language.
According to a preferred embodiment of the method, a question and answer game
is prerecorded on a magnetic tape as previously described. A question is posed
and a time limit, for example, of ten seconds is announced in open language,
visually and/or audibly. At the same time a participant's electronic unit is
directed by instructional signals to accept an entry by a participant for the
following ten seconds and then to evaluate the entered response in accordance
with response criteria. During these ten seconds, there is either no recording
or, if desired, a musical recording provided on the tape. Following expiration
of the ten second time interval, one or more acceptable and previously recorded
answers are announced in open language. The comparison and scoring means evaluate
a participant's entry relative to the transmitted response criteria. A successful
respondent is informed in a known manner, which can include the dispensing of
a monetary prize as described. Questions and answers may be at two or more difficulty
levels as described hereinabove.
In the operation of the system, a dedicated telephone line may be coupled to
a playback device which plays back one specific tape or one of a specific group
of tapes selected by a subscriber to the telephone service. Thus, by calling
a number, the caller will automatically receive a playback of a particular tape.
The equipment at a subscriber's remote location comprises a sub-system, including
the equipment for two-way communication between the remote location and the
central facilities and further including the elements of the response unit for
entering and evaluating answers. The two way communication equipment may include
means not only for directing a multiple digit call to a dedicated number, but
also for automatically activating means controlling the tape playback mechanism.
The sub-system may include means requiring only the lifting of a receiver or
the pushing of one button to activate the playback of a tape at a central location
for transmission to the caller's location.
When desired, the equipment at a subscriber's remote location includes previously
described means for selecting one of several difficulty levels chosen by a contestant,
answers at a higher difficulty level being rewarded with a larger prize. And,
as previously described, means are provided for generating a hard copy record
of an award earned by a participant, these means being capable of printing on
a coupon or magnetizing a plastic card so as to indicate the value of an award,
normally a monetary prize. The response unit in cooperation with a modem (FIG.
22) may transmit data indicating the amount of a prize won by a participant
over the two-way communicating system to a central location where the amount
of the prize is stored. The operators of the telephone service can make payment
of a prize amount to a winning subscriber in any fashion, including the crediting
of the account of a winning participant with the amount of a prize, such credited
amount being carried on the ledger of the operator and reflected in billing
the winning subscriber.
The method and system may be modified so that every time a subscriber dials
a dedicated number, such a call automatically authorizes the operator of the
service to charge an amount to the caller, which amount can be on a per use
basis, on a time basis, or ca be determined by the caller.
When desired by a participant, a prize amount can be electronically transferred
by the subscription service to a bank account of the participant so that the
amount of the prize is immediately available to the winner in such a game.
In another version of the present invention, members of a remote audience wager
on the outcome of an event. Members can place bets on the accuracy of their
respective predictions, but do not necessarily play against other members of
the audience.
Using a two-way communication system a participant, who has a line of credit
with an operator of a televised event, may choose a specific event and stipulate
the amount of a wager on the outcome of the event on which the participant wishes
to bet. Events, the outcome of which can be predicted, include sports, elections,
polls, and other kinds of happenings, the outcomes of which are capable of being
defined in terms of results, scores, points, decisions, and other measurements.
With reference to FIGS. 22 and 24, the system employs traditional telephone
facilities at a central location which may be operated by a telephone company,
a subscriber service, or by other facilities operators. The facilities are contacted
by a person wishing to place a bet on the outcome of an event, such contacting
being done by conventional communication means. The person contacting such central
facility in order to initiate a wager, may be referred to as an observer, subscriber,
wagerer or bettor. In contacting such a central facility, the observer of an
event to take place authorizes the central service organization to charge the
observer either a previously stipulated amount, an amount determined by the
real time use of the facility, or an amount stipulated by the observer, such
as is the case if the amount of the wager is fixed by the wagerer. The amount
charged to or authorized by the wagerer is billed to him directly, but may also
be debited by the central subscriber service to the wagerer's bank account.
Following authorization by the subscriber, the operator of the central service
initiates the playing of a recording or the transmission of a broadcast and
activates a sub-system of the subscriber, normally located at the subscriber's
home. In addition, the service operator accepts a bet on a specified outcome
of an event, such acceptance being done by a human operator or through electronic
communication. Thus, for example, within a bettor's line of credit, a bettor
who dials a "900" number and additional digits, can place a bet and, by dialing
a specific number of digits, the event and amount of a bet can be specified
by the subscriber.
At a central location, which may be the same as or different from that at which
the central telephone facility is located, events are broadcast to subscribers'
remote locations and the outcomes of events are monitored. Broadcast signals
of such events are transmitted to and received at remote locations, so that
subscribers can follow the progress of events as they unfold. Outcome criteria
signals defining the outcome of an event in absolute terms or in relation to
the predictions and wagers are transmitted to subscribers at remote locations.
The response unit at a subscriber's location informs the subscriber of a successful
prediction by generating and dispensing to a successful bettor a token of a
winning bet, such token being a printed coupon or magnetized card. The response
unit also scores a winning prediction in accordance with an applicable difficulty
level.
Payments computed and payable to or by a bettor can be debited or credited to
a bettor's account or monthly statements, or can be reflected directly on the
bettors bank account. Alternatively, when a winning token is generated and dispensed,
the token which has the amount won indicated thereon, can be submitted for credit
to the operator of the service, to a bank, or to another redemption center.
Following authorization of applicable
charges, a subscriber's sub-system can, when appropriate, be made operative
by signals sent over telephone wires or by another form of communication, including
wireless and cable systems. According to another aspect of the method, the subscriber's
sub-system can be activated by the subscriber, and a hard copy record of a successfully
predicted outcome is dispensed to the observer of an event. This method is preferred
when subscribers do not wish to place bets, as may be the case in a home or
in a public place in which members of a family or friends are gathered, or when
betting is illegal. Records issued in such an instance have no commercial value
unless validated by a verification number or a code which is only provided upon
a subscriber's having authorized an appropriate charge by the central telephone
or subscriber service. Verification data are transmitted to remote locations
via a communication link such as a telephone line or cable.
As an example of operating the system, two central facilities are provided,
one being a telephone subscriber service and the other being a station televising
a sports event, such as a boxing bout. Viewers are informed that they can wager
on the outcome of each round or on the final outcome of the bout, the wager
being a win, lose, or draw. Viewers also are informed that boxer A is a favorite
over boxer B and that a successful wager on boxer B will be rewarded with 200%
of the amount of the wager, whereas a successful wager on boxer will be rewarded
with 125% of the amount of the wager. Subscribers to the telephone service then
dial a dedicated number, including additional digits specifying a chosen round
and/or the final result and the amount wagered on each outcome.
Viewers watch the event on television and at the end of each round and/or of
the bout, instructional signals are sent from the central broadcast facility
to remote locations defining each outcome and providing scoring instructions
to subscriber response units for computing the amount won by a successful subscriber.
The invention may be applied to a game which is conducted from a central location
and enables players at remote locations to win prizes delivered instantly at
each player's location. Prizes normally take the form of tokens redeemable for
cash.
In an adaptation of the system described, players are provided with a response
unit and recording medium for the outputting of hard copy with a recording of
identifiable data. A first set of data has been provided on the recording medium
prior to delivery thereof to the players. The data may be presented as alphanumeric
or other symbols. For example, a set data may comprise a combination of six
letters and numbers which have been prerecorded on a tamper-resisting recording
medium.
The recording medium may consist of a paper tape divisible into sections or
it may consist of a plastic card having data magnetically recorded thereon.
In any event, such token or recording medium is capable of being placed in the
response unit for the purpose of having recorded thereon at least one additional
second set of alphanumeric data or symbols. Signals from a central station serve
the purpose of conveying data and controlling the printer of the response unit.
In the operation of such a system, a second set of data may comprise, for example,
six letters and/or numbers selected or picked at random at a central location.
Signals conveying the data are electronically transmitted to remote locations.
Transmission can take place over the air or by wire. The central transmitting
facility is adapted to activate and direct the printers to print the second
set of data. The printer also is directed then to print a third set of data
on the recording medium, the third set of data consisting of a verification
code or number.
The recording medium, which in this instance is a paper tape, can be separated
into sections, each section containing the first and second sets of numbers
or letters, as well as the verification code.
A player therefore receives a recording medium with at least three sets of data,
which data may be readable by individuals and/or may be machine readable.
If the game is played as a lottery, a winning recording medium is one which
has two sets of alphanumeric data or other symbols, which either match completely,
match partially, or have some other previously defined correlation. Partially
matching sets of data can be rewarded with small prizes which become larger
as more of the digits match. Other forms of correlation can be established,
whether mathematical or not, including for instance multiples and fractions.
When desired, the central transmission facility can instruct the printer to
record additional information on the recording medium. The response unit compares
the two sets of alphanumeric or other data mentioned, computes the amount of
a prize in accordance with instructional signals transmitted from a central
location, and indicates the amount of the prize on the recording medium.
According to a preferred embodiment of the method employed in the system described,
a player is able to discern whether two sets of alphanumeric data on the recording
medium are a match, a partial match, or have some other correlation; but the
player may not know the amount of the monetary prize presented on the outputted
recording medium. The medium, which may be a printed coupon or a magnetized
card is delivered by a winning player to a redemption center where the player
is informed of the size of the prize. Such a redemption center may be a place
of business, for example, a store in which such a prize evidenced by a printed
coupon or magnetized card may be redeemed for cash and/or merchandise. This
method of informing players that they have won a prize, without knowing its
amount, is utilized to attract buyers to a place of business. The above method
and system permit conducting a game similar to a lottery by retail businesses,
which game is purely a game of chance and in which players at home may participate
without charge to them.
Yet another feature of the invention is demonstrated with respect to FIG. 14
which allows for a replaying of a previously recorded program without further
replay of previously recorded of response criteria including an acceptable response
and a scoring mode. This is useful in the case of an advertiser who provides
a program of a situation about which questions may be asked, the program being
recorded along with response criteria on a tape for distribution to members
of the public. However, possibly for reasons of awarding only one prize per
tape to successful respondents, the advertiser wishes to conduct a question
and answer procedure only once so that prizes can be awarded only once. But,
the program situation which typically includes descriptions of a advertised
products may be played back numerous times.
This feature may be demonstrated, by way of example, by constructing the recorder
520 of FIG. 4 with both a playback head 718 and a record head 20 disposed alongside
the path of a tape 722 upon which the foregoing program and response criteria
have been recorded. This is accomplished by providing the recording medium of
the tape 722 with a first recording portion which stores the program situation
including advertising information (or other data), and a second recording portion
which includes the response criteria. The distinction between the two portions
of the recording medium is shown diagrammatically in FIG. 14 by use of a set
of dots at 724 on the tape 722 to identify the second portion of the recording
medium. Included in the second portion is a digital code which commands a disabling
of the recorded response criteria data after the response criteria has been
played back. The tape 722 moves, in a direction shown by an arrow, from the
playback head 718 to the record head 720. As the second region at 724 moves
past the playback head 720, the digital code is retrieved along line 346 and
decoded by a decoder 726 also located in the recorder 520. Upon receipt of the
digital code, the decoder 726 records a disabling signal upon, or erases, the
second portion of the recording medium so that the response criteria originally
recorded thereon can no longer be used. Alternatively, the recording of a disabling
signal may be replaced by a step of physically impairing the integrity of the
second recording portion.
With reference to FIG. 25, and in accordance with a further aspect of the invention,
it is desirable to provide a respondent with the capacity to select an area
of interest in the program transmitted from a central station to a remote receiving
station. This area of interest may pertain to answering questions relating to
specific parts of the subject matter presented in the transmitted program, or
to the nature of awards which may be provided to successful contestants. By
way of example in the nature of the questions requiring a response, the questions
may be directed to historical aspects of the material being presented on the
program, or may be directed to the manner of construction of items presented
in the program, or to the cost of the items. For example, in a program devoted
to the merchant marine in which both new an old forms of ships are presented,
questions may be of an historical nature directed to when and where certain
forms of ships were employed. Or the questions may be directed to the manner
of construction of ships in both ancient times and the present time. Questions
might also be directed to the cost of buying a ship and the cost of maintaining
a ship. During the presentation of the ship program advertisers may display,
by way of example, merchandise such as clothing to be worn on cruises and on
other vacations. Coupons awarded to successful contestants may specify a discount
towards specific styles of the clothing or, alternatively may provide a discount
to certain marine products shown in the program or, by way of further example,
toward theater tickets.
A specific type of award is associated with specific types or categories of
questions which a contestants may select in order to avail himself or herself
the benefit of a preferred category of award. Thus, a contestants choice of
area of interest may be based on the subject matter of the questions or on the
nature of the award. This capacity for selecting an area of interest greatly
increases the chance that a contestant will participate, and that the contestant
will redeem the coupon. Fortunately, as will be shown in the ensuing description,
this aspect of the invention can be practiced with a response unit, such as
the response unit 22 of FIG. 4, the response unit 210 of FIG. 8, or a response
unit 800 to be described in FIG. 26, with no more than a minimal change relating
to the addressing of memories therein.
The addressing of the memories is demonstrated in FIG. 25 with respect to the
response unit 210 of FIG. 8. As has been explained hereinabove with reference
to FIG. 8, command signals entered at the keyboard 356 are operative via the
control logic unit 350 to activate the memories 330, 332, and 334. In the foregoing
description of the system 200 of FIG. 6, or the system 200A of FIG. 7, the central
station transmits a televised program plus answering instructions, scoring criteria
and a message to appear upon a coupon to a remote station wherein the response
unit 210 operates with the answering instructions, the scoring criteria and
the coupon message upon activation by a contestant. In particular, it is noted
that the transmission of answering instructions, the scoring criteria and the
coupon message relate to a single set of questions in only one area of interest,
such as the area A indicated in the memories 332, 334 and 330, respectively.
However, in the practice of this aspect of the invention wherein the contestant
can select areas of interest, the central station sends also additional sets
of answer instructions, scoring criteria and coupon messages for other areas
of interest such as the area B and the area C shown in FIG. 25. While only three
areas of interest are shown, it is understood that more areas may be employed
if desired. Also, by way of example, four questions are shown in FIG. 25, it
being understood that more questions may be provided if desired.
To practice the invention, the response unit 210 is provided with the capacity
to store the requisite information for a plurality of interest areas to enable
the respondent to choose an area of interest. In the operation of a response
unit 210, the respondent first selects the area of interest, after which the
response unit 210 functions in the same manner as has been described with reference
to FIG. 8. The selection is accomplished by entering at the keyboard 356 a letter,
or other symbol, designating the desired area of interest. The entered letter,
as shown in FIG. 25, serves to address the appropriate regions in each of the
memories 330, 332, and 334, so that the response unit 210 can then function
in accordance with the coupon message, the response criteria and the scoring
criteria of the selected area of interest. The response unit 210 compares responses
of the respondent with the acceptable answers stored in the memory 332 to identify
an acceptable response, scores and times responses in accordance with data stored
in the memory 334, and outputs a coupon with redemption and advertising data
thereon in accordance with information stored in the memory 330. If desired,
the response unit 210 may be provided with a dedicated selector device, such
as a selector switch 802, shown in the simplified view of the keyboard in FIG.
25, for addressing the memories.
The capacity to select an area of interest is particularly useful for the merchandising
of products with the aid of a game show broadcast from the central station 202
of FIG. 6, or transmitted in prerecorded fashion by use of the recording apparatus
presented in the cabin 500 of FIG. 11 or the system 618 of FIG. 22. The respondent
plays the role of a contestant in the game or quiz program, and also acts as
a potential shopper for merchandise presented in the program. By use of the
selector switch 802, the shopper selects the area of interest having the product
of interest. The shopper then plays the game or quiz in earnest to receive a
coupon which facilitates purchase of the product by redemption of the coupon.
If desired verification codes may be imprinted on the coupon in a manner described
hereinabove. A product may also be selected prior to responding to a task, subject
of course, to entering an acceptable answer or prediction.
FIG. 26 shows the response unit 800. The response unit 800 provides the functions
of the response unit 210 of FIG. 8 by use of a computer 804 which replaces certain
components of the response unit 210, namely, the comparators 372 and 374, the
registers 376 and 378, the multipliers 380 and 382, the summer 384, and the
accumulator 386. The computer 804 is operative with a memory 806 which provides
the program for performing the functions of the replaced components, and also
connects with the control logic unit 350 for interaction with the memories 330,
332 and 334, the timing unit 336, and the buffer store 336. The computer 804,
which may be constructed as a microprocessor, outputs signals to the dispenser
390 and to the scoring logic unit 370 as does the accumulator 386 in FIG. 8.
Also, the computer 804 can provide data on the display 358 via the control logic
unit 350.
An advantage in the use of the computer 804 is that the memory 806 may store
algorithms for providing more complex routines for a more versatile scoring
of the responses than is possible with the response unit 210 of FIG. 8. For
this purpose, it is desirable to provide the memory 806 with an external replaceable
storage medium such as a tape which may be mounted on a card, a dedicated replaceable
read-only memory (ROM) chip, or a floppy disk so that scoring can be customized
to match the product selected by the respondent shopper. The memory may be provided
with advertising data and redemption instructions as well as verification material
to be placed on the coupon awarded to the successful respondent shopper. This
enhances the merchandising capabilities of this method of the invention wherein
the respondent selects areas of interest. Also, by virtue of the connection
of the computer 804 to the dispenser 390, the computer can direct the imprinting
of specific material on the coupon in accordance with specific instructions
of an advertiser or merchant.
In some cases, it may be desirable to provide the functions of comparing responses
with acceptable answers, identifying acceptable responses, and scoring the acceptable
responses at a central station such as the central station 202 of FIG. 22. This
is accomplished by providing the system 618 with a response evaluation unit
808 connected to the switchboard 622. The response evaluation unit 808 includes
the computer 804 and the memory 806 of FIG. 26 so as to be able to perform the
functions of comparing, identifying, and scoring. By virtue of the connection
of the evaluation unit 808 to the switchboard 622, the functions of the evaluation
unit 808 are provided to the central station 202 in response to signals from
the remote stations. For example, these functions could be disabled in the response
units 210 of the remote stations and provided by the central station with the
response evaluation unit 808 employing algorithms not available to the remote
stations.
FIG. 27 shows a flow chart of the program for operation of the computer 804
of FIG. 26. Operation begins at block 810 wherein the computer receives instructions
from the program memory 330 via the control logic unit 350. Then at block 812,
the computer reads the keyboard 356 via the buffer store 366 to determine what
entry may have been made by the respondent. If no entry has been made, operation
loops back to the block 812 for a subsequent reading of the keyboard. If an
entry has been made by the respondent, such as the entry of a response to a
question, the computer reads the memories 332 and 334 at block 814 for response
and scoring criteria or instructions.
The procedure advances to block 816 wherein a comparison is made between the
respondents answer with acceptable responses stored in the response memory 332.
This is followed by an identification of correct and partially correct answers
of the respondent. At block 818, the computer performs the scoring function
giving full credit and -partial credit in accordance with the scoring instructions
stored in the memory 334. This is accomplished by using the scoring criteria
including difficulty level, timing of response, and key word or full text credit
where applicable in accordance with the nature of the response to the question.
Then at block 820, the computer tallies previous scores from previous answers
in a set of answers, if applicable to the questions at hand, this function having
been done by the accumulator 386 in the response unit 210 of FIG. 8.
The computer again checks the keyboard at block 822 to see if there is a further
entry. If there is a further entry, operation loops back to block 814. If there
is no further entry after a predetermined interval of time, operation proceeds
to block 824 for determination of the award. Then, at block 826, the computer
signals the scoring logic unit 370 to command the dispenser 360 to issue the
coupon. The coupon is imprinted with material based on instructions and data
stored in the program memory 330, and may also contain data stored in the supplemental
memory 806.
The teachings presented in the preceding embodiments for the systems and methods
of the invention are applicable generally to the selection aspect of the invention
providing the product choice and choice of area of interest. The following discussion
amplifies the description of the practice of the selection aspect of the invention
to provide a full appreciation thereof.
In many instances, local or regional suppliers of goods and services develop
their own and highly focused marketing priorities. As an example, a local retailer
may wish to dispose rapidly of certain excess inventory or of perishable goods.
Nationally broadcast programs may not be the most suitable forum for such promotions.
Frequently, suppliers prefer to sponsor a coupon program directed at local or
regional audiences. Until now, however, local newspapers have been the only
forum of any consequences available to such local sponsors for detailed product
offers.
The discounts or prizes are in many instances applicable to merchandise sold
in stores and supermarkets. Specifically included are children's stores. When
desired, the products to which a discount applies may also include such items
as admission tickets, travel tickets, total accommodations, subscriptions, vouchers,
personal and any other marketable services, including service agreements.
The components of the several systems and methods for practicing the invention
will now be described.
A central broadcasting facility includes the normal elements for transmitting
a program. For purposes of illustration, the invention will be described in
terms of television, but is equally applicable to radio.
The television program is received and presented on standard TV-receivers at
viewers' remote locations. The program includes one or more tasks, such as questions.
Members of the broadcast audience who wish to become contestants on the spur
of the moment are informed of the time allowed for a response to each announced
task.
Each task is accompanied by one or more predetermined acceptable responses.
Instructional signals conveying response criteria defining acceptable responses
are electronically transmitted from a central facility to remote locations,
said signals being referred to as response criteria signals. They include data
conveying the allowed period of time and mode for scoring an acceptable response,
i.e. for assigning a calculated value to the prize coupon dispensed to a successful
contestant. The response criteria are received at remote locations and may be
modified or reformatted by a conductor of the program from task to task.
The electronic transmission can be done in any known manner: it can be on a
radio frequency, via optical or light impulse codes, via cable, vertical blanking
intervals or other means.
If desired, a task, such as a question, may be answered at one or more levels
of difficulty. If there is more than one level of difficulty, the lowest or
base difficulty level normally is selected by the broadcaster and a higher difficulty
level may be selected by a respondent. Means for such selection are provided
to the broadcaster and to each member of said audience.
Another group of predetermined signals is transmitted from a central broadcasting
facility to remote locations conveying a listing of or information pertaining
to the products of sponsors of such a broadcast. The term "product" includes
goods and services whether specifically promoted in the course of such a broadcast,
such as a commercial, or only appearing in the product listing of a sponsor.
The information conveyed by these broadcast signals is referred to as product
signals and comprises prices, specifications, sizes, capacaties, colors, packaging
and other characteristics, as well as availability and discounts applicable
to specified products. Product signals may also include "sales", "specials",
free samples and any other information pertaining to such products and deemed
useful by a sponsor. The product information is modified or reformatted as determined
by a sponsor.
Members of the broadcast audience are equipped with means for receiving and
presenting the broadcast program, which includes tasks or may essentially consist
only of tasks. Members of said audience have means to receive the response criteria
signals and the product signals, the data for both being stored in appropriate
storage means at members' locations. The product signals can include all the
promotional data mentioned. Product information may be presented to viewers
on a standard TV-set or on a separate screen or display. In addition, members
are provided with means to enter a response to a task, such response data also
being stored at members' locations.
The response criteria data product data, when modified, replace or supersede
any previously stored data of the same nature. Response criteria include, when
desired, a formula for placing a value on an acceptable response, referred to
as scoring mode.
The means provided at members' locations for displaying the latest product list
and other information desired by sponsors permit sponsors or broadcasters to
delete, substitute, add or modify information. Audience members are equipped
with means for individually selecting from said product list a product they
prefer and intend to purchase. Said selecting means may be separate, or may
be associated with the means for entering a viewer's response to a task.
The equipment provided at each remote location normally includes signal receiving
means and presentation means for the program, task and product information;
signal receiving means for response criteria; entering means for response and
product selection; data storage means; comparing and scoring means; and means
for generating and dispensing a prize token.
The above mentioned means at contestants' locations may conveniently be combined
into a response unit.
The methods described lend themselves well to narrow-casting. The term narrowcasting
is defined as the ability to transmit product or service information to a select
group of members of a broadcast audience. The present method described, which
dispenses prizes to individuals intending to purchase a specified product or
products, narrowcasts product information because only viewers with a discount
incentive will use the product information. Conversely, product information
will use the product information. Conversely, product information can be utilized
only by viewers who have earned a prize through skill and have qualified for
a discount applicable to a selected product.
A response entered by a member and stored, if necessary, is compared by comparison
means with the applicable response criteria. A winning contestant's prize is
calculated by scoring means on the basis of the applicable scoring mode. The
product selection and a winning respondents score are outputted to a device
at each contestant's location for generating a permanent record, such as a coupon,
which, when dispensed, has provided thereon an indication of the prize and of
the chosen product, including any sales or redemption information the advertiser
wants the shoppers to have. At least one scoring mode or base is always required
and used in order to determine the value of a prize. In some instances, only
one mode of scoring may be desired. This is the case if only one fixed award
is to be made to winners obviating the computation of a score. An example would
be a "true or false" type of answer. Such a single fixed award is made to all
successful participants in case a sponsor intends to introduce a new product,
in which event winning contestants are given the opportunity to select a free
sample from a number of different available products. The chosen product is
then specified on a prize coupon.
The device for generating a permanent record normally comprises a printer capable
of printing or otherwise marking on a substrate, i.e. the recording medium,
the award information, product information, redemption terms and a verification
number; the record, such as coupon, includes commercial messages, including
advertisements and announcements of special events and prizes. When desired,
prizes may be awarded to a successful contestant over and above the award for
an acceptable response; examples being "blind" or sweepstake prizes.
The term "prize" is intended to include all forms of rewards, such as cash,
prizes, discounts, free merchandise, other financial and non-financial benefits,
certificates, recognition or benefits. The terms "prize" and "discount" as used
herein may occasionally be interchangeable.
The term "redeem" is intended to include the collection of a prize by delivering
or presenting a coupon personally, through the mail, or other forms of obtaining
a prize or discount upon surrendering or in exchange for a coupon.
The term "sales outlet" is intended to include retail and public stores, redemption
centers, catalog centers and all sales location whether accessed in person or
by mail.
The word "conductor" or "host" as used for instance in the term "conductor of
a broadcast transmission" is intended to include the individuals engaged in
the operation of formulating a message or program for broadcasting on behalf
of an advertiser, manufacturer, store or sponsor.
The term "dissimilar" is intended to include the meaning of different and non-identical.
The term "shopper" is intended to include individuals who are potential or perspective
buyers of products and services.
The term "scoring basis" is intended to include complex scoring based on a formula,
credits earned, difficulty level, time consumed and other criteria, as well
as an automatic or fixed scoring basis, such as a single and universally applicable
score as would be applied to a "yes or no" answer. An example of a fixed scoring
basis would be a 10% discount prize for every correct answer entered within
the allowed time limit.
A "correlation" of alphanumeric or other symbols may take the form of a complete
or partial match or any other mathematical or predetermined correlation thereof.
The term "listing" as in "product listing" is intended to include the names
of products, their specifications, prizes, discounts and other product information.
The term "matching" is intended to include any predetermined correlation of
alphanumerics or symbols.
The term "superior" as in "superior response" is intended to include answers,
response and predictions that are more accurate, more comprehensive, more responsive
or entered within a shorter period of time.
The term "acceptable response" is intended to include answers to questions and
prediction of events which are wholly correct, or sufficiently or in part correct,
or which otherwise qualify for a prize, discount, recognition or award.
The term "conjointly" as used herein refers to the transmission and reception
of electronic signals and the presentation of a task-setting message and of
product information conveyed by said signals in combination, taking place partially
or entirely concurrently or following each other so as to form a joined presentation.
The signals electronically transmitted and conveying task messages are referred
to as the task-setting signals. The signals, electronically transmitted and
conveying the response criteria are referred to as the response criteria signals.
The signals electronically transmitted and conveying a product list or product
information are referred to as product information signals. The signals electronically
transmitted and conveying the outcome criteria of a prediction are referred
to as outcome or success criteria.
The product signals may include information regarding additional or special
discounts or other prizes over and above, and unrelated to, the coupon prize.
For example, a product listing may include under one or more products the statement
"The purchase of this product doubles your coupon prize". This form of direct
marketing gives managers a great deal of maneuverability including sales on
short notice. These types of messages presented to shoppers for instance on
a TV-terminal, or LCD-screen, or appearing on prize coupons, can be modified
upon a seller's instructions on very short notice, such as through telephonic
instructions by a store manager to a broadcast station which transmits the response
criteria and other instructional signals.
Typically, the printer includes means for storing a recording medium, for instance
a continuous paper tape which, following the printing of a coupon, is severed
or divided into coupon sections. According to the present invention, the device
includes known means capable of dispensing tokens, such as coupons of larger
or smaller size, depending on the amount of text printed on such coupon and
having desired configurations. When desired, for example in the case of an educational
quiz as described below, the printer can be designed for the presentation of
graphics or it can take the form of a telefax device capable of depicting pictures,
drawings and the like.
Using the present methods and the systems described, a broadcaster or a sponsor
formulates task sets, the sets each comprising task-setting and response criteria
signals, being broadcast successively. Tasks may be interspersed in programs
or program segments and may be broadcast individually or intermittently. Each
task is accompanied by one or more acceptable responses. One acceptable response
may apply to more than one task, such as the answer "yes" applying to a number
of questions. A task-setting message can comprise a question requiring an answer,
or a solicitation or request for a prediction of the outcome of a future event.
Operationally, these two types of task-setting messages and shoppers' responses
thereto are treated similarly, except that in the case of a question-, the period
of time allowed for entering an answer normally is fixed, whereas in the case
of a prediction, the entering or further entering of predictive information
or the modification of predictions is not necessarily inhibited after a fixed
period of time, but is inhibited prior to or at approximately the time of the
occurrence of the event.
The response or outcome criteria signals are broadcast from a central location,
which may or may not be the location of the task broadcast. The product information
signals normally are broadcast but may be broadcast from another central location.
The product signals may be modified at any time as directed by a sponsor.
In the operation of the system described, a retailer prepares a listing of products
selected for sales promotion in the target market. The products selected may
be designated by name, but often are numbered and may be divided into categories.
The products listings displayed at members, locations are grouped accordingly.
If the product listing of a sponsor is lengthy, it can be displayed to members
in successive segments or groupings. This is achieved by the use of known display
and scrolling devices. Members' display devices may also be adapted to display
and re-display successive listings of products or lists of numbered products
in different categories as and when desired and such additional lists may be
called up in sequence by a member of the broadcast audience until a desired
product category and/or a specific product is displayed which a member intends
to buy.
When preferred, the entire presentation of product information can be performed
on television. In that event, the product listing can be shown on the television
screen and the instructional signals are transmitted on the audio sideband frequency
of the TV-program. Alternatively, the product listing can be shown on a liquid
crystal display or on a small, separate, passive TV-screen. Both the passive
terminal and the response unit include comparison, scoring and printing circuits
receiving their radio command signals via a TV-audio or radio sub-carrier.
Using the split-screen television technique, the product information can conveniently
be displayed along with other portions of the TV-program. This method is particularly
easy and economical to implement on an automated cable channel, which for example
can display concurrently a question and a product list.
The selected product is identified by touching numbered buttons on a respondent's
entry device, or by other means. This selection is outputted to and is stored
in a memory coupled to the printer or to means for computing the coupon value.
The coupons may carry the same percentage value, but a different value in absolute
terms, depending on the price of the merchandise. For example, for the same
correct answer or prediction a $5.00 item selected by a contestant may be subject
to a $.50 discount, whereas a $2.50 item is subject to a $.25 discount, the
computation being performed by scoring means. In order to accommodate a variety
of differently priced products, the coupon value can be expressed in terms of
a percentage discount applicable to any product selected by a member.
If a higher difficulty level is chosen, the absolute monetary award or the percentage
of the discount is raised. As an example, at the basic or first level of difficulty,
the discount is 10%, at level two it is 15% and at level three it is 20%.
The response unit may include a self-contained memory which lists products for
long term use. Memories of this kind, such as boards or cards for use in the
response units, may be in interchangeable form for substitution in the response
unit as required. For example, when a member receives a new coupon tape, whether
in the mail or through personal pickup at a store, a sponsor may utilize the
opportunity to provide such a member with a revised memory board which is supplied
to such member along with the new tape and inserted in or connected to the response
unit. Such revised memory is valid until replaced. Normally, the product listings
assign numbers to individual products for use by shoppers. The response units
at members, remote locations may be equipped with a memory capable of retaining
all of the product items of a retailer for a predetermined period of time. Products
may be numbered permanently or on an ad hoc basis. Periodically, say every day,
the retailer conveys a listing of the names or numbers of products selected
for promotion on that day. A sponsor's product listing may be stored in a memory
for extended periods of time. The memory may be part of the display means permanently
storing product information. The shopper is provided with control means to activate
the screen displaying such listing at any time and further is provided with
means to enter and indicate one or more items of interest to such shopper in
the near future.
The selection of said item is stored in a memory coupled to the means informing
shoppers of items chosen by the sponsor for promotion. The display and selection
means are further provided with comparing means and alarm means, visual or audible,
to inform or alert a shopper when the item of interest to the shopper is one
chosen by the sponsor to which a prize is applicable. This method enables shoppers
to wait until an item on a shopper's marketing list is announced as one eligible
for a special prize and then attempt to qualify for such a prize by responding
to a question. In such an event a shopper's product selection is entered prior
to the entering of an answer or prediction.
Prize coupons can be redeemed at a sales outlet specified on said coupon; other
provisions may appear on coupons, such as dates and terms of redemption. A discount
or other prize specified on a coupon may be made applicable to a group or mixture
of products which includes the product specifically selected by the contestant,
as well as other products to be promoted. Coupons may be redeemed in person,
by mail, or by telephone using the validation code on the coupons to verify
its authenticity.
In an alternative embodiment, contestants' display means are directed by the
product signals to display only the names or numbers of product items selected
by a sponsor from the comprehensive listing of products permanently stored in
the memory of the response units. The product numbers thus displayed and applying
for example to a "special" on sale the same day may be changed easily and quickly.
A sponsor may provide printed lists of all products to viewers, each product
being permanently numbered so that a viewer can relate a broadcast product number
to a specific product.
When preferred, the entire presentation of product information can be performed
on television. In that event, the product listing can be shown on the television
screen, using for example the split screen or window technique, and the instructional
signals can be transmitted on the audio sideband frequency of the TV-program.
Alternatively, the product listing can be shown on a small, separate, passive
terminal screen, which can be part of the response unit.
The methods provide, when desired, for an announcement of product information
by the host of a TV-broadcast. This embodiment is preferred when the information
is to be particularly emphasized or relayed to the public as quickly as possible.
In that event, the host indicates to members of the broadcast audience the products
or the reference numbers applying to specific products, so that a contestant,
by touching appropriate buttons on a keypad of the response unit, can designate
the product which is to be identified on the coupon dispensed to a successful
contestant. An on-stage or off-stage announcer can orally describe the product
and related information, while the corresponding visual information can be retained
on the screen for as long as is desired.
The present invention has applications in areas other than the traditional promotion
of commercial merchandise. An example is an inventory of perishable produce
which will have to be discarded, unless sold within 48 hours. A "special" on
such produce can be announced on very short notice, the produce carrying a 40%
discount if purchased within 48 hours. The following day, the discount provided
on prize coupons can be raised to 75%, if the produce is purchased that same
day. It is evident that a store manager will prefer to salvage 25% of the retail
value of a product to a total loss. As an additional promotion device, the basic
level of difficulty in answering a quest-ion can be dropped, so as to generate
an even larger number of prize winning shoppers. As an additional illustration,
in the example, a product selection may be left unchanged for all tasks presented,
or may be changed when the desired number or quantity of products has been reached
to which the prizes won by such a member are applicable. The system can be adapted
to permit contestants to select more than one product to be specified on a prize
coupon, provided all of such products are included in the listing of products
eligible for discounted purchase.
A prize can be made available to a shopper in the form of a coupon carrying
a discount on a product or in another form, such as a cash prize, a credit or
other benefit collected personally, by telephone, or through the mail.
In an alternative embodiment of the present method, the broadcaster or organizer
of a program composes and provides to viewers product listings supplied by a
plurality of sponsors. In such an event a program initiator periodically collects
information from several local suppliers with respect to the products each of
them wishes to promote. Based on such information, the program initiator or
broadcaster than prepares a composite listing of appropriately numbered products
available from a plurality of suppliers, which listing is announced and/or displayed
to the remote audience on their display screens. The response criteria signals
instruct the printer to output a hard copy record stipulating the sales outlet
at which the products of the respective sponsors can be purchased using a discount
token.
Thus, the latest product information can be conveyed to members of the remote
audience and can be updated at any time. A sponsor can alter the instructional
signals by making a telephone call to the local FM-station. This adds a great
deal of flexibility to the promotional efforts of regional producers and local
retailers. Obviously, the principle of the systems and methods described can
be applied also to national broadcasts. In that event, the sponsors of an advertising
campaign or program lists only products to be promoted on a nationwide basis.
It will be clear from the description of the coupons that, apart from carrying
a prize, the coupons can serve a an effective direct marketing tool having advantages
which no other form of promotion can match. The methods of the present invention
make it practical and economical to combine the delivery in a shopper's home
of a promotional hard copy record representing a financial award with sales
information of specific interest to the winner of the prize at the time of receipt.
The fact that the contestant has specified a product selected for intended purchase
signifies that such a shopper is likely to visit the sponsor's store and examine
the coupon and its other promotional messages closely. Being in the store and
exposed to another product promoted on the coupon, the contestant will at least
seriously think about the other products promoted.
As an example, a dispensed coupon can carry a discount on a first product selected
by a TV-viewer and, in addition, can carry a "buy one, get one free" message
regarding a second product, the latter product being much more likely to be
purchased once a shopper has entered a sales outlet than if the product had
been the subject of a free-standing magazine insert.
Thus, a prize coupon carrying a discount on a first specified product and redeemable
in a specified sales outlet, can be utilized to attract a shopper to said sales
outlet in order to induce said shopper to purchase a second product available
in the same sales outlet, said coupon carrying an additional discount or prize
on a second product.
Coupons dispensed to winners normally bear a verification number or code. When
desired, sweepstake or other prizes may be awarded in addition to the prizes
applicable to scored responses, such additional prizes being awarded to a small
number of winners determined in any suitable fashion.
Such additional prize information is conveyed to members, locations through
the transmission of additional response criteria signals. For example, if the
verification code consists of six digits, the last three digits in their specific
order may constitute the "lucky number" of the day, if matched by a 3-digit
number chosen by a sponsor on that day, entitling the holder of the winning
coupon to an additional prize upon redemption of the coupon in a sales establishment
or other specified location. The three digits chosen by the sponsor or broadcaster
can be revealed at the place of redemption, or can be transmitted with the response
criteria signals. The number of such additional prizes, which can range up to
the value of sweepstake prizes, is controllable. In the above instance, the
number of winning coupons is one per thousand coupons dispensed.
The fact that a prize coupon is issued only to contestants who have won it through
skill, make it legally permissible in many locations to attach larger or even
sweepstake prizes to such coupons. The delivery of a prize-winning record at
a sales location preferably is tied to the personal delivery thereof, but may
also be performed by using the mail or telephone.
The present invention combines practical, psychological and financial inducements
to bring about an increased rate of coupon redemption by television viewers
and radio listeners. A member of the broadcast audience who has selected a product
because its purchase is timely, who wins a discount prize through personal skill,
and who will save on the purchase of the product, is very likely to redeem such
a prize coupon by buying the product at the specified sales outlet.
A number of additional methods intended to induce TV-viewers to redeem coupons
will now be described. The instructional signals directing the response units
at viewers' locations to generate a token, such a coupon, direct the coupon
generator or printer to generate and dispense to one successful contestant more
than one coupon at a time. Multiple coupons may be awarded for superior responses.
For example, a total prize may be awarded in the form of three coupons redeemable
upon purchase of two or more items or kinds of merchandise, or a total prize
may be awarded consisting of two identical coupons for the same merchandise.
Additional coupons and cash prizes may be dispensed for one acceptable response
at a high difficulty level or for an exceptionally comprehensive answer. If
more than one coupon is awarded for one response, the two or more coupons may
have different values, redemption dates or places of redemption, in order to
increase the number of shoppers attracted to sales establishments on any given
day or to induce a shopper to visit a place of redemption more than once.
In another embodiment of the methods described, coupons dispensed to winners
of an award are provided with first code symbols, said symbols varying from
coupon to coupon, an example being consecutive six-digit numbers. The first
code symbols may have previously been provided on said coupons, for instance
on the coupon tape prior to the insertion of said tape into the coupon generating
means. The first code symbols can also be provided on the coupons at approximately
at the time of or subsequent to the printing of the prize indication. The first
and second codes together constitute a winning combination if they match or
bear a predetermined correlation, said correlation having been determined by
an organizer of the broadcast, such as a sponsor, or advertiser. As an example,
in the case of a six-digit number code, a correlation may be determined to exist
if the last three digits on such a coupon match. Other code forms may be devised.
Winning codes or code combinations normally are not intelligible, i.e. not identifiable
as a winning code, by a contestant at his location and are revealed to a shopper
only at the place of redemption of the prize coupon.
A code may be alphanumerical and/or comprise other symbols, which code is only
machine-readable at the place of redemption, so that the bearer of such a coupon
will not know whether a prize coupon caries an additional prize until and until
and unless said coupon is redeemed. The opportunity of winning an additional
"blind" prize, the value of which is not discernible by a contestant who already
has won a prize through skill, i.e. by correctly answering a question, will
in many instances be the decisive factor that will make the holder of such a
coupon decide to visit a store or other place of redemption. A coupon may carry
a discount applicable to the price of a first selected product as described,
and in addition, the generating means, such as a printer, may be directed by
the instructional signals to provide on the coupon indications of an additional
prize or other benefit tied to the purchase of a second product. The second
product may be specified by the contestant, or it may be specified by a sponsor,
or it may be an unspecified product. In the latter case the holder of such a
coupon will be able to purchase the selected product at a discount and apply
the additional prize to a second product selected once the shopper is in the
place of redemption.
In another use of the invention, a combined method is employed to raise the
redemption rate of coupons preprinted in magazines, newspapers, free-standing
inserts and the like, hereinafter referred to as preprinted coupons. The following
examples illustrate a number of uses of the response unit of the invention in
combination with the above mentioned preprinted coupons.
A hard copy record generated at a shopper's location bears a stipulation to
the effect that, upon presentation of a specified or otherwise identified preprinted
coupon together with the generated record, the shopper is entitled to an additional
prize. The prize may be specified on the generated record, or it may be a "blind
prize" which is revealed to the shopper only at the place of redemption of the
preprinted coupon. It may also be printed on the coupon contained in the free-standing
insert. In another version of the method, the preprinted coupons are provided
with an identification, such as an alphanumeric or other code. Coupons dispensed
to a prize-winning shopper by his or her response unit also are provided with
an alphanumeric or other code. A shopper presenting a preprinted coupon and
a prize-winning coupon having matching or correlated codes is entitled to an
additional prize, which may be a sweepstake prize. The value of the additional
prize is disclosed to such a shopper only at the sales outlet. All of the methods
described will raise the redemption rates of coupons.
If desired the steps of comparing entered responses to the applicable response
criteria and of identifying and scoring prize-winning responses can be performed
at a central location, in which event shoppers' entered responses are electronically
transmitted to a central location, such as by telephone and modem. In such a
situation, means for comparing, identifying and scoring are provided at a central
location, these means operating in the manner described previously with respect
to the response unit at a remote station. Instructional signals governing the
generating of a hard copy record are then electronically transmitted to shoppers'
locations, at which location said records are generated and dispensed. The instructional
signals can be transmitted to shoppers' remote locations in any known manner,
such as on an FM-radio frequency, or, in television transmissions through the
vertical blanking intervals, through TV-audio or video sub-carrier signals generated
by subliminal light impulses.
In all instances, however, hard copy records are generated and dispensed at
shoppers' remote locations.
According to the present invention,
scrambling devices may be provided as part of the response units at shoppers'
locations; such scrambling devices of known design are activated and controlled
by instructional signals transmitted from a central location. It is the function
of said scrambling devices to scramble in random fashion alphanumeric data transmitted,
so that when desired, the codes printed or otherwise provided on the hard copy
records of a multitude of shoppers randomly differ from each other. In that
manner, shoppers in a geographically limited area will receive tokens such as
coupons bearing dissimilar or non-identical alphanumeric or other codes. The
method of randomly rearranging or disturbing the order of numbers and other
symbols transmitted, permits the organizer or sponsor of a broadcast to limit
the distribution of prizes to a restricted and somewhat controlled number of
television viewers, thus limiting the financial exposure of such sponsor. When
broadcasting to a larger audience, the financial exposure of a sponsor can be
statistically determined within a narrow range by following the scrambling procedure
described.
The product list may be presented to shoppers at their remote locations by transmitting
instructional signals from a central location directing the printers of the
response units to print the names or numbers of a plurality of products on the
prize coupon generated and dispensed as described. The shopper having received
such a coupon displaying a listing of several products then indicates his or
her choice of product on the coupon in any convenient manner, such as by checking
off, circling, filling in a box, drawing a line, etc. The prize carried by such
a coupon is applicable to the earmarked product. Thus the coupon itself serves
as a product list limited to products from which a shopper can make a final
selection after having entered a sales outlet. Thus a winning TV-viewer can
take to a store a discount coupon applicable to a product selected by the shopper
at the checkout counter from a list of products. In this fashion, the sponsor
has the ability to limit the list of discount products and the shopper can make
the final selection.
According to a preferred method and configuration of the passive terminal, a
participant can program a memory in the terminal by entering the names or numbers
of one or more products targeted by the participant for early purchase. The
potential shopper can then leave the terminal unattended. When the sponsor of
a program includes a product so specified by a shopper among those earmarked
by the sponsor for discounts or other awards, an alarm in the terminal is activated
so as to alert the shopper to this fact. The shopper then has the opportunity
to participate in the game and to win a prize token, such as a coupon, carrying
a discount on the selected product targeted by the shopper for immediate purchase.
It is virtually certain that such a shopper will redeem the coupon thus obtained.
FIG. 28 shows steps of the method for the selection aspect of the invention.
Preparation of materials, including formatting of response and scoring criteria,
may be performed by the host at the central station, or prerecorded by the host
for transmission to remote stations from the central station, indicated at block
828. Program material including questions and product listings are televised
at block 830 to be received for viewing, at block 832, by a shopper, indicated
at block 834. A separate communication channel at block 836, such as a sideband
of an audio or video portion of the television transmission, provides instructions
such as response and scoring criteria, as well as product advertising information
in the form of electronic signals to be employed in the operation of a response
unit, indicated at block 838. The response unit includes a keypad for entering
an answer, memory for storing the various criteria and instructions plus advertising
or merchandising matters, computation equipment for evaluating answers, and
a printer for producing a hard copy record of the respondents performance.
The shopper selects an area of interest at block 840 at the response unit, and
then enters a response at block 842. Upon a successful responding, the respondent
shopper receives at block 844 a coupon from the response unit. The coupon provides
a discount for selected products, and may carry advertising. At block 846, the
shopper transmits the coupon to a redemption center by any one of a variety
of ways, such as, by mail or by telephone or in person. Then, at block 848,
the shopper redeems the coupon and receives an award such as a discount on the
purchase of a selected product.
The foregoing description shows the full versatility of the system and methodology
of the invention for allowing contestants at remote stations to participate
in a game, quiz or other form of show, contest, game of chance, or making predictions
of the outcomes of unknown or future events, whether the show be live, prerecorded,
or partially prerecorded and partially live.
FIG. 30 is a block diagram of a playing station of the system of FIG. 29; and
FIG. 31 is a flow chart showing method steps employed at various components
of the system of FIG. 29 for practicing the forgery proof wagering game.
FIGS. 29 and 30 are block diagrams showing a further embodiment of the invention
employing a central station and a set of remote stations, similar to those described
above, in a system 900 for the conduction of a wagering game in a forgery-proof
fashion. The system 900 includes components which are essentially the same as
components described above, and includes modifications for adapting the components
to the practice of wagering, as in a wagering game. The system 900 includes
the central station 202, described above in reference to FIG. 6, and playing
stations 206C similar to the remote stations 206B of FIG. 22. Each of the playing
stations 206C includes a response unit 800 and a receive system 558 described
above with reference to FIG. 26, and a TV system 220 described above with reference
to FIG. 6 and employing a screen 208 (FIG. 6) or screen 20 (FIG. 1) for presenting
data or a scenario to a person at the remote station. If desired, a scenario
or wagering situation may be presented to players via the telephone. Also included
in the system 900 are a telephone switchboard 622 and a response evaluation
unit 808 described above with reference to FIG. 22, and a central telephone
facility 702 and a subscriber's bank 708 described above with reference to FIG.
24. The system 900 further comprises a scoring computer 902, a data facility
904, a redemption facility 906 and an authorization unit 908. In a playing station
206C (FIG. 30) the response unit 800 is connected via lines 346 and 348 to the
TV system 220, as shown also in FIG. 6, and optionally via line 696 to a detector
652 at the screen 20, as shown also in FIG. 3. Message and control signals (FIG.
29) are coupled between the central station 202 and the switchboard 622 via
lines 638 and 640 as shown also in FIG. 22. Connection of a playing stations
206C (FIGS. 29 and 30) via modems 634 and via lines 636 to the switchboard 622
is shown also in FIG. 22. In FIG. 29 a communication system 910 provides for
a broadcast transmission, via a communication channel 912, between central and
remote stations, such as the broadcast transmission 222 of FIGS. 6 and 22, or
the separate broadcast transmissions by radio and television links of FIGS.
1 and 3. The communication system 910 also provides for communication via the
telephone switchboard 622 and telephone lines 636, such as the telephonic communication
of FIG. 22.
In the practice of wagering by the invention, a player at a playing station
206C is informed about the nature of the wagering situation as a first step
in the usual practice of the invention. The information provided to the player
may be only rudimentary, such as a time when wagering may be performed, and
a situation wherein a game such as lotto is to be played by choosing one or
more numbers. Alternatively, the information provided to a player may be complex
such as a situation involving a game show, as has been described above with
reference to FIG. 6, wherein at some point in the show, the players at the remote
playing stations 206C may be asked to bet on an outcome of the show or some
other event. The communication channel 912 is intended to represent various
ways in which data can be disseminated to the players at the stations 206C such
as by television and/or radio, a radio being indicated at 914 in FIG. 30. It
is understood that the communication system 910 includes transmission of the
requisite data by various means, in addition to the foregoing broadcast transmission
of television and radio, such as by means of a previously recorded audio message
employing a recorder 916, in accordance with the practice described above with
reference to FIG. 11. Data may be provided even by means of a printed medium
918 such as a newsletter. And, as will be explained below, the communication
system 910 includes transmission of the requisite data also by means of a telephone
620.
Additionally, a video cassette recorder (VCR) 920 may be selectively coupled
via a first branch of a switch 922 to the TV system 220, in lieu of connection
of the TV system 220 to the antenna 282 for receipt of the broadcast transmission
222. Connection of the TV system 220 to the VCR 920 provides data in the manner
described above with reference to FIGS. 11 and 12. A second branch of the switch
922 selectively provides for connection of the response unit 800 to the antenna
36 (shown also in FIG. 1) via the receiver 40 and the demodulator 42, or to
a receiving system 558 for reception of data via the telephone line 636 as described
above in reference to FIG. 22. Data may also be inputted to a player via a telephone
620 connected to the telephone line 636 as described in FIG. 22. The various
ways in which data can be inputted to a player at a playing station 206C are
represented collectively in FIG. 30 as a data input unit. In the practice of
the invention, a record outputted by the dispenser 360 of the response unit
800 may be in the form of a card 362 which is conveniently carried by a player
to the redemption facility 906 for receipt of a prize for a winning wager. The
carrying of the card 362 to the redemption facility 906 is represented by a
dashed line 924. A communication link 926 connects the redemption facility 906
with the data facility 904. A communication link 928 connects the central station
202 with the data facility 904.
With reference to FIGS. 29-31, the operation of the system 900 begins with the
preparation of data, at block 930 (FIG. 31), to be presented to a player at
a playing station 206C, via block 932, and to be inputted to the response unit
800 at the playing station 206C via block 934. In FIG. 31, the method steps
are presented in solid blocks while the locations in the system 900 (FIG. 29)
for the performance of the steps are shown by dashed lines enclosing the solid
blocks. Typically, the input data is prepared at the central station 202, but
may also be prepared at some other location. By way of example, a wagering situation
may be based on the outcome of a horse race, as in off-track betting, wherein
the identity of the horses varies from race to race. In this case, a host at
the central station 202 presents the players with the various combinations of
winning situations (to win, to place, to show) and possibly handicaps prior
to each race. A televised presentation of a sequence of races may be broadcast
directly from the central station to the remote playing stations in the form
of a live broadcast or in the form of a prerecorded broadcast, or may be broadcast
from some other site distant from the central station but concurrently with
the presentation of the host at the central station. Announcers may also present
a situation via radio or telephone.
Thus, for example, the program signal transmitted via the communication channel
912 may include a listing of the horses' names and identification numbers while
an instructional signal transmitted via the channel 912 would include the odds
for each horse and the horse identification numbers plus scoring criteria for
categories of win, show and place. If, instead of a horse race, the wagering
is based on a televised game show, such as has been described hereinabove, the
program and the instructional signals would include the data and instructions
as described above, and would include also data and instructions relating to
the wagering. For example, studio contestants may be playing a game of geography,
and players at the remote stations may be attempting to guess the answers before
the studio contestants. Wagers can be placed on the answers. For example, a
question may be posed as to which countries border on the Black Sea, and players
would enter the names of countries via the keyboard 356 along with wagers that
the countries entered are the correct answers to the questions. Prizes can be
gradated commensurate with knowledge presented. In a similar fashion, the studio
program might involve mathematical calculations which would be performed by
the players at the remote stations, multiple choice answers would be provided
on the television screen 208 at each playing station, and the players would
bet on the right answer. In this case, the outcome of the wagering would depend
on the players, skills as well as on luck. In the simplest situation, it is
possible to practice the invention without a transmission of data and instructions
from the central station 202, as in the case of a game of lotto wherein each
player chooses six numbers out of a set of one hundred numbers. In this case,
data of the event including the time and rules could be published in a newsletter,
and instructions for operation of the computer 804 could be provided in a magnetic
medium of the memory 806 (FIG. 26).
As has been described above with reference to FIGS. 4, 8 and 26, the response
unit, in its various embodiments, outputs a record such as the card 362 providing
data as to a player's response. The outputting of the record is indicated at
block 936. The record may include a player's score and identification (I.D.),
as well as the serial number of a response unit and other data. In similar fashion,
the response unit 800 employed in the conduct of wagering in FIGS. 29-31 also
outputs a record such as the card 362 by means of the dispenser 360 to provide
information as to a player's wagering. In particular, the number or set of numbers
selected by a player, as in a lotto game, the identity of a winning racer, as
in the case of a horse race or ski race or boat race, by way of example, or
selected elements of a game show which may include an article of clothing or
a geographical place or the author of a book, by way of example, is imprinted
on the card 362. For ease of describing the invention, the outputted record
may be described as the card 362, it being understood that the outputted record
may have the form of a tape, coupon, entry ticket or other of various forms
as have been described above. The card 362 is conveniently carried by a player
to the redemption facility 906 to obtain a prize.
In accordance with a feature of the invention, protection against a forgery
of the card 362 is provided. This is accomplished as follows. In addition to
the recording of a player's response and identification on the card 362, the
response data is recorded automatically also in a storage unit 940 of the data
facility 904 via block 938. The storage unit 940 is inaccessible to players
and all other persons except for authorized personnel conducting the lottery
or other form of wagering. Communication of the wagering data from the playing
stations 206C is accomplished via the communication system 910, particularly
via the telephone lines 636 and the switchboard 622 to the data facility 904.
Later upon redemption of the card 362 at the redemption facility 906, the invention
provides for the process steps of authenticating the record, at block 942, and
only after a successful authentication, redeeming the card or coupon at block
944. In the process of authentication, the redemption facility 906 communicates
via the communication link 926 to the data facility 904 to interrogate the storage
unit 940 to attain the copy of the record, this being followed by a comparing
or the data on the record copy of the data facility 904 with the record on the
card 362. Any alteration of data on the card 362 will cause a disparity between
the two records of data resulting in a rejection of the card 362. Thereby, the
system and methodology of the invention are rendered forgery proof.
In a typical wagering situation, the entering of data by a player (block 932)
into the response unit 800 is accomplished within a preset amount of time allocated
for the response, after which the response unit 800 refuses further entries
in accordance with commands of the instructional signal as described hereinabove
with reference to FIGS. 4, 8 and 26. Alternatively, or additionally, following
an announced point in time, command signals may be transmitted from the central
station 202 directing the switchboard 622 to terminate transmission of further
entries to the storage unit 940. Thereafter, in accordance with the process
of the invention, a host at the central station 202 announces the winning entity
such as the winning number or set of numbers of a lotto game or the answers
to a game of geography or other form of game, at block 946, and broadcasts the
winning entity to players at the remote playing stations 206C via the communication
system 910. Additionally, the winning entity is communicated to the response
units 800 at the playing stations 206C via the communication system 910, and
to the data facility 904 via the communication link 928 for storage in the storage
unit 940. Communication of the winning entity to the response unit 800 is indicated
at block 934 (FIG. 31), and communication of the winning entity to the data
facility 904 is indicated at block 938.
The winning entity includes a reference element against which a player's response
can be compared to determined the correctness of the response. The reference
element is established, typically, by the host at the central station 202 at
block 948 for transmission to the evaluation unit 808. For example, in the case
of a lotto game wherein a player is to select six numbers from a set of one
hundred numbers, the reference element would comprise the six numbers to enable
the evaluation unit 808 to compare a player's response to the six numbers. In
the case of a race, the reference elements of participating racers can be one,
two, three and so forth. Alternatively, if the wagering game required a player's
response to fall within a range of values, such as in a case wherein a player
is to guess the average summer temperature in Alaska, then the reference element
would provide the average temperature and the requisite range of values to enable
the evaluation unit 808 to compare a player's response with the designated average
value, and also to determine if the player's response falls within the range.
Utilization of the evaluation unit 808 is accomplished by continuing the inventive
process at block 950 wherein each player's response is compared to the reference
element. Each player's response and the reference element are coupled, respectively,
from the data facility 904 and from the central station 202 to the evaluation
unit 808, and the result of the comparison is fed from the evaluation unit 808
back to the data facility 904 for storage in the storage unit 940.
The invention provides for still further evaluation of a player's response in
the form of a scoring of the response at block 952 by use of the scoring computer
90 in accordance with instructions from the central station 202 provided at
block 954. Data for the scoring computer 902 is provided by the data facility
904. This additional evaluation is useful in the foregoing example in which
a player wagers on the value of the average summer temperature in Alaska. The
instructions at block 954 may provide for a highest score to a player who selects
the correct value of the temperature, and lower nonzero scores to all players
who have selected temperatures falling within the designated range. Additional
score points may be awarded, by way of example, for player responses closer
to the correct value than an average deviation of selected values from the correct
value. Thus, the scoring computer 902, in this example, would compute the average
deviation of selected values from the correct value, in the process of scoring
the responses. In the case of a race, such as a horse race or a sailing race,
the scoring computer 902 would evaluate the odds based on the responses of all
the players, and then employ the odds in computing each player's score.
With respect to the magnitude of a wager entered by a player, the magnitude
may be expressed as a dollar amount or an amount of points, or an amount of
gifts to be presented by an advertiser, by way of example. The scoring computer
902 also multiplies the amounts wagered by the players' scores to obtain the
total prize or award due each player. In the event that the amount of prizes
to be awarded is based also on the total amount wagered, as in the case of a
purse at a horse race, then the scoring computer 902 also calculates the total
amount wagered for computing the amount of each prize. Suitable programs for
operating the computer 902 to accomplish these calculations are well known,
and need not be described herein. The resulting scores and magnitudes of prizes
are stored in the data facility 904, and are also transmitted to the central
station 202 for subsequent transmission to the response units 800 at the playing
stations 206C. At each of the playing stations 206C, the dispenser 360 of the
response unit 800 imprints upon the card 362 data as to the amount of the prize.
The card 362 is now ready for presentation at the redemption facility 906, and
the data facility 904 has a copy of the data on the card 362 to permit the authentication
step to proceed prior to redemption of the card 362. Thereby, the invention
has accomplished a two-fold goal of being adaptive to a large variety of wagering
situations, and of providing a forgery-proof process for redemption of the cards
362.
The features of the invention, as provided by the system 900, are readily implemented
in a fashion convenient for people at home, as well as other locations, as may
be appreciated from the ensuing discussion of the operation and the advantages
of the invention. The invention is applicable to the conducting of a large variety
of games of chance including lotteries wherein players can participate in their
homes and obtain entry tickets, such as in the form of the card 362, by way
of example, directly in their homes. Furthermore, the players can pay for their
wagers without leaving their homes, so that players who do not win do not have
to leave their homes, and players who do win need make only one trip to a local
lottery agent at the redemption facility 906 to collect their winnings.
FIG. 29 shows the use of the central telephone facility 702 in conjunction with
the switchboard 622 to provide a convenient method of paying for one's wagers
without leaving the home. By means of prior arrangement with the telephone facility
702, a player at any one of the playing stations 260 is provided with a personal
identification number (PIN) which is readily entered via pushbuttons on a telephone
to identify the player to the telephone company. The PIN number securely identifies
the player to permit a monetary charge to be placed against his account in the
same fashion as a charge is placed for a long-distance telephone call. The PIN
number and the amount of money being wagered can be applied via the keyboard
356 and the modem 634 to be received by the telephone facility 702 in the same
fashion as can be accomplished the the use of pushbuttons on a telephone, but
at a much greater convenience than by use of the telephone. The keyboard 356
in conjunction with the computer 804 and the modem 634 enable a player to attain
connection with the data facility 904 in much the same fashion as a computer
terminal may be employed in the home to interrogate a computer service, such
as a service providing legal, medical, travel, financial, or other materials
as are currently available. By means of the authorization unit 908 which checks
the PIN number, the telephone facility 702 ascertains that the player is a bonafide
approved user of the telephone system.
The amount of money wagered is billed automatically by the telephone facility
702 to the bank 708 of the player, or telephone subscriber. To facilitate this
billing function, the computer 804 may tally the amount of all wagers being
entered by a player in response to a game show or other wagering situation presented
by the central station 202 and then, upon completion of a succession of wagers,
present via the modem 634 the total value of the wagers to be deducted from
the players account in the bank 708. If desired, an indication of payment by
the player may be transmitted by the telephone facility 702 to the data facility
904 to ensure that there is no consideration of a player's wager until after
payment has been made. The process of billing the player, or telephone subscriber,
is similar to that described above with reference to FIG. 24. Alternatively,
the billing may be performed by a separate entity (not shown), such as by a
service provider connected via telephone lines to the switchboard 622.
It is an advantage of the present invention that the identity of winning players
and the amount won can be announced on television or radio immediately following
the drawing of a winning number. The convenience of use of the inventive wagering
system contrasts greatly with wagering processes presently available to the
general public. At the present time, individuals who wish to participate in
a lottery must visit the location of a local lottery agent or retailer to purchase
a lottery ticket. Thereafter, a second trip is necessary to collect the winnings
at the agent's location. The identities of winners often are not publicly announced
immediately following the drawing, and sometimes are delayed for one or more
days. Normally, no televised entertainment value is attached to a lottery. These
and other drawbacks are overcome by the present invention.
The response unit 800 is registered in the name of an owner, such as a TV viewer
who may elect to become a player in a wagering game. The hard-copy records dispensed
by the response unit 800 can bear identification data tracing the hard-copy
record back to the specific response unit. The user's name may even be printed
on each ticket. The hard-copy record, described above as the card 362, may serve
as a coupon, ticket, or proof-of-entry ticket for participation in a lottery
or other wagering situation. Furthermore, as noted above, the card may also
serve as a winning ticket by which a player redeems his prize at the redemption
facility 906.
The card 362 may be provided with validation data and coded markings, as has
been described above, for additional security to be used in conjunction with
the forgery-proof benefit provided by the placing of a copy of the card data
in the data facility 904 in a secure fashion which is inaccessible to all persons
other than personnel operating the data facility 904.
If desired, a player may select his or her own lottery number, and to compare
a selected number with a winning number printed on the hard-copy record without
delay, to enable the player to determine whether a prize has been won. A ticket
or card 362 may be printed with alphanumeric characters which are readable by
the player, and/or by means of bar coding which is to be read by machine for
increased accuracy and security in the ticket redemption process. Furthermore,
by printing both the winning number or entry along with the player's entry on
the ticket prior to the drawing, a player is able readily to compare his entry
with a winning entry. In terms of construction of the system 900, the data facility
904 may be located distant from the central station, or may be located on site
with the central station 202. Also, the scoring computer 902 and the evaluation
unit 808 may be located at sites distant from both the central station 202 and
the data facility 904 or, alternatively, either one or both of the computer
902 and the evaluation unit 808 may be located at the central station 202 or
the data facility 904. Furthermore, while the playing stations 206C are located
normally at considerable distance from the central station 202, such as in a
different city, it is within the inventive concept to locate one or more of
the playing stations 206C relatively close to the central station 202 as is
done in the situation of a studio audience participating in a contest, or in
the aircraft shown in FIG. 11. Also, by virtue of communication between the
data facility 904 and the central telephone facility 702, different credit limits
can be set for different lotteries such that the storage unit 940 is provided
with credit limit data prior to the conducting of a lottery or other wagering
situation. A wager which exceeds the credit limit is rejected by the data facility
904, and the telephone facility 702 is directed to credit the subscriber's account
in the bank 708.
If desired, the data facility 904 may store additional data of players who have
registered to play a wagering game. For example, photographs of individual ones
of the players may be stored digitally in the storage unit 940 for subsequent
transmission to the central station 202 followed by a television transmission,
to the playing stations 206C to allow all members of the viewing audience to
see a picture of a winning person. If desired, the televising of a person's
previously stored picture may be employed for participation from a remote station
in a game show even without the placing of a bet on an outcome of a game show.
The game show and the lottery may be, but do not have to be, televised from
the same central location.
To ensure additional protection against forgery various identification numbers
or other indicia may be imprinted in coded format, or in an invisible format
such as by use of magnetic media, or holographic optical recording media, with
a copy of the identifying data being stored at the data facility 904. A ticket
presented for redemption must have the requisite identifying data.
In the playing of a lottery game, the player has the option of selecting a winning
number or, alternatively, allowing the computer 804 of the response unit 800
to pick a number for the player. This may be accomplished by providing a random
number generation program for the computer 804, such programs being well known.
Thereupon, the computer 804 is able to select in random fashion one or more
numbers from a set of numbers used in the lottery.
The capacity of the system of the invention to create and to dispense wagering
tickets with security against cheating is an important object of the invention
because this allows players to operate their response units, including the printers,
in their homes without danger of someone tampering with a printer to forge a
winning ticket. The validating data imprinted on a ticket and the comparison
of data with previously stored data in the central data facility enable a foolproof
verification of the ticket. By virtue of the invention, the printer cannot be
used as a forgery tool. Also, the system meets the objective of providing convenience
to players by allowing persons to participate on the spur of the moment in a
lottery game or other predictive contest while being debited automatically without
leaving their home. The conduction of wagering in conjunction with a task, contest
or game of skill rewarded with a prize adds significant entertainment value
and possibly instructional value to the wagering experience. Game of lotto and
bingo can be accomplished with particular facility by the invention, and the
capacity for immediate announcement of winners on television enhances excitement
among the participants.
The systems and the methods of the invention apply to events or games, by chance,
such as lotteries, and to events or games covered by knowledge, skill or ability,
such as quizzes, tournaments, bouts, contests, and races by humans, machines
and animals. It should be understood that a prediction may pertain, for example,
to an event of the past, but not known or no longer remembered by a player,
so as to constitute a de facto prediction from that player's perspective. An
operator or judge of a game of chance or skill determines the rules or conditions
that are to be met to qualify for a prize. For example, in a form of betting
known as "off track" betting on a horse race, there are odds governing payoffs
to winners. The odds are determined at a central location and are reflected
in the winning wager information transmitted from the central location to the
remote playing stations for imprinting on the players' tickets.
In the practice of the invention for wagering, the terms "operator" or "organizer"
of a game of chance or skill are intended to include all individuals in charge
of such gaming activities or in any kind of decision-making capacity, including
judges, referees, handicappers, umpires, racing committees and other officials.
The terms "forgery-resisting" and "tamper-proof" are intended to include prevention
and alteration, as well as the preventing of tampering with an object of the
forgery, typically a lottery ticket, and also includes making inaccessible and
preventing electronic access to the object of forgery. The terms "fee" or "charge"
are intended to include the meaning of debit, cost, or price charged to participants
in a wagering situation. The terms "wagering", "betting" or "gaming" are intended
to include the meaning of players' predictions of, or bets and wagers on, the
total, final, midstream, or partial outcome of a game of skill, such as a golf
tournament, and includes also the wager amount. The term "ticket" is intended
to include the meaning of vouchers, coupons, certificates and other hard copy
records.
The term "presentation" of a wagering situation or scenario is intended to include
a presentation over TV, radio, and/or the telephone. The term "authentication"
is intended to include processes of validation, verification, confirmation and
acceptance of a winning ticket. The term "matching" as in "matching numbers"
is intended to include any predetermined relationship between a player's entered
data and the determined reference element, and between selected and winning
numbers, such as a mathematical, partial, or zero relationship. The term "forgery-resistant
data storage facility" is intended to include any facility in which stored data
are protected against tampering, are inaccessible, or beyond the reach or influence
of would-be forgers. If a wager is offered by an operator and such wager carries
only a single type of fixed award, for example, or if only one wager amount
is offered, then the term "wager amount determined by a player" is intended
to include the acceptance of such fixed wager.
The term "game show" is intended to include the meaning of one or more questions,
quizzes, predictions and solicitations to perform a task. The term "response"
is intended to include the meaning of an answer and of a prediction. The term
"scenario" is intended to include the meaning of a presentation, definition,
view or description of an event or a situation. The term "entered wager" pertains
to data entered by a player prior to the determination of the data constituting
a winning wager. The term "winning wager" pertains to an entered wager having
a determined correlation to a reference element. The term "reference element"
pertains to data, such as a number, by which an entered wager is judged in order
to determine whether the entered wager is a winning wager. The term "reference
element" is intended to include measurements and expressions of evaluation,
such as points scored, time consumed, judged performance, achieved ratings and
standings of participants and players/contestants.
In a preferred embodiment of the invention, the operators of a game of chance
decide on a formula by which prizes may be won by players whose selected indicia
do not completely match a winning indicia. Rewards may be granted to players
whose selected number or indicia come closest to the winning indicia. Players
may enter selected indicia up to a cutoff point in time determined by a game
operator; also, means may be provided for modifying a selected wager prior to
the cutoff point. By way of example, if a winning indicia is the number 100
and the prize is $50,000 for a completely matching number, the following formula
may be determined and applied in the event that none of the players has selected
the number 100. Players having selected number 101 or 99 divide $30,000 among
them, and players having selected numbers 102 or 98 divide $20,000 among them.
Other schemes may be employed.
As has been described above, a number or indicium may be selected by a player
or may be established by random selection. The number assigned to a player is
communicated to the central data storage facility prior to a drawing of the
winning number.
By way of further example in the use of the invention, a question may be posed
in a TV show, the question asking the years in which World War I began and ended.
A time limit for answering and a prize also are announced. A winning player
would enter the years 1914-1918 in the response unit. The response unit prints
out a ticket stating the players' entered information and identification. The
response unit also transmits the same information via a modem and a telephone
line to the central data storage facility.
When or after the host of the TV-show has announced the correct answer on the
air, the signals conveying the correct answer and prize information are transmitted
from the location of the TV-show to players' remote response units. The response
units print the winning information on all players, tickets for comparison purposes.
Winning tickets on which a player's entered information matches the winning
information may be presented by the ticket holders at an appropriate location
for redemption or playoff. As described above, the agent at the location can
verify the authenticity of the ticket by communicating with the data storage
facility and obtaining confirmation. In the case of a ticket formed as a magnetic
card, the magnetic card can be validated by passing it through a well-known
scanner connected to the data storage facility, the scanner reading the data
recorded on the card for transmission to the data facility whereupon the data
facility transmits back a signal acknowledging verification or denying verification.
In some instances, the conditions under which a lottery is conducted are similar
in many respects to those of sweepstakes and other games. The present invention
therefore is intended to be applicable to any game, contest or wagering based
on knowledge, skill, or chance, in which it is important to prevent tampering
with or forging of hard copy records by interested parties. While it may not
be necessary to employ all the safeguards described herein in connection with
every wager, the operator of the wager game has the option of employing the
security measures disclosed herein. For example, in the case of wagering situations
for which prizes of high value may be awarded, there may be further storage
of a player's data indicia, number or symbols in an accessible location to facilitate
secure redemption of a ticket. In the event that a player's betting exceeds
acceptable monetary limits, the automatic billing via the telephone system,
as disclosed hereinabove, may limit the amount of betting and disclose to the
central data facility and to the response unit a rejection or limitation of
bets exceeding a previously established limit. When required, players are notified
and are asked to communicate their wager information to a designated location
for storage and comparison purposes. Such a notice to players makes it clear
that tampering with a player's home response unit is useless. Thus, players
are dissuaded from attempting forgery or other form of falsification.
Security is enhanced further by providing the response unit with a registration
or serial number by which each response unit is registered in the name of its
owner. Hard-copy records dispensed by the response unit may bear the same serial
number, if desired, to enable tracing of a hard-copy record to the specific
response unit which generated the record. This security is in addition to that
provided by the PIN number described above by which a player gains access to
the telephone system. Normally, in a wagering situation, a time limit is established
electronically for the entering of wagers at the keyboard of each response unit
such that a late entry, made after the time limit becomes effective, are not
stored at the central data facility, and are not printed on the player's ticket,
this precluding the player from winning a prize for a late entry of wager.
In the printing and dispensing of hard-copy records by a response unit, it is
noted that the records may have a variety of forms which facilitate different
manners of utilizing the hard-copy record. For example, in the event that a
ticket is employed wherein the winning number and a player's entry are printed,
the player has the opportunity to check as to whether he has won, or to the
extent in which he has won in the event that various levels of winning are present.
In the event that a magnetic card is employed as the hard-copy record, the card
can be utilized in connection with automatic electronic debiting of a player
by the amount of the wager, and with an automatic electronic crediting of winnings
to a player's account. Equipment, such as automatic banking machines employing
card readers, are already available for cooperation with the inventive system
for providing these functions of crediting and debiting. Bar codes and bar code
readers may also be employed in which case the bar code is imprinted on a ticket
along with data imprinted with alphanumeric characters to be readable by a player.
As has been described above in the operation of a response unit, the invention
enables participants in the remote audience to designate areas of interest.
This is particularly important with respect to an award received by individual
ones of the participants, such that the award is related directly to a participant's
area of interest. Thus, in the case of a game show wherein advertisers' products
are displayed in various areas of interest, a participant of the remote audience
can select a product area of interest and, subsequently, receive an award in
the form of a coupon allowing him to purchase a product in the area of interest.
This greatly increases a participant's interest in the game show. This feature
also increases greatly the chance that a participant will employ his coupon,
as by visiting the store of an advertiser to redeem the coupon. Also, in a quiz
program, a contestant is given the opportunity to select an area of interest
from alternative areas of interest in which the contestant is believed to have
a special knowledge area. Prize coupons may be available to winning contestants
entitling the player to a discount on merchandise promoted by a sponsor. However,
in the event of a discount coupon issued for a product that is not in demand,
the unwanted product, most likely, would not be redeemed. However, unlike merchandising
systems of the past where coupons have been issued in areas of little interest
with consequential low rates of redemption, in the case of the present invention
a high rate of redemption is anticipated because of the capability afforded
to participants to select areas of interest, both with respect to manufacturers'
or retailers' products as well of areas of interest in terms of a participants'
knowledge.
In view of the use of the telephone system for communication of data between
a response unit and the central data facility, it is possible also to employ
the telephone system to substitute for communication via the television and/or
radio in areas wherein television and/or radio reception are not available to
a participant. Thus, by way of example, the progress of a contest can be reported
via telephone to a participant. Also, if desired, such progress can be reported
by a telephone to supplement data received via television and/or radio broadcast.
If desired, the central data facility or the telephone system may store financial
information regarding individuals who are subscribers to a wagering service
provided by the invention. The financial information may be updated periodically
or when desirable, for instance each time a subscriber pays a bill or commits
a sum to a wager. This enables the telephone or other service facility to check
the financial standing or credit status of each player in the context of the
wager a player wishes to make.
In accordance with a further aspect of the invention, it is noted that the concept
of playing a game by responding to stimuli, such as a scenario presented by
television, by radio or by telephonic communication, can be extended over a
period of days, weeks, or even months. Scenarios may be authorized such as in
the case of dramatic or prearranged scenarios. Over such an extended interval
of time, a respondent might make entries via the keyboard of the response unit
22 (FIG. 4), 210 (FIG. 8) or 800 (FIG. 26), or update entries during participation
in a game, a contest, an educational process, a process for shopping for merchandise,
or other extended field of endeavor. An extended playing or responding interval
can be illustrated readily with respect to a shopping for items that may be
offered on sale or at a discount at some future time. The basic procedural steps
follow those which have been described above for the conduction of an educational
game. There follows an example by use of the system 200 of FIG. 6 with the response
unit 800 of FIG. 26.
The extended shopping interval proceeds as follows. A list of items obtainable
by purchase at a local market is set forth in a listing contained, by way of
example, in a newspaper, in a mailing to householders, or on the television
screen 208 along with identifying numbers which are provided also to the memory
of the response unit via the instructional signal. The listing may comprise
all of the products obtainable from a manufacturer or from a retailer, even
if only some or none of the products are on sale or discounted at the time of
the listing.
The respondent employs the keyboard to enter into a memory of the response unit
the identifying numbers of those items for which there is an interest in a future
purchase at a sale or discounted price. From time to time over the ensuing days,
weeks, or even months, the instructional signal transmits to the response unit
an updated listing of the items of merchandise including data of items put on
sale or on discount by the manufacturer or retailer. This effectively flags
those items which are on sale or available at discount. The computer 804 (or
a comparator 372 or 374 in the case of use of the response unit 210 of FIG.
8) compares the respondent's entries with the flagged items, and then indicates
a match by a suitable indication such as by sounding the bell, and by leaving
a message on the display 358 of the response unit. The respondent, by command
entered at the keyboard, directs the printer to list the sale or discounted
items. Alternatively, respondent enters on the keyboard items desired for purchase
and, upon such items being put on sale, the printer of the respondent's response
unit prints out coupons conveying a discount on the items without additional
commands by respondent. Such discount coupons may be printed even during an
absence of the respondent, and will be waiting for the respondent upon his or
her return.
Furthermore, with respect to the wagering aspect of the invention, the respondent,
or player, can wager on which item or items may go on sale or be discounted.
The selected items serve as the subject of a bet in the same fashion as presented
in the foregoing description of the wagering.
The foregoing description has demonstrated that the various configurations of
central station and remote station can be employed additionally in the conduction
of a wagering situation, either by itself as in a game of lotto, or in conjunction
with an educational program, a sporting event, or a program directed specifically
to products of interest to an advertiser, by way of example.
The methods of the invention will now be described in connection with FIGS.
32 and 33, depicting method steps and FIG. 34 illustrating a mailing piece used
in collecting household data.
FIG. 32 is a diagram of the initial steps in practicing the present method following
exposure of a shopper 1003 to an advertisement 1001 which generates a visual
and/or audio stimulus 1002. The stimulus has an immediate impact as well as
a lasting effect on shopper 1003. It is an object of the present method to quantify
the degree of erosion of the effectiveness of a stimulus over a short period
of say two days, or a longer period of, say seven days.
Stimulus 1001 can take any form, including TV and radio commercials, print media
advertisements and others.
The advertisement 1001 is identifiable by a reference element, such as a number,
or by the date and time it is displayed and noticed by the individual 1003.
One or more products may be promoted and identified in advertisement 1001.
Advertisement 1001 also may promote a service, an organization, a resort, or
any offering to the public herein collectively referred to as product. The individual
1003 who is persuaded by the said stimulus to become a buyer, lessee, etc. of
the promoted product, registers his or her intent to acquire the product identified
in the advertisement 1001 in step 1004, which is an entering in the coupon dispenser
or response unit 1005 of a request for a record 1008 described in FIG. 33. The
entering step 1004 includes an identification of the stimulus of advertisement
1001. Thus, both the product intended for purchase and the advertisement which
prompted the buying decision are identified and can in turn be identified on
the record dispensed by the dispenser or response unit 1005. Response unit 1005,
is described in connection with FIGS. 1, 3-6, 8 and 26 and can include a clock
directing the printer of the individual coupons and the cumulative record 1018
of FIG. 33 to print the time of a shopper's request on both types of records.
The term "stimulus" as used herein is intended to include the meanings of any
presentation designed to bring about an act on the part of a person exposed
to a stimulus, including TV and radio commercials, telephone promotion or telemarketing,
print advertisements, direct mailings, free-standing inserts, indoor and outdoor
advertising, direct mail coupons, billboards, posters, electronic displays and
the like. Thus, a stimulus can be a theater or sports program listing an event
and the cost of an admission ticket. Such an announcement can indicate the discounts
available to persons exposed to and acting upon said stimulus,
The terms "tabulating, analyzing, measuring, massaging, comparing, processing
and quantifying" are used interchangeably, except where specifically described
or limited.
The term "shoppers' locations or "individuals' locations" are intended to include
locations remote from a central transmitting station, such as homes, offices,
clubs, restaurants, etc., such locations being provided with a response or dispensing
unit.
The use of a noun is intended to include when applicable, the singular or the
plural of the noun. The term "product" is intended to include services, such
as those pertaining to credit cards, insurance, home improvements, transportation,
etc. The terms quantifying, analyzing, evaluating, tabulating and processing
shoppers' records are, when appropriate, used interchangeably.
The term advertiser is intended to include the meanings of marketer, seller,
lessor, promoter, retailer, discounter and organizer of a contest, poll, vote
or campaign.
The purpose of exposing individuals to a stimulus is to prompt, cause or induce
such individuals to perform an act desired by the promoter, such as the act
of purchasing, renting, leasing, selling, voting, responding to surveys and
polls, selecting, identifying, responding or expressing an opinion, both direct
and implied.
In FIG. 33, the response unit 1005 prints a record 1008, such as a discount
coupon requested by a shopper in a printing step 1006, which may be combined
with printing step 1007 of a cumulative printout or record 1018. Record 1008
specifies the selected product and the purchase incentive, i.e. the discount
or other value available to a shopper upon purchase of the product. Record 1008
also identifies the shopper and the stimulus that prompted the purchase decision.
The identification of the stimulus can, but does not have to be, a condition
to be met by a shopper to qualify for the benefit. Alternatively, a shopper
identifying the advertisement through appropriate entry on the response unit,
can qualify for a larger benefit than one who has not identified the stimulus.
The coupon is taken by the shopper to a retail store to step 1010. Between the
moment the shopper enters the store and the actual purchase of the targeted
product, the shopper is exposed to step 1011 to the influence of competitive
in-store promotion and point-of-purchase advertising. Shopper's purchase decision
1012 reflects all conflicting influences and results in a purchase decision
1013 in favor of the originally selected product, or in purchase decision 1014
in favor of a competitive product, or in the abandoning of the purchase 1021.
Following decision 1013, the shopper purchases the selected product and presents
the record for redemption in step 1015. Shopper's records are collected by the
seller in step 1016 and are available for tabulation or other analysis in step
1017. Because all coupons associate the purchased product with the individual
shopper and the stimulus which prompted the product selection, the tabulation
of a shopper's redeemed coupons creates over time a completely accurate picture
of that shopper's buying behavior.
According to the present invention, the response unit or dispenser 1005 includes
known means for printing on a paper tape or other matrix a composite record
of products for which individual coupons have been dispensed. In a preferred
embodiment, the printer of the dispenser creates a duplicate imprint of the
information printed on the coupon on the matrix of the cumulative record 1018,
which also identifies the response unit user or dispenser 1005.
Shoppers replace the matrices of records 1018 periodically as needed, preferably
when replenishing the tape forming the matrix for individual coupons 1008. The
cumulative records 1018 also can take the form of a mailing piece described
in connection with FIG. 34. Normally, records 1018 are collected by the same
organization performing record tabulation 1017. However, because records 1018
list all products selected and the associated stimuli, the records 1018 represent
a valuable data base in the sense of portraying a family's shopping intent.
In a related sense, a shopper's buying interest, even if not ultimately implemented,
makes such a shopper a prime target for a follow-up promotion, such as direct
mailing.
Additional valuable conclusions may be drawn by a comparison and analysis of
records 1018 and records 1017. By simply deducting in step 1019 the products
of records 1017 actually purchased from the products of record 1018, the net
loss of sales 1020 following the time of requesting a coupon (and the assumed
decision and intention of buying the product), can be determined.
Such net loss will be due to a decision not to buy any product of the kind specified
on coupon 1017, or a decision to buy a competitive product; the latter being
the much more likely reason.
The use of the methods of the invention relative to the quantitative analysis
of some variables in the fields of advertising and promotions will now be discussed.
The variables cited are intended to be illustrative of different types of measurements
that can be performed; others can be added by persons skilled in the art. Variations
in results by virtue of modified, controlled conditions are statistically evaluated
in the following examples The resulting records 1017 and/or 1018 are analyzed
in each instance.
EXAMPLE 1
A product commercial is shown once in prime time on a single TV-station in the
area served by said station and is not repeated for one week. The cut-off period
for the redemption of discount coupons is fixed at one week. In a modified example,
different commercials for the same product are shown and their results are compared
and evalued.
EXAMPLE 2
The circumstances of Example 1 are replicated, except that the TV-commercial
is shown twice or more frequently in prime time.
EXAMPLE 3
Examples 1 and 2 are replicated except, that some or all commercials are shown
at different times of the day.
EXAMPLE 4
Examples 1 and 2 are replicated, except that a radio commercial is added under
otherwise identical circumstances.
EXAMPLE 5
Examples 1-4 are replicated, except that the discount rate of the coupons is
varied.
EXAMPLE 6
Examples 1-5 are replicated except that the cut-off period for redemption of
coupons is varied.
EXAMPLE 7
Examples 1-6 are replicated for products in various price ranges.
EXAMPLE 8
Examples 1-7 are replicated and coupon redemption is limited to specified stores.
EXAMPLE 9
Examples 1-8 are replicated at different times of the year.
EXAMPLE 10
Examples 1-9 are replicated, except that some or all commercials are replaced
or supplemented by print advertisements.
EXAMPLE 11
Examples 1-9 are replicated. The product commercial promotes two or more different
products and the effectiveness of a commercial relative to different products
is evaluated.
EXAMPLE 12
Examples 1-11 are replicated, except that identical stimuli (e.g. broadcast
commercials or print advertisements) are presented by two or more sources (e.g.
broadcast stations or newspapers) which overlap in the territories they cover.
The relative effectiveness of individual sources is evaluated.
The present method has other important applications in the field of statistical
analysis, one being the effect of different stimuli on groups of persons having
the same characteristics and the other being the effect of an unchanged stimulus
on different groups of persons.
By measuring the impact of controlled variables of stimuli on an unchanged population
sample, the effectiveness and the change in effectiveness of different or modified
stimuli can be quantified.
Conversely, by measuring the impact of an unchanged stimulus on different population
samples, the effectiveness of the same stimulus on different populations can
be quantified.
FIG. 34 depicts an alternative form of the cumulative hard copy record 1018
dispensed by the response unit described herein. In the embodiment of the hard
copy record designed for use in market research, a mailing piece, such as a
post card is dispensed by the response unit. According to a preferred embodiment,
the printer of the response units in shoppers' homes described in connection
with FIGS. 1, 3-6, 8 and 26 is adapted to accommodate and print on a card capable
of being mailed under bulk mailing regulations, whereby the card requires no
postage by the sender, the postage being paid by the addressee or in this instance
the advertiser.
One side of the record 34-B bears address 1035, which is the address of the
organization undertaking the research, which can include tabulation and analysis
of all of the records collected from shoppers. In the top left hand corner the
numbered response unit 1036 identifies the shopper or user through the response
unit. Each response unit is registered in the name of an identified individual.
The reverse side 34-A of the post card can take the form shown, including the
heading "Identification" 1030, a column headed "Advertisement" 1031 and a heading
"Product" 1032. The stimuli or advertisements under the heading 1031 are numbered
and listed in group 1033. The products under heading 1032 and promoted in said
advertisements are grouped under 1034. For instance, the decision to request
a coupon redeemable upon the purchase of tomato soup was prompted by TV-commercial
No. 47; the decision to request a coupon with a discount on an airline ticket
was prompted by the printed advertisement No. 56. It is a simple matter for
the sponsor of a promotion to indicate the number of the commercial or advertisement
in the commercial or advertisement by a number, letter or other symbol. This
enables the organization analyzing the marketing data to determine the source
of the stimulus, e.g. TV-station, radio station, or print publication, as well
as to relate the purchasing decisions to the time factor, i.e. the date and
the part of the day during which the stimulus or stimuli appeared. Date and
time can be printed by well known means added to the printer of the response
unit. Thus, the comparative effects of differing stimuli during different parts
of the day can be determined. Such a capability would be of interest in the
event a retailer cooperates with a manufacturer in a test market. In such a
case the redeemed coupons which can be coded or otherwise identified, can be
tabulated and the period elapsed between the time of coupon receipt and use
can be measured, including the diminishing rate of redemption over measured
time periods.
If desired and to allow shoppers to express their reactions accurately, provisions
can be made on the card to indicate that the buying decision was the result
of cumulative effect of several stimuli for the same product. In that instance,
the consumer would check off a space, marked "cumulative", or even identify
two or more stimuli by entering identification information.
The above described hard copy record can have the configuration of a normal
post card with return address and a bulk mail permit appearing on one side,
the other side being available for a listing of the type described and including,
when desirable, space for advertising or promotional messages. Such messages
can be printed by the dispenser or directed by the instructional signals controlling
the printer. The said record can have other configurations and can also, by
itself, constitute or comprise a discount coupon or cash voucher. In order to
ensure the surrendering of said record to a retail outlet or other organizer
of the research program, the record can contain a notation that, upon surrender,
the shopper will be entitled to receive value, which may be a discount, cash,
free samples, etc. According to a preferred method, the said cumulative record
is exchanged by a shopper for a new matrix at the same time the paper tape which
serves as the matrix for the coupons must be replaced. Preferably, the matrices
for the individual coupons and the cumulative record are inserted into the response
unit at the same time. Normally, the matrix for the composite record has a number
of spaces on the side shown in FIG. 34-A equal to the number of coupons 1008
comprising the coupon matrix tape.
The value of the incentives described and intended to induce shoppers to purchase
the promoted products can be varied by the instructional signals and can range
from cents off to larger discounts, including 100% discounts, i.e. free samples.
The electronic signals controlling the dispenser units also can control inhibiting
or blocking means which prevent the receipt of certain electronic signals not
intended for the owners of such dispensers. Using well known techniques, the
receiving means in the dispenser unit include means to selectively permit or
inhibit the reception of coded electronic signals, thus distinguishing between
different signal streams. As an example, a dispenser is provided with means
to accept the receipt of a plurality such as six distinct streams of coded electronic
instructional signals and to reject all others. The sender of said electronic
signals, by including the appropriate coded signal instructions, can select
the types of information to be conveyed by said signals and accepted by the
dispenser unit. Accordingly, information regarding unwanted or excluded products
is not received by the dispenser and no coupons regarding these products are
printed. In this manner, the promoter of products can focus said promotional
activities on targeted audiences and can avoid the dispensing of coupons carrying
value consideration to individuals believed not to have a need for said products.
It will be obvious that, using the above system and methods, a sponsor can ensure
maximum efficiency of promotional efforts by adapting the dispensing of tokens
such as discount coupons and free sample coupons to those shopper groups, including
demographic, psychographic and other groups, most responsive to the promoter's
sales strategy.
In another embodiment of the methods described, the stimulus, e.g. a radio commercial,
is automatically identified in the following manner without input by the shopper.
Concurrently with the transmission of the commercial message, electronic instructional
signals are transmitted to the response units which convey an identification
of the radio commercial. The electronic signals direct the printer to print
an identifying reference element on the discount coupons as well as on the cumulative
record. The said instructional signals can be coded and combined with signals
conveying purchase inducements or scoring instructions for computing the value
of a prize awarded for answering a question or having made a successful prediction.
In another application of the invention, a marketer can measure the counteracting
effect of a stimulus presented by said marketer. For instance, following a competitor's
advertisement, a marketer can expose a sample population to a stimulus specifically
designed to blunt or overcome the effect of the competitive advertisement. The
marketer can measure the effectiveness of said stimulus in the face of competitive
efforts.
In the practice of the invention, an entire family, as well as individual members
of household consisting, say of father, mother and 4 children 17, 12, 8 and
5 years of age, can all be sampling units. The older members of the family can
be participants in contests, such as game shows or prediction of the outcome
of sports events and can receive coupons. Challenges designed for younger children
and educational programs can offer awards in the form of coupons on different
toys or food items wanted by children. Each member of the family, including
the five year old, has a personal identification code entered by the individual
at the time of selecting the preferred item.
The coupons dispensed to each individual are either redeemed by said individual
or are turned over to the family head, the family shopper or other designated
person. The coupons requested, as compiled on the cumulative record, reflect
as a minimum each person's desire to receive the selected item. Although some
of the coupons, such as those dispensed to children, may not be redeemed once
the family shopper has entered the store, valuable information as to each person's
desires is collected by the promoters of these programs and can be followed
by promotions targeted with rifleshot precision.
A determination of the demographic or psychographic characteristics of a population
becomes difficult or even meaningless in areas having mixed populations. In
such areas, a market test can be replaced by a sampling unit consisting of a
family or even an individual to whom promotions can be directed. The findings
of such a test can then be used as probability samples in projection and in
multistage sampling. Each household member can be provided with a PIN-number
or other identification which is entered when specifying a product coupon. The
method described can be useful when it is intended to experiment with a new
method of merchandising to a narrowly defined market segment.
The invention enables advertisers to directly measure and quantify the immediate
impact of advertisements and promotions, as well as their diminishing effect
over time. Furthermore the initial and lasting effect of a single aspect or
feature of an advertisement or promotion can be quantified. The effect of even
slight modifications can thus be measured.
In a preferred application of the invention to market research, an advertiser
or promoter arranges for a single insertion of an advertisement in a single
newspaper; no other advertisement, broadcast commercial or other stimulus is
presented in the market area served by said newspaper. By means of the techniques
described, the effect of said stimulus can be measured in terms of any desired
units of elapsed time or in terms of other discrete, controlled variables. For
example, if said advertisement appears in a morning newspaper, the number of
requested and redeemed coupons can be tabulated for, say the first twelve hour
period following the appearance of the advertisement. The cumulative record
compiled in the response units indicates the time at which a coupon has been
requested, the time of the appearance of the advertisement being known. Alternatively,
the measurements can be twenty-four or forty-eight hours, or it can be a week
or longer.
The said measurements can be made over any desired time periods irrespective
of the cutoff date for coupon redemption. However, a marketer may wish to quantify
the immediate impact of a promotion and may tabulate coupons redeemed by the
end of the following business day.
Similarly the effectiveness and the synergism of a combination or repetition
of stimuli can also be measured both with reference to the number of insertions
(advertisements, commercials, etc) and the number of sources (newspapers, broadcast
stations, etc).
The dispenser normally is provided with means by which individuals enter the
identification or designation of the stimulus which has prompted a buying decision.
In order to test the accuracy of a shopper's continuing recollection, the instructional
electronic signals directing the printer of the dispensing unit to print a product-specific
token, can also convey in coded form the identity or other designation of the
specific stimulus to which individuals have been exposed and the effectiveness
of which is to be tested or measured. A comparison of these two inputs establishes
the strength of the impact, or lack thereof, or the shopper in terms of accurately
recalling the stimulus.
It can be argued that the reason for unredeemed dispensed coupons is related
primarily to the diminishing or overridden effect on the shopper of the initial
advertisement. It may also be contended that most or all of the said sales loss
is likely to be caused by the in-store offer or promotion of a competitive product.
Particularly if the time limit set for claiming the discount or other incentive
is short, not exceeding for example one week or even two days, the likelihood
of a shopper receiving a discount coupon on a competitive product by means other
than in-store couponing in such a short time span is very small. Therefore any
sales loss, as reflected by the difference in the totals of requested coupons
and redeemed coupons will largely be due to in-store promotion and advertising.
By tabulating and analyzing said records, the early and the lasting impact of
an identified advertisement by an identified TV-station, radio station or print
medium can be quantified, along with its vulnerability to competing stimuli.
The invention enables advertisers to directly measure and quantify the immediate
impact of advertisements and the diminishing effect of such advertisements over
time. Furthermore, the initial and lasting effect of a discrete advertisement
and modifications thereof can be quantified.
In a preferred embodiment of applying the invention to market research, an advertiser
arranges for a single insertion of an advertisement in a single newspaper; no
other advertisement, broadcast, commercial or other stimulus appears in the
market area served by said newspaper. By means of the techniques described herein
the results of the single advertisement can be measured over any desired units
of time. For example, if said advertisement appears in a morning newspaper,
the number of requested and redeemed coupons can be tabulated for, say the first
twelve hour period following the appearance of the advertisement. Alternatively
the period chosen can be twenty-four or forty-eight hours, or it can be a week
or a month.
Similarly the immediate and lasting effectiveness of repeated stimuli, such
as broadcast commercials can be measured. The effectiveness and the synergism
of a combination of stimuli can also be measured, both in terms of the number
of insertions (advertisements, commercials, etc) and the number of sources (newspapers,
broadcast stations, billboards, etc).
In a modified version of the method described hereinabove, an organizer or research
firm intends to induce individuals to perform a certain act in consideration
of an inducement, which can be a financial inducement. As an example, an organizer
of a survey may present a stimulus to individuals in their homes. The stimulus
may be an identifiable radio advertisement. Instructional electronic signals
are transmitted on a subcarrier frequency by said radio station to the dispenser
or response units of individuals at remote locations. The act to be performed
by the member of that broadcast audience, i.e. the users of the response units,
can be the completion of a questionnaire, such as a list of questions, or the
selection of items from a listing printed on a post card or other token in accordance
with said electronic signals. The token can be adapted for automated processing
by a research firm or the survey organizer. Upon surrendering said token to
the organizer, the individual who has completed the survey, is entitled to a
reward. Following exposure to the stimulus, respondents receive the questionnaire,
complete the same and surrender it to the organizer at a specified location
to collect their reward in person or by mail. Upon receipt of many such filled-in
questionnaires, a market research firm will be able to analyze the aggregate
results of that survey and report the findings to the organizer of the survey.
It will be obvious that by structuring the survey to meet different objectives,
a great many objects of tabulating, processing and analyzing the survey returns
on the hard copy record may be achieved. The types of stimuli are numerous and
can meet objectives of organizers in the fields of quantitative and qualitative
market research, the teaching of educational courses and the grading of examination
results, conducting televised home shopping programs and many entertainment
programs, such as game shows.
The present method is much more reliable than the so-called diary method currently
used in market research, in that it requires only a single act in response to
a promotional message, i.e. a product selection by touching keyboard buttons.
In the diary approach, the steps required, which are a product selection and
a diary entry, do not automatically follow each other and one step may inadvertently
be omitted. Thus, the diary approach, in which a person intending to purchase
a needed product first selects or clips a coupon and as an independent step,
makes a diary entry is a two-step process. It is replaced by the present method,
in which the shopper by requesting a product-specific coupon performs only one,
and much less cumbersome, act.
The invention permits generating a household by household data base quantifying
the effect of stimuli under varying circumstances of promotion. By tabulating
and comparing coupons requested and redeemed under conditions of controlled
variables, singly or grouped, the effectiveness of each such stimulus can be
analyzed and quantified. The requesting by shoppers of coupons having monetary
value and associating the product selection with the identified stimulus replaces
the keeping of diaries and other attempted forms of tracking shoppers' purchasing
decisions. Variables whose impact on shoppers could not be quantified heretofore
on a single household basis, include purchase incentives, frequency and timing
of stimuli, singly or in combination. Such assessments are made possible by
the present invention.
The method described permits a very direct and focused quantitative analysis
of the effectiveness of a stimulus. This is achieved by limiting the incentive
to a single one, such as a discount on a movie ticket, and presenting the stimulus
through a single source, say one newspaper advertisement. By avoiding the fuzziness
introduced by offering incentives on different products and therefore of different
degrees of interest, a clearly identified, single incentive permits an unequivocal
assessment of the impact of a specific stimulus.
The
method permits a sharply focused analysis of a single stimulus on a homogeneous
population. An example of an ideal statistical measurement situation would be
the exposure of the residents of a retirement
home to a newspaper advertisement for a denture adhesive, wherein the original
purchase, use and replacement of the product can be monitored.
It is to be understood that the above
described embodiments of the invention are illustrative only, and that modifications
thereof may occur to those skilled in the art. Accordingly, this invention is
not to be regarded as limited to the embodiments disclosed herein, but is to
be limited only as defined by the appended claims.
Comments